Helen Andrews Profile picture
Sep 8, 2023 10 tweets 9 min read Read on X
Thanks, @edwest, for highlighting the chapter of BOOMERS on white flight. There were many anecdotes of school integration in DC that I included in early drafts of the book but later cut for reasons of space. Here are a few. /1 edwest.co.uk/p/the-great-am… x.com/edwest/status/…
“People have asked me how my white children and colored children got along together… When the colored children first came over, my white children treated them as guests, and they would go and get them desks and chairs and give them pencils and look at them as if to say, ‘Are you all right?’ That was the general attitude, that they were hosts and hostesses to the colored children. But it got to the point where no white child could swim in the swimming pools of the city or play on the playgrounds. You ride by them and you don’t see any white children… I think there was force exerted. Threats, and I think there was some violence. I don’t know personally, except the children said, ‘We can’t go over there, we get beat up.’”Image
“During the first year of integration, we had girl cheerleaders. But during some of the basketball games in the McKinley gym, where it is very crowded, there were so many remarks, and so on, made to the girls, that I called a meeting of the mothers of the girls and told them that I would no longer take the full responsibility if they let their daughters go there.

The mothers said they would take responsibility. I furnished them with passes to the game, the mothers and fathers. And then there was one incident in which the mothers and fathers removed the girls quickly from an incident that didn’t amount to too much, but which might have, which frightened them. And then they came to me and said, ‘We want to do away with the girls cheerleaders,’ and I ended it.”

“Would you describe the incident?”

“I don’t think I can describe all of it. It was between the players, and the girls were sitting on the sidelines nearby, and they began stampeding onto the floor, and it became a little of a frightening incident.”Image
Image
“I asked why they were singing in the hall. Of course, the reason was that they had nothing to do and therefore were entertaining themselves. Then I asked why they did not take into consideration the fact that they were disturbing the rest of the school, certainly along that corridor… One of the boys said to me, ‘But Miss Fowler, you are fussing at us, you are picking on us because we are colored.’ Well, frankly it made me a bit angry… I said, ‘No, I am not picking on you because you are colored, because I would not do that anyway, but it does seem to me that if you object to being picked on because you are colored then you should act as the white children do.’

“The next day I was called to the office of the principal and the principal asked me if I knew a doctor, I am sorry to say I cannot tell you his name… He said he was from Howard University. I said, I am sorry, I do not know the gentleman. He said, well, it was reported that you had spoken to this group of boys in the hall, and he said: ‘The doctor agrees that if the boys need scolding they should be corrected, but that it does not necessarily have to be done in that manner.’”

“One day I was going to lunch and as I went in the opposite direction, I passed a hall that leads along the side of the auditorium and it dips like a roller coaster. In that hall, going up and down in a trash cart that is on wheels were 3 or 4 or 5 colored boys riding up and down in the trash cart… It was very noisy and I started after them, and I am sure I did not take more than four steps before I remembered what had happened to me before so I said, No, Katherine, you just let them go and let the principal of the school or somebody else who is supposed to do it in the hall take care of it. You go on and eat your lunch.

I hate to say this, because in all the years of teaching I have never considered that I should neglect my duty in such a fashion before.”Image
Image
Image
Image
“I found her very much upset and very excited. It seemed that she and one of the student clerks in the building had gone down the long hall that would lead along T Street, for example, and then down Second to the gym. They were going to a game. In the process of going to the game she had been assaulted by one of the colored boys. It was not that day. It had happened the day before and she was extremely agitated about it, because she had been requested—I presume it was request, that is a presumption on my part—not to say anything to the police about it. Her first reaction, of course, since it was late in the evening, was that it should be reported to the police, and she had been asked not to.”Image
“Would you be good enough to tell us how many illegitimate births we had in 1955 in the District of Columbia under 15 years of age?”
“There were 86 recorded.”
“How were they divided as between whites and non-whites?”
“There were 5 white and 81 nonwhite.”

“I have calculated here the number of illegitimate births in the categories of 15, 16, 17, 18, and 19 years of age. I get 95 white and 1,089 colored, is that correct?
“That is correct.”Image
Image
“The standards which existed in Division 1 and Division 2 [white and nonwhite] prior to integration of the schools, you stated that they had the same curriculum and the same requirements for teachers…”
“I said the same curriculum, the same allotment per pupil for textbooks and supplies, the same textbook list….”
“The same salaries?”
“That is right.”
“Efforts were made to provide equal facilities?”
“Very definitely.”

“What was the difference?”
“Here I am having to generalize where I think generalizations are a bit dangerous. Customarily in colored schools there was a more rigid, almost militaristic discipline than existed in the white schools. In the white schools the emphasis was more to teach the child to develop habits of control, not where he had to walk step by step with everybody else all the time. That difference, for example, created a problem integration, because when the colored students got into this other type of school many of them had not had the buildup.”Image
Image
“The former assistant principal, Miss Stewart, informed the teachers that stealing had become so bad that we were instructed not to report any more stealing to her.” Image
“The Easterner [the student paper] had an editorial one time after integration with the heading ‘Hands Off’?”
“Yes. That did not necessarily mean white girls were being touched by colored boys, but we felt that the girls were being manhandled in the corridors in a way that was not uplifting…

We had a survey in our building of every student. We handed out a mimeographed questionnaire asking what the student—it was unsigned and returned—what the student felt were the problems they were facing as a result of integration… That particular issue dealt with boys who were manhandling, shall we say.”
“How did they manhandle?”
“Well, they were touching certain parts, certain areas that one wouldn’t expect to be touched in public.”
“Was it an obscene handling? Was it vulgar, lewd, or give some better indication please. Was it suggestive?”
“Yes, definitely.”
“What portions of the body were they touching, if you can tell us that?”
“I prefer to let you use your own imagination.”Image
Image
I’ll end the thread on that unforgettable phrase, “manhandled in a way that was not uplifting.” More at Ed’s post (for subscribers; surely you are one?). edwest.co.uk/p/the-great-am…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Helen Andrews

Helen Andrews Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @herandrews

Jul 14
“An American Dilemma” is a perfect example of foundation-led social science because Myrdal splashed around so much money to other scholars for “research.”

“When the generosity of the Carnegie Corporation became known… black academics were demanding salaries of $10,000 or more.” Image
Image
Image
Naturally, giving away all that money guaranteed good reviews from the relevant experts.

“As his staff member and confidant Guy Johnson put it, ‘If you hadn't involved all these people and spent all this money … the reception [of the book] might not have been as enthusiastic.’” Image
Gunnar Myrdal originally thought he should have at least one white Southerner read the manuscript, but he couldn’t find a suitably friendly person so he gave up. Image
Image
Read 4 tweets
Jul 9
How do Russians think about their demographic crisis? This author sat in on a lecture in a demography class at a provincial university and got the standard history. The lesson starts with “the Russian Cross,” the graph showing the moment in 1991 when deaths outpaced births. Image
Image
“Already in the 1970s and especially the early 1980s, Soviet demographers began to be concerned with the shrinking population… To prevent the decline, the Soviet state introduced a series of ‘paid motherhood’ policies.” These policies had some success in halting the decline. Image
Image
“And then in 1992 came Gaidar. Do you remember him? He's the guy who told you, go forth and multiply, only at your own expense… In the Soviet Union, the state took partial responsibility for childbearing. And then Gaidar and his cronies came to power.” Births cratered. Image
Read 5 tweets
Jul 8
Great Feminization, Soviet-style: In 1968, demographer Boris Urlanis published a bombshell article, “Save the Men!,” arguing that men were the second sex with higher mortality rates. Since nearly 80% of Soviet doctors were female, he said, it was up to women to save the men. Image
Image
Women were 36 percent of Soviet professionals in 1940, 59 percent in 1980. Universities became majority female in 1976. Technical schools were 57 percent women. “In 1978, 26 percent of Leningrad brides said yes to less-educated grooms; two decades ago only 5 percent did.” Image
Image
The “Save the Men!” phrase became a cultural landmark and prompted a flurry of responses. It even became a movie in 1982. Marfa Petrovna runs a research institute, hates cooking, and bosses her husband around. Can he reclaim his masculinity and avert their divorce? Image
Image
Read 4 tweets
Jul 7
Soviet law is hilarious. A factory manager was imprisoned by the NKVD as a “Trotskyist” and sentenced to a labor camp, but then Yezhov fell and he was one of the political prisoners released. He got his job back—and sued for back pay for the months he was in prison. Successfully. Image
Image
This poor widow with a young daughter deserves legal relief from the bad housemate who is trying to get the house to himself by driving them out with obnoxious behavior, but her husband was an officer in the White Army so the Soviet court will do nothing for her. Image
Misha Dresher lied to get into college, concealing that his parents were “class enemies.” When his secret was revealed, he was sentenced for the crime of “swindling” (financial fraud), later reversed on grounds that Misha had made himself “essentially” a worker by good conduct. Image
Image
Read 4 tweets
Apr 13
Good piece with a simple thesis: The girlboss lifestyle would not exist if it were not massively subsidized.

Cheap immigrant labor to do their cooking, cleaning, and child care; student loans and the whole higher ed sector; email jobs that don’t need to exist; etc.
It’s really very simple. There are two claims here:

1. For a long time, America didn’t have a servant class. Its absence helped to define our unique postwar social order.

Mass immigration changed that. Now we do have a (racially distinct) servant class.

Bad, IMHO.
2. The have-it-all lifestyle of the modern career mom just wouldn’t be possible without that servant class—daycare, DoorDash, etc.

It’s not bad to use those services, but the only reason average middle class families can afford them is because mass immigration made them cheaper.
Read 5 tweets
Mar 28
The thing about decolonization is, every colony in Africa was unique: the white population was small or large, transient or settled; were schools built; was native labor exploited; etc.

Britain tailored independence plans to each specific case—yet the result was always the same.
All the complexities that were pondered in the run-up to independence—the moral claims of various parties, the colony’s unique history, the economic needs of the future state—collapsed before the simple Fanonist logic of white man bad.

Don’t overthink it, is what I’m saying.
“It’s not communism, and it’s not just
sheer racism. It’s race communism. It’s the merging of the two.”

Good podcast on this topic today, Lomez says some wise things:
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(