Post

How to get URL link on X (Twitter) App

On the Twitter thread, click on or icon on the bottom
Click again on or Share Via icon
Click on Copy Link to Tweet
Paste it above and click "Unroll Thread"!
More info at Twitter Help

Jon Bruner

@JonBruner

Oct 18, 2023 • 26 tweets • 10 min read • Read on X

Scrolly

What’s inside Apple’s $129 Thunderbolt cable? We CT scanned one to find out, and compared it to some cheaper cables… 🧵

Turns out there’s a lot going on in this Thunderbolt 4 connector. There’s a very complex PCBA that appears to have two inductors. This cable can deliver 100W to the connected device, plus it has to power its own ICs.

The PCBA has 9 layers, with lots of blind and buried vias. An industrial CT scan lets us filter by density; in the second image, I’ve removed the PCB substrate from the visualization, showing the denser materials in the vias.

Data can flow through this connector so fast that microscopic differences in trace lengths matter. Notice how the inside trace in this pair has a wiggle that makes it exactly as long as its outer counterpart.

The cable is a work of art. 20 separate wires, 10 of them coaxially shielded. The wires and their shields are soldered to the PCBA separately. It’s all protected by a strain-relief fitting that’s crimped in from 8 directions.

The wires that transmit power are soldered together upon reaching the PCBA; the data wires are soldered independently. This is very high-quality soldering, but even Apple’s solder has a little bit of porosity.

Here’s another fun animation before we move on to some other connectors.

By the way, you can explore these scans for yourself here:
lumafield.com/article/usb-c-…

Here’s an Amazon Basics USB-C connector. It’s thoughtfully designed, though without any of the intricacy that we see in the Thunderbolt connector.

While the Thunderbolt connector has all 24 pins allowed by the USB-C standard, this connector has just 12 pins, and they’re not independently connected to the PCBA; where mirrored pins are present, they’re jumped across.

@lumafield While the Thunderbolt’s PCBA is bristling with surface-mount components, this has none. The PCBA in the Amazon Basics connector just connects pins to wires. The strain relief here is much simpler than the Thunderbolt’s, too: it’s just a pair of arms crimped together.

@lumafield This cable is fairly complex, though; it has 5 wires, two of which have hollow cores. And the whole thing is shielded by woven wires that land at the connector’s metal enclosure. Way better than what we’re about to see…

@lumafield Now for the extreme comparison. This is a $5.59 USB-C cable offered by NiceTQ. It went off the market immediately after I ordered it.

Nothing here is shielded; the pins and the connector’s shell are all floating independently in overmolded plastic (along with a splatter of metal inclusions left over from the soldering process).

There are 8 pins in this connector, but only 4 are connected to anything at all, soldered directly to the cable’s wires. The other 4 are floating in overmolded plastic along with the connector’s shell.

The listing for this cable claims it transfers data at 10 Gbps. That would be a USB 3.1 Gen 2 speed, but its pins and wires are only configured for USB 2.0, which maxes out at 480 Mbps. There's no redundancy; if one of the four active pins wears or breaks, this will stop working.

Compared to the other cables we’ve looked at, this one is very simple: 4 stranded wires with rubber insulation and no shielding.

Here’s a mystery: an even cheaper cable (just $3.89) that has a much more complex design. This one is by ATYFUER and only claims to transmit power, not transfer data.

This connector has all 24 pins, each individually fixed to a PCBA–a construction detail that’s present in the $129 Apple cable but not the $10 Amazon Basics cable. Only 12 of those pins are connected to traces on the PCBA, though (5 on one side, 7 on the other).

The PCBA connects those 12 pins to just 4 wires, which are soldered on with quite a bit of porosity. Why have 24 pins if only 12 are connected? Why not economize by having fewer pins, like the Amazon Basics connector?

My guess is that this factory also makes a Thunderbolt cable, and it’s cheaper to maintain a single design and process for the pin assembly, even though that means more material and more components. If you know why it’d be designed this way, reply to the thread!

Although this is only advertised as a charging cable, it’s configured as a USB 2.0 cable that can transmit data, with two thicker stranded wires for power about 0.75mm in diameter (~AWG 20) and two thinner wires for data about 0.4mm in diameter (~AWG 26).

CT scans show relative material density; the blue color in the scan shows that the power wires are less dense–probably aluminum–and the yellow data wires are denser, probably copper. How much money is this manufacturer saving by mixing aluminum and copper?

You can explore these scans yourself! This post has links to each scan; if you're on a computer you can slice through them and play with relative densities just like I've done above. lumafield.com/article/usb-c-…

This thread was made possible by my engineering colleagues at @lumafield, who were able to glance at these scans and find interesting details. If that sounds fun to you, check out our open positions here: lumafield.com/careers

@lumafield If you’ve made it this far, you might enjoy this introduction to industrial CT!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

More from @JonBruner

Jon Bruner

@JonBruner

Oct 8

We just announced a major breakthrough in X-ray CT technology at @lumafield: scans that take hours with conventional CT will now take seconds. Here's why that's important 🧵

A CT scan is the richest possible source of industrial inspection data: it gives you a full 3D model of your part, inside and out, along with relative density information. But it's always been too slow for use in high-volume production environments—until now.

By bringing scan times down to as little as 0.1 seconds, we've overcome the major drawback of CT. Now it's a practical inspection technology for high-volume production.

Read 7 tweets

Jon Bruner

@JonBruner

Sep 25

Pens are made by the billion, require insane precision, and still work almost every time. We CT scanned a few common pen types to see what’s inside... 🧵

First up: a fountain pen 🖊️ These date back to the 10th century, but practical designs appeared in the 19th century. When the pen is tilted, gravity pulls ink from a cartridge to the nib. Capillary action pulls the ink through a slit in the nib, where it flows onto the page. Here are the 2D X-ray radiographs we captured of a fountain pen; we use software to reconstruct them into a 3D model (next tweet).

Here’s the 3D reconstruction of a retractable fountain pen—the Mahjohn A1. Our CT scan of the pen tip shows a spring loaded door that opens and closes to prevent the ink from drying out and to protect the nib.

Read 12 tweets

Jon Bruner

@JonBruner

Apr 9

We CT scanned an Apple Vision Pro! We also scanned two Meta headsets. Here’s what we found inside, and what it says about the two companies’ approach to AR/VR and to hardware development in general. 🧵

Here are our industrial CT scans of the Meta Quest Pro and Meta Quest 3 headsets. If you want to explore these scans, head to . Now let’s see what we found… lumafield.com/article/apple-…

Apple and Meta have taken different approaches to the market: the Vision Pro is a premium technology showcase for early adopters, while the Meta headsets are priced for accessibility in order to get as many people into the metaverse as possible.

Read 23 tweets

Jon Bruner

@JonBruner

Mar 28

This is an industrial X-ray CT scan of a Luer activated valve—a tiny medical connector that costs just 75 cents but is remarkably complex. Let’s take a look at how it works… 🧵

Luer connectors are used to join medical tubing for fluid delivery—think tubes that hook into IV bags, or needles that fit onto the ends of syringes. Hospitals use thousands every day. They twist together with less than one turn and must be secure and completely leakproof.

These connectors have an added feature: silicone valves that stop fluid from leaking out when disconnected. The valves are silicone sleeves with a slit at one end. The two connectors shown here work differently…

Read 10 tweets

Jon Bruner

@JonBruner

Mar 14

We CT scanned a Stanley Quencher cup to look for the lead that’s supposedly inside. Here’s what we found, and what it says about how these cups are made… 🧵

These cups have been a viral sensation, increasing Stanley’s revenue 10X since 2019. But late last year, social media influencers discovered lead in the cups. Stanley confirmed the cups contain lead, but says the lead doesn’t contact the cup’s contents. So what’s going on?

Here’s a @lumafield CT scan of a Stanley Quencher. Using X-ray images taken from different angles, we’ve constructed a 3D model that includes internal and external features. We can crop into the cup to see its cross section.

Read 13 tweets

Jon Bruner

@JonBruner

Feb 28

This is a CT scan of Heinz’s new ketchup cap. It represents a $1.2 million engineering investment over 8 years. Here’s why it’s significant… 🧵

This is the previous Heinz cap design. CT scans like @lumafield’s capture density, shown here on a blue-red spectrum. There are three plastics in this cross-section. The bottle is PET, and the cap is unlabeled but likely polypropylene. Inside the cap is another material.

@lumafield @HeinzTweets @KraftHeinzCo @BerryGlobalInc It's a small silicone valve. Here we strip out low-density plastic (the PP cap) and isolate the PET body and the silicone valve. Silicone is flexible and durable, and the design of the valve lets ketchup pass at a predictable rate when the bottle is squeezed.