Thread by @csmaje

Interesting review of my book #NOtoFarmFree from @Jeremy_Williams. A few remarks:

Maybe it’s premature to dismiss a technology that "doesn’t exist yet beyond a single experimental company" but time isn't on our side. What’s clear is that this technology will *always* use... 1/6

https://twitter.com/Jeremy_Williams/status/1701203087908618609

...more supplied primary energy than cultivated plants

Given that per acre yields from agroecological production aren't less than from industrial production, there’s no need to ‘prove’ the former can feed the world... 2/6

...but it’s true it might not mesh with the kind of high-energy supply chains required by cities like Tokyo. Given impending energy constraints, the likelihood is therefore future ruralization. I think the onus is on the ecomodernists to explain how this can be avoided... 3/6

...I explain at length in my book why there’s a kind of Gresham’s law in ag tech, where high-capital/tech/energy approaches chase out low-capital/tech/energy ones... 4/6

...No doubt it’s nice to “reserve the right to say both” low & hi-tech, local & global etc. But just saying it won’t stop the sharp political conflicts now emerging over land & food around the differences between Monbiot’s position & mine, which will likely not yield both... 5/6

I get why some people criticise my ‘No to farm-free’ title, but I stand by it. I explain why in my book & @ . IMO the drive of his book is toward Ch 7 (‘Farmfree’) & its title doesn't lie. I don’t think it will bring the results he hopes for 6/6chrissmaje.com/2023/06/saying…

...to clarify, 'his book' = George Monbiot's 'Regenesis'

@threadreaderapp unroll