I attended the @CitizAssembly yesterday as an observer
Along with @iancriminology and Senator Lynn Ruane, we had communicated with the Assembly's secretariat to convey our serious concerns about the dearth of relevant criminal justice & policing expertise heard by the Assembly
My first time observing the Assembly in action, and it was an impressive and inspiring example of deliberative democracy in action
I was very impressed with the structure and procedures governing the presenations and questions
I thought the Chairing was excellent
#CADrugUse
I also had the opportunity to speak informally to a number of members of the Assembly
Unfortunately, our concerns were proven as it seems that some very basic but fundamental parts of Irish and international drug policy have not been explained to the Assembly
I must admit, it was was quite shocking to find that Assembly members have not, in five weekend meeting, had the background and context to the Misuse of Drugs Act 1977 explained to them
Nor, it seems, has the background to the UN's Single Convention been explained
#CADrugUse
It's also not at all clear that the models of regulation being examined by Germany, Malta and Luxembourg for cannabis legalisation have been explained
Given the Assembly will at their next and final meeting be voting on regulatory models – this is a major informational gap
Some of the Qs asked by Assembly members suggests – perhaps unsurprisingly given the onslaught of misinformation from some in the parade of public servants that have dominated oral presentations at #CADrugUse – that there remains significant confusion about the evidence base
Given the generational significance of this process
It is an understatement to say that I am extremely disappointed by the significant gaps in evidence presented to the Assembly
It's also hard to convey my frustration that the #CADrugUse process has carried on without the direct input of relevant expertise
I'm confident the above issues wouldn't have come about if there had been direct input by criminal justice experts from the outset
There have throughout the process been some startling exclusions from oral evidence
Compounded by some predictable, non-expert campaigning, inclusions
Unfortunately (but predictably)
The voice of the panicked upper middle class medic – fearful their child won't get a perfect leaving cert because they'll smoke cannabis – has been as dominant within the Assembly as it has been on our news media
On the plus side
There have been some hugely impressive and compelling contributions from grassroots advocacy workers
Particularly memorable from yesterday was Andy O'Hara from @myuisce
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Funny how many in media, gov & courts have forgotten that's what the Disclosures Tribunal was ultimately all about
Part of the reason for this amnesia is no doubt how little judge Charleton made of that extraordinary feature of the scandal and what it said about Garda culture
I can't be the only who looks at policing here that's heard multiple accounts of the bullying, misogyny, homophobia and racism in Templemore
How recruits were labelled 'troublemaker' for asking questions (sound familiar)
How being sent to Templemore was viewed as a punishment
In Ireland, the only solution mainstream politicians offer in the aftermath of awful attacks like that in Talbot St is 'more Gardaí' and 'tougher sentencing (powers for courts'
But we aren't a particularly under-policed state (if we take that to mean 'how many cops are employed'