Matthew Horwood Profile picture
Sep 13 7 tweets 3 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
Gm, it's day seven of the trial of Freedom Convoy leaders Chris Barber and Tamara Lich.

Ottawa Police Service Sergeant Joanne Pilotte is on the stand again. We are watching two 75 minute long videos this morning.

The first is a press conference with Convoy leaders from the middle of the protest.

Benjamin Dichter is asked by a reporter why politicians are sounding like "tin-pot dictators" when they talk about the Convoy.

Dichter says the truckers have been giving out free food, cleaning up the streets and helping the homeless, while politicians "go on their little Zoom calls and call everybody names."
Image
The organizers are asked about how the government can be kept "accountable" post-COVID.

Dichter tells the story of a single mother who told him for the past two years, she had been depressed and suicidal.

"She saw this, and she said, 'you've given me hope in my life, and I came to Ottawa,' she brought her children, and [the child said], 'mommy, the truckers are going to free us and we're going to have our lives back.'"

Tom Quiggin, a former intelligence officer who helped to protect the Freedom Convoy, responds to the original question by saying he's not sure exactly what can be done to keep government accountable.

"What we're seeing here in Canada, I hope, is the start of a movement which is going to go national, where the politicians are going to have to start looking over their shoulders and say, 'Well, if we do this, what do you what are those guys going to do?'"
The organizers are asked what they think would happen if the police tried to forcibly remove the protestors from Ottawa.

Quiggins responds that if there were a "physical attack" there would be thousands more showing up in peaceful non-compliance.

"That would be such a egregious overstep, in my mind, that it would be a mistake on their part."
The second video is being shown in court. It's another press conference with the convoy leaders.

Dichter starts out by telling the independent media in the room that there is no "fake media" allowed, and the CBC was thrown out for "pushing you around."

(I see some head-shaking from the reporters sitting at the front of the courtroom.)

Dichter says the morale of the protestors on the ground has not changed. He saw two protestors who spoke different languages, but we still able to develop a friendship at a Tim Hortons over their shared cause.

"This is what Canada is supposed to be about."
Dichter expresses anger towards GoFundMe for freezing the protest's funds, calling it "GoFraudMe." He says Bitcoin embodies the principle of freedom and decentralization, as it can't be frozen in the same way as fiat money.

(The convoy received over $1 million in crypto donations.)

He also pushes back against accusations that the Convoy is a white supremacist movement. "I'm Jewish. I have family members that are buried in mass graves in Europe, but I am a white supremacist? This garbage stops," Dichter says.

He also claims the mainstream media will learn "very harsh lessons" for their coverage of the protest.
Quiggins says there has been a 10 day injunction against truckers honking, which is "fine." But he points out that a senior judge from the Superior Court of Canada said the truckers had a lawful right to free expression, both under Common Law and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Quiggins also says the idea that the convoy wants to overthrow the government is "fantasy." He says some groups with different agendas have talked about creating a new government alongside the governor general, but this has "no basis in reality."

(He is likely talking about organizer James Bauder's "memorandum of understanding." Bauder withdrew the MOU halfway through the protest, saying the document was merely meant to raise awareness around mandates.)

Quiggins says the "spin by some of the mainstream media" about the convoy wanting to overthrow the government is "completely inaccurate."
IT'S OVER: We're breaking for lunch. Back at 2:15.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Matthew Horwood

Matthew Horwood Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Matt_HorwoodET

Sep 12
Gm, it's the sixth day of the trial of Tamara Lich and Chris Barber.

Yesterday mostly revolved around whether nine witnesses from Ottawa would be called to testify about the impact the Freedom Convoy had on the city.

Let's see what the judge decided 🧵 Image
We're starting off with deliberations over the admissibility of a 212-page exhibit showing the Facebook page of the Freedom Convoy.

Ottawa police Sergeant Joanne Pilotte is on the stand (again) going over posts from the Freedom Convoy's social media that she screen-capped as part of her investigation.

The process is being done to ensure the documents are established as authentic... But it doesn't make for very exciting live-tweets.
Pilotte is being asked by Crown prosecutor Tim Radcliffe about the "blue lines" in one of the Facebook posts. She explains that those are hyperlinks. (Riveting stuff.)

Pilotte is also asked if she knows who specifically made one post on the Freedom Convoy's Facebook page, and she says she does not.

(We're not going over the specific contents of the posts, and I can't really see them without my 🤓)
Read 20 tweets
Sep 11
Gm, it's day five of the trial of Tamara Lich and Chris Barber.

On Friday, the judge said she was "very unhappy" after the Crown revealed binders of new evidence three days after the trial had begun.

"This should have been done well before the trial," said Justice Heather Perkins-McVey.

Word on the street is that this afternoon, the lawyers for Lich and Barber will argue against allowing nine Ottawa residents and business-owners to testify. 🧵
Image
Defence lawyer Lawrence Greenspon begins by filing the "witness impact statements" of the nine residents.

The Crown instead argues that an overview of the statements should be seen by the judge.

Judge says she does not want to read the statements, as she is concerned that she might mix up this statements with the eventual testimonies of those witnesses.
The judge brings up that none of the witnesses have had direct dealings with the accused, and the Crown agrees.

Greenspon brings up several prior legal decisions and argues that at no point during them did the Crown tend to bring forth victim impact statements during the cases.

He says those statements are always reserved for the sentencing portion of the trial.

Defence adds that the evidence is not "legally relevant" to the case.
Read 19 tweets
Sep 7
Gm, it's day three of the trial of Tamara Lich and Chris Barber.

Ottawa Police Sergeant Joanne Pilotte is testifying today. She will give observations of her investigation into Barber and Lich, specifically their social media activity leading up to and during the Freedom Convoy.

We will also be apparently reviewing five hours of video footage being presented by the prosecution. 🧵
Image
First off, we're reviewing the TikTok account of Chris Barber (BigRed19755), that Pilotte reviewed for her investigation.

In the first video, taken shortly before the police action commenced, Barber warns the protestors that thousands of police officers are on the way and the organizers' Internet might soon "go dark."

"So if this video gets to you, and we go dark all of a sudden, that means you need to use whatever means you can you come to a peaceful protest. You peacefully protest. You come here and you flood the city. I don't give a shit if the entire country of Canada comes to f*cking Ottawa."
Image
In the second video from early February, Barber tells his followers that GiveSendGo is a "trusted platform" to use to fundraise for the Freedom Convoy, and criticizes the previous fundraising platform GoFundMe for freezing the protest funds. He also talks about having shaved his beard.

In the third video from February 7, Barber is "scoping out an area" of Ottawa, and says an intersection near the National Art Gallery "looks lonely."

"It doesn't look like there's anybody here. You think we can fix that?" Barber says.
Read 10 tweets
Sep 6
It's day two of the trial of Tamara Lich and Chris Barber.

We can expect two witnesses today. First up is Operations Support Inspector Russell Lucas with the Ottawa Police Service.

He was the incident Commander during the Freedom Convoy 🧵 Image
Lucas moved into his role as incident commander the first week of Jan. 2022. In that role, he would typically be responsible for overseeing the OPS' staffing, logistics, traffic management for special events like festivals, sporting events and protests.

That month, he was planning "how we were going to respond to and manage the impacts of the impending convoy protest."

The police liaison team and public order unit of the OPS also fell under his command. The PLT's role role, affording to Lucas, was to be a "go-between between the police and the different types of protesters."

Overall, Lucas was trying to "find a balance between facilitating lawful protests," and the managing impacts on the community.
Lucas said on Jan. 21, he believed he was dealing with five different convoys. But by Jan. 28, it was 13 different convoys, which "changed the dynamics" of their planning.

"To try and get a good concept of the true numbers that would be attending was was challenging," he adds.

OPS was trying to calculate numbers based off social media interactions with convoy leaders, talking various police agencies, and reading the Ontario Provincial Police's Hendon Reports.

Lucas says original intelligence indicated there would be up to 100 vehicles per province, but "they greatly exceeded that."
Read 21 tweets
Sep 5
The trial of Freedom Convoy organizers Tamara Lich and Chris Barber begins today in Ottawa.

Dozens of supporters have gathered in front of the Ottawa Courthouse in support of the two.

I'll be live-tweeting (live-Xing?) the court proceedings🧵 Image
Lich and Barber are co-accused of mischief, obstructing police, counselling others to commit mischief and intimidation.

Their trial is expected to last 16 days. Image
We've entered the courtroom, just going over technicalities.

Over the next few weeks, witnesses at the trial will include employees from OC Transpo and Mayor Jim Watson's office, downtown residents and employees, and officers from the Police Liaison Team.
Read 16 tweets
May 18
Former CBC Reporter Marianne Klowak is testifying at the National Citizen's Inquiry in Ottawa.

Klowak said during COVID-19, the rules seemed to "change overnight" at the CBC.

"As a public broadcaster, you'd expect us to be telling you the truth, and we stopped doing that." Image
Klowak, a reporter for over 34 years, said she was blocked from writing certain stories during the pandemic.

These included articles on protests against COVID-19 vaccine mandates, safety concerns about vaccines, and issues with Canadians' reporting of adverse vaccine reactions.
The newsroom Klowak worked at in Manitoba was a "leader in investigative journalism, second only to Toronto," which put out stories that sparked changes at the highest level of government and corporations.

"By the time I left in December 2021, I no longer recognized the CBC."
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(