A chalk and cheese argument.
#ashokkkantha: Just because the Taj Mahal & Lal Qila were built, these somehow absolve the Mughals of the centuries of brutalities against the #Hindus? This is recorded by their own historians.
Do read up on that bloody period of India's history. 1/n
2/n Now, certain Western historians have taken it upon themselves to portray Aurangzeb as a benevolent monarch. But read this, in Mughal historians' own words:
India was prosperous well before the advent of the Mughals. Until 1000 AD, India accounted for ⅓ of the world's GDP. It's erroneous to state that India's GDP grew only after the onslaught of the Mughals.
Nobody's writing them off but we need to acknowledge the #barbarism.
3/n 👆
4/n Now, with a population of over 230 million in India — and steadily growing — they are, above all, #Indians.
Who wants to construe them as separate? Certain elements within their own echelons do. You can wholly #integrate only if you yourselves want to. That's the hope.
@threadreaderapp unroll
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I can name quite a few; but #GopinathMohanty, whom my parents and I have translated, is just as great, and, in many senses, greater. We need to be cautious before passing carte blanche judgement against #Indianwriters. I've read &/or taught all the novelists below save Lovecraft.
#CSLewis and #JRRTolkien taught my father at Christ Church, Oxford. Arthur Conan Doyle and Jules Verne certainly don't bat in the same league as Chekov. And to put Jonathan Swift in here? How's that? #GopinathMohanty is in the league of #Tolstoy, #Dostoevsky, #Dickens & #Hardy.
As well, I've pretty much read the bulk of the writings of Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Dickens and Hardy. And, to this list of #greats, I could add two or three dozen European novelists, but let me add #GeorgeEliot: #GopinathMohanty is as brilliant & as trenchantly incisive as her.
Modiji's forefathers have not built a single monument worth showcasing to the world? Hindu temple srchitecture, with its 1000s of ancient temples & forts, is world renowned for its extraordinary beauty.
I wonder which planet this bigoted person inhabits.