James Clayton Profile picture
Aug 24, 2023 15 tweets 7 min read Read on X
Today I’m going to begin to describe how the Organization of #Ukrainian Nationalists, (#OUN) progressed from publishing antisemitic articles in its theoretical journal, Rozbudova Natsii (Building the Nation) to genocidal incitement, from 1928 (left image) to 1941 (right image).
Rozbudova Natsii, #4, 1928.  (author’s comments in bracketed text)  Contents  1.	D. Andrievsky – Steps towards construction 2.	Jacquito Trezziono – a (sympathetic) Philosophical Political Assessment of Fascism 3.	Mykola Stsiborskyi – Echo 4.	Dr. Volodymyr Galan – How to understand Americanization 5.	I. Stobar – The Imponderable (an argument against rationalism) 6.	E. Konovalets – For a history of the Ukrainian Sich Rifleman in the Ukrainian Revolution  7.	Official Notifications  8.	Official Business of the OUN  Chronicles (of Ukrainians)  9.	Ukrainians in the USSR 10.	Under Polish rule 11.	...
Lviv, June July 1941.   Ukrainian People! --Until now, we have been operating underground. There we prepared for the harvest and repelled the attacks of the enemy who wanted to destroy us and You. Now we ascend. We are starting the armed struggle.  The Moscow prison of peoples -- the USSR is collapsing. The leadership of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists announced on all Ukrainian lands the INDEPENDENT UKRAINIAN STATE.  But this Independence must be defended in battles.  By order of Stepan Bandera, on the order of the Regional Command of the OUN, the first columns of fighters - sol...
How was the #Holocaust in #Ukraine ideologically prepared? How did demands for an 'independent' Ukrainian state lead to its destruction by German #imperialism? Due to the large body of evidence, we will divide our exposé. Here we deal with the period 1928 to Spring 1933.
Rozbudova Natsii Masthead, 1928, #1.
Ukrainian Nationalists welcome Nazi military parade. The banner reads, "Slava Bandera" in Ukrainian, and "Cheers to the German Volk... "
The OUN had been preparing itself ideologically to commit genocide and ethnic cleansing in Ukraine since 1928. These preparations began in the first issue of R.N. which came out openly against democracy, against the Soviet Union and socialism. Our Position. 1928 #1.  He criticizes the older nationalist generation  "These are the remnants of either underground political work under the burden of the Tsarist regime, or the remnants of the socialist and democratic psychosis that gripped Europe in the 19th century, or the offspring of the parliamentary system of the former Austrian Empire, or the result of the hypnosis of the Moscow-Tatar satrapy, which occupied one sixth of the globe , and the red imperialism of Moscow, which is competing for mastery over the whole world. All our existing ideologies and allegiances have their ro...
The OUN’s opposition to ‘demo-liberalism’ and ‘humanitarianism’ was consciously based on a philosophical rejection of reason and the Enlightenment. Rozbudova’s fascist, anti-socialist politics, and its genocidal schemes, sprung from the same rotten philosophical soil as Nazism.
I. Stobar – Imponderable, 1928#4  "Rationalism, as a method of knowing, that is - materialism, as a worldview, brought many disasters to modern civilization and greatly devastated the soul of the modern European. But - "everything passes." The wave that carried them to the level of the philosophy of the 19th century had to break. Nowadays, the funeral bells for these systems, which were so recently praised, toll more than dithyrambs and hymns to their truth. Nevertheless, for a long time, their influences, the beliefs they fostered, and the inattention caused by them to the i...
Stobar. Demoliberalism as Ideology. 1928.#10-11 "Disregarding the division of society into orthogonal groups and rejecting hierarchy, they imagine humanity as composed of atoms -- UNITS. When they consider themselves a nation, or an artificially created class, then again for them it is just the sum of components, which differs from humanity only in the number of atoms... Demanding freedom and the right to self-determination is only a long-term consequence of the principle of the will of an individual. It is clear what the demo-liberals favor: the cornerstone of their ideology is the eq...
In 1928 #3, E. Onatskyi’s infamous ‘On Fascism’ appeared. He compared Ukrainian nationalism and Italian fascism, but declared that Ukrainians must work hard to build a state before they can call themselves ‘fascists.’ The article is full of praise for Italian #fascist youth. "This bunch of energetic young people, armed at first only with ardent love and indomitable energy, is steered by the hand of an unusual organizer and leader; Mussolini..."  "Many Ukrainian nationalists began to call themselves fondly Ukrainian fascists and sought support from Italian fascists. They did not see that between Ukrainian nationalism and Italian fascism there is an impassable chasm that can be filled only by time and stubborn hard work. Italian fascism has something in common with Ukrainian nationalism, that it is also, above all, clearly expressed nationalism. Bu...
1928 #12, a fascinating article, ‘Ukrainization of Ukraine’ attacks the original, #Bolshevik nationalities policy of support to national minority cultures, the policy of ‘Korenizatsiya.’ I will discuss this article at length as it exposes the reactionary basis of racial politics. Chronicle: In Soviet Ukraine. 'Ukrainization' of UKR  If you take a close look at everything that the Ukrainian Soviet press has recently reported, we must say that, although the results of the  five-year-work are significant, especially noticeable in the cultural field, they are not yet satisfactory and It is very far from what was promised by the government the beginning of the Ukrainization trend.  It must be stated that, on based on statistical comparisons of the Communist Party of Ukraine, which in in the beginning it was almost purely Muscovite - in the Russian language -  produced a ...
Reviewing mid-1920s #Soviet statistics, nationalists were forced to admit the successes of the ‘Ukrainization’ policy. The article exposes as a lie the Ukrainian nationalist assertion that the early Bolshevik policy oppressed Ukrainians. (Stalinist policies, certainly later did.) "From the detailed statistical comparisons of Ya. Mariasik in the article "Party Cadres" ("Communist" from November 19, 1927), it is particularly clear how the Ukrainization of the very top of the party and all lower representatives is progressing. The number of Ukrainians in the personnel, which include heads of regional branches of Professional Unions, managers of medium-sized enterprises of the All-Ukrainian Council of the People's Economy, rectors of Higher Educational Institutions and heads of all technical schools, heads of RVCs, secretaries of RKPs, heads of ...
The Bolshevik policy of 'Ukrainization' was NOT about ‘creating a Ukraine for Ukrainians only’ but about raising the cultural and political level of #Ukrainian peasants and workers, part of a struggle for a world #socialist #republic enabling the full participation of Ukrainians.
M. Pavlovich. Ukraine as the Object of International Counter-revolution. Winnipeg, 1922. Cover.
"In comparison, in the Republic of Soviets, careful and fraternal attention is paid not only to more or less large, but to the smallest national units. Honest Ukrainians, sincerely desiring the national and cultural revival of Ukraine, have come to believe that only the Soviet government can fulfill the role of liberator of Ukraine from all kinds of oppression, to the end.  Two or three decades will pass and we will see how, along with the expansion of public education in the Soviet Republic, along with the opening of thousands and thousands of schools, evening courses, academies, etc....
R.N.'s 'Ukrainization' article is the first of many in which ‘Jews’ are counted as separate from Ukrainians using statistical information from the Soviet Union. The nationalists were very concerned to quantify the ‘Jewish problem’ which they qualified using antisemitic slanders. Statistics demonstrating that the majority of the Peoples Courts in Ukraine consisted of Ukrainian officials, while the majority of officials of the ‘Peoples Commissariat of Justice’ (Наро́дный комиссариа́т юсти́ции СССР) and the prosecutors and trainees of the НКІО were 80% composed of Jewish people.  This disparity was not the fault of the early Soviet government, but the inevitable demographic effect from the previous, socially backwards society, which the revolutionary state had inherited. It takes a decade or more to train leading legal officials, perhaps more in a society struggling agai...
1929 #3-4: “Russian-Jewish Domination and the role of Russian culture in Soviet Ukraine” by 'V. Bogush'. It is an extended complaint using demographic statistics, that although Ukrainians are a majority of the population, power and influence in Ukraine rest with Jews and Russians "In Ukraine, Ukrainians are in a particularly difficult situation, where Ukrainians comprise 42.79% of the urban population (2,5 million) and as many as 87.45% of the rural population (20 million), while Russians make up 25% of the urban population (1,3 million) and only 5.6% of the rural (1.3 million) and Jews 22% (1,2 million) of the urban and only 1.59% of the rural (355 thousand). The rest of the population consists of such minorities as Germans, Poles, Moldovans, Greeks, Bulgarians, Tatars, Czechs, Belarusians, Gypsies, etc., mainly in villages (about 1.5 million) and in small num...
1929 #8-9 “Jewry, Zionism and Ukraine” by Yuri Milyanich: Jews are the “enemies of the Ukrainian independent national idea” and “In the fight against Jewry, which is hostile to us in every respect, we must develop the most advantageous forms for solving the Jewish question.”
Y. Mylianych. Jewry, Zionism and Ukraine. "The Jewish issue is one of the most difficult problems in Ukrainian politics. Unfortunately, neither Ukrainian journalism nor Ukrainian active politics pay attention to that problem. Nevertheless, the reality remains the reality: more than two million Jewish people live on the lands of Ukraine, which is a foreign and, in addition, mostly hostile body in our national organism. It is not necessary to enumerate all the harm and evil that the Jews did to our recent liberation cause. This is how it was done throughout history and this is how it is ...
"In the fight against Jewry, which is hostile to us in every respect, we must develop our own system and the most advantageous forms for solving the Jewish question. The problem is difficult and, thanks to its neglect, rather dark from the Ukrainian side. But it must be solved."
1930 #9-10. Mykola Stsiborskyi, later author of the 1940 OUN-M constitution publishes “Jewry and Ukraine” in which he argues for assimilation of “Jewry” subordinate to Ukrainian state goals, in order to re-start capitalist social relations, after the future collapse of the USSR
Mykola Stsiborskyi: Ukrainian nationalism and Jewry.   "The general issue of minority policy in Ukraine includes the problem of the relationship of the future national government to Jewry -- a problem, complex, acute, and confusing... But we will not be mistaken when we say that the majority of our parties and in their programs and in their practical policy, they do not pay due attention to it, leaving its specification for the future. What is true, (in most party programs we find a mention of the so-called "minority policy", from the general direction of which one can get a ...
"First of all, it should be noted that the mechanical inclusion of the Jewish problem in the general minority policy in Ukraine and, in general, an attempt to build that policy on the same basis, without differentiating those minorities into separate components by nationality (Muscovites, Poles, Jews, Germans, etc.), is a mistake and one that hides a lot of danger. A. it is because these components of the total mass of minorities are sharply different - both in their number, and in the degree of their political and socio-economic weight, and finally - in the nature of their fundamental...
1932 #1-2 Mitsiuk's antisemitic account of ‘Pre-revolutionary Jewish trade relations’ accusing ‘Jewry’ of monopolizing trade and exploiting the peasants of the Hutsul region. A 1943 Krakivski Visti article would later rejoice that ‘there were no more Jews in the Hutsul region.’
Professor O. Mitsiuk. Jewish economics in Ukraine during the period of reaction - 1882-1917.
"those "traders" (as he calls the Jews) have already settled over 509 plots of land... and to investigate, he said, the estates of the peasants, and even then it will turn out that a third, a half, or even a greater half of the peasants no longer have any land ownership, because all their land has fallen into the hands of these "traders". Peasants live only in a barn, and the land is rented from "merchants". Neither cattle, nor grain, nor hay belong to them, although they walk around all that.. The entire economic inventory of such a "merchant" i...
Rozbudova published Mitsiuk’s incitement in every issue for two years, and then issued the articles as a book. What is clear is that well before the Nazis constituted a mass movement, Ukrainian nationalists had developed clear plans for a ‘Ukraine for Ukrainians only.' 1941 OUN Leaflet: "Ukraine - for Ukrainians!"  "Long live an Independent Ukraine! Beat the 'Katsaps' (pejorative for Russians) and every internationalist bastard."
I will follow this up in the coming weeks with an examination of OUN's ideology into the 1930s, after the Nazi seizure of power, and how fascist ideology was openly expressed in the Ukrainian Canadian press of that time. Stay tuned.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with James Clayton

James Clayton Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JamesClay1917

Mar 16
🧵There is a political split in the petty bourgeois Palestinian leadership, and some elements are desperate to try to cover it up and silence debate about it, using moralizing identity politics to prevent anyone from elaborating a political analysis of it.
Palestinian journalist Motaz has issued a filthy statement blaming Palestinian resistance for Israel's genocidal actions. He has seemingly aligned himself with Fatah, just as the imperialist powers are promoting the quislings of Fatah as 'legitimate' Palestinian leaders.
Canadian Foreign Minister Melanie Joly flew to Israel this week to meet with Netanyahu, and then to Ramallah to be photographed, along with Zionist MP Ya'ara Sacks, with Fatah leader Mahmoud Abbas. Fatah is being prepared by imperialism to suppress the Palestinian resistance.
Read 7 tweets
Mar 5
Imperialism lurches toward escalation because there simply are no more young Ukrainian men to draft into its war against Russia. There was a massive decline in Ukrainian births after the dissolution of the USSR, and most Ukrainian men aged 20 to 35 are either dead, or fled.
Ukraine has a massive surplus - of babushkas, due to WWII and its aftermath. Note the approaching third demographic crisis. The murder by imperialist war of most of the young males now threatens the very existence of Ukrainian people. Image
The Ukrainian population bulge in the graph represents Ukrainians born during the Soviet period. The Soviet Union produced lots of Ukrainians. Capitalist restoration, Ukrainian nationalism and fascism have, when combined, murdered more Ukrainians. Image
Read 4 tweets
Mar 2
🧵The Israelis and imperialists are deliberately starving Palestinians in #Gaza, just as the Nazis developed the ‘Hunger Plan’ to starve the Jews and the Soviet working class in WWII. If Zionism looks like Nazism, it’s because Zionists are copying #Nazi policies to conquer Gaza.
Image
Image
Fact: the State of Israel has decided on a policy of #starvation against the population of #Gaza. The openly genocidal statements of Israeli leaders are a simple matter of public record. They are criminal self-indictments, which cannot be reinterpreted post facto, or taken back.


https://shorturl.at/coJQ8
https://shorturl.at/coJQ8
https://shorturl.at/coJQ8
https://shorturl.at/coJQ8
Retired #IDF General Giora Eiland described this plan in November 2023. “Severe epidemics in the southern Strip will bring victory closer and reduce fatalities among IDF soldiers.” Starving people are too weak to fight their occupiers. (See alt text)
archive.ph/DmwAp
Compare Eiland’s justification with those of the Nazis for their starvation plans.  Eiland: “There is no reason why the Hamas leaders won’t surrender if the population lacks water and fuel and epidemics come and endanger their family members. As long as Israeli captives are held, don’t speak to us about humanitarian aspects,”  Alfred Rosenberg, key architect of the Holocaust: “We see absolutely no reason for any obligation on our part to feed the Russian people with the products of that surplus-territory. We know that this is a harsh necessity, bare of any feelings.”
Read 17 tweets
Feb 2
🧵Today we recall the Revisionist #Zionist movement of Vladimir Jabotinsky, political ancestor of the criminal Netanyahu. Like the the Ukrainian nationalists, the dependency of the Zionist bourgeois and petty bourgeois on world imperialism drove them towards fascism and genocide. Vladimir Jabotinsky
Jewish workers and peasants had an alternative to Zionism – revolutionary socialism. The conquest of power by the working class created the basis to destroy antisemitism, which arose historically, and can only be destroyed by workers acting consciously in the historical process. Bolshevik Jewish newspaper, Der Emes (The Truth.) Lenin "It is not the Jews who are the enemies of the working people. The enemies of the workers are the capitalists of all countries. Among the Jews there are working people, and they form the majority. They are our brothers, who, like us, are oppressed by capital; they are our comrades in the struggle for socialism. Among the Jews there are kulaks, exploiters and capitalists, just as there are among the Russians, and among people of all nations. The capitalists strive to sow and foment hatred between workers of different faiths, differ...
1921. Jabotinsky made a secret pact with Maxim Slavinsky, ambassador of Ukrainian pogromist Simon Petliura, to send Zionist police with a 15,000 strong Ukrainian nationalist army, backed by France, to attack the Soviet Union, moving Jews out of Soviet Ukraine. The plan failed. Ovruch Pogrom (February 1919). Photographer unknown. Wikimedia  https://archive.ph/HIAgq   "After independent Ukraine was defeated by the Red Army, Petliura found refuge in Poland, which had fought against Soviet Russia. He planned to return to Ukraine at the head of an army of exiled expatriates. Jabotinsky suggested that Petliura enlist units of Jewish soldiers. Clearly Jabotinsky's rabid anti-Communism was one reason behind the proposal. Publicly, he rationalized the offer by claiming that the Jewish divisions in Petliura's army would defend the Jewish population from possible pogro...
Read 23 tweets
Dec 28, 2023
🧵To hear Zionists, the Oct 7th Palestinian uprising against illegal Israeli occupation is akin to ‘original sin.’ Each act of #Zionist barbarism is justified by the ‘bloodguilt’ of #Hamas. They are copying #Nazi propaganda techniques used against the Poles and Great Britain. 'Documents of Polish Bloodguilt' was a 459 pg document of atrocity propaganda produced by the Nazis in 1940 to retroactively justify the Nazi invasion of Poland on September 1, 1939 and Nazi crimes against the Poles and the Jews.  it can be downloaded from the Internet Archive at the following link:  https://ia902907.us.archive.org/2/items/nslarchiv_201910/B%C3%BCcher/B%C3%BCcher_Bis%201945/Auswaertiges%20Amt%20-%20Dokumente%20polnischer%20Grausamkeit%20%281940%2C%20459%20S.%2C%20Scan%29.pdf
On Sept 3 1939, Germans in #Bydgoszcz Poland attacked a Polish military barracks, coordinated by German military intelligence. In response, the Polish majority of the town rose up and violently resisted. Approximately 400 German civilians and soldiers were killed over two days. llustrierter Beobachter Nr. 37/1939, S. 1428. As cited in: Arani, Miriyam Y. Fotografische Selbst-und Fremdbilder von Deutschen und Polen im Reichsgau Wartheland, pg 205. Verlad Dr. Kovac, Berlin. 2008
Historian Ian Kershaw writes: “For German propaganda, the attacks on ethnic Germans were exploited as an apparent justification for a policy of 'ethnic cleansing' that had surpassed in its first days anything that could be regarded as retaliation.” (see Alt text for full quote) Image: Illustrierter Beobachter 39/1939, S. 1498 as cited in Arani, Miriyam Y. Fotografische Selbst-und Fremdbilder von Deutschen und Polen im Reichsgau Wartheland, pg 206. Verlad Dr. Kovac, Berlin. 2008 The complete Kershaw quote:  "For German propaganda, the attacks on ethnic Germans were exploited as an apparent justification for a policy of 'ethnic cleansing' that had surpassed in its first days anything that could be regarded as retaliation… Terrible though these atrocities were, they were more or less spontaneous outbursts of hatred that took place in the context of panic and fea...
Read 20 tweets
Sep 25, 2023
Canada's 'Nazi scandal' has been sitting in plain sight for decades. In 2010, the #Ukrainian Canadian Congress tried do draw a big equals sign between soldiers and others killed fighting the Nazis, and Ukrainian #Nazi collaborators who killed them. #Hunka
ucc.ca/2010/11/11/ukr…
Image
The 'First Division of the Ukrainian National Army' referred to above is the 14th #WaffenSS #Galizien Division. Below is their commanding officer, Friz Freitag. Fritz kept a diary, reducing his mass murder to such banalities as "114 prisoners taken, 283 Jews shot." Image
The Canadian state in the 1940s and 50s WANTED #Nazis, to go after #socialists in the working class. Upon arrival, that's just what the Nazis did. They attacked workers meetings across the country. On October 8th, 1950 they bombed Toronto's #Ukrainian Labour Temple .
Winnipeg Tribune, October 17, 1949
Image
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(