Benjamin Carlson Profile picture
Oct 19 30 tweets 9 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
How do you make people join radical movements?

Perhaps the best answer comes from Dostoevsky's forgotten masterpiece, Demons

Sentenced to death for conspiracy, he knew the lure of radicalism—and saw the madness to come

28 insights on how brainwashing really works: Image
Attract followers not with logic, but with raw feelings.

Sentimentalism—playing upon soft-heartedness—disarms people's rational defenses.

You must persuade purely through emotion. Amplify feelings of resentment and injustice. Image
Make them ashamed of having their own opinions.

When constructing a radical movement, you must make sympathizers embarrassed of holding a different view. Discourage questions and independent thought.

This is the glue that holds everything together. Image
Erase privacy. Create a culture of snooping and denunciation.

To keep order in your secret society, encourage spying and reporting on one another.

There should be no such thing as an innocent remark. Image
Shower followers with made-up jobs, titles, ranks, duties.

Actions are upstream of beliefs.

If you give a man a made-up title for your ideological cause, he will take responsibility for it.

Inevitably he will start to believe in your ideas. Image
Bind them together in wrongdoing.

Unite a group by driving them to commit crime.

Once they have done evil, they will never step out of line against the organization, or one another, because they all are bound together in guilt. Image
Eliminate all original ideas.

You have succeeded when one no longer has a single original thought in his head.
Target the refuse of society.

In times of radical change, the dregs float upward and become prominent in public life.

Scoundrels. Sullen misanthropes. Sentimental idealists who can be twisted to go against their own interests. Image
Create the appearance of a vast global movement.

Give followers a feeling that an irresistible force—history itself—is at their back.

Encourage their sense of belonging to a great power waiting to reveal its strength.
Leverage fear of being left behind.

Some people dread nothing more than being seen as latecomers to a fashion.

Prey on this vanity. Image
Negate the good.

An ideology that glorifies disgrace is a flame to draw weak and angry members of society.

Make a point of openly dishonoring the noble. Pull down the talented.

“Shakespeare must be stoned.” Image
Foster hatred.

Hatred will bind together the conspirators in the end. Not merely hatred of their object, but finally, hatred of one another and fear of the damage they can cause to one another.
Use mockery.

Comedy and vulgarity play in essential part in the overthrow of a moral order.

Corrosive cynicism and sarcasm accelerate revolutions in beliefs.

The vanguard of a regime change is vulgar comedy.
Rely on cowardice

As low characters gain influence, let them loudly denounce everything sacred.

To avoid seeming out of touch, elites will begin to listen. Some will smile and even nod their heads to approve even the most outrageous ideas.
Appeal to the vanity of the elites.

In time, a small group of "advanced" people (who are always anxious to show they are in advance of other people) will assume control of the criminal elements and egg them on.

Afterward, many will wonder how they lost their heads. Image
Abolish crime.

Make society ashamed to enforce the laws, and the laws are suspended.

At a certain point, crime becomes practically a duty: if a radical needs money and feels he must commit crime to get it, there can be no possible objection to it. Image
Know your allies

Your supporters include many who unwittingly help the cause of radicalism

Judges who tremble in fear to give an unpopular sentence. Teachers who mock the beliefs of children's families. Kids who beat and rob just for the thrill.

These are seeds to grow Image
Embrace stupidity.

To change the world, great ideas must either be brilliant or stupid.

Nothing else but the greatest genius or the greatest stupidity can cause a revolution. Image
Elevate scoundrels.

Disturbances of politics will always be accompanied by intrusions of sinister people into the sanctum of the elite. This humiliation will accelerate a crisis. Image
Silence dissent

Allow some to furiously attack anyone who speaks up.

You must curb not only those who dare express an unorthodox thought, but also those who express orthodox ones.

Once everyone is intimidated into silence, only the insane will choose to speak.
Deceive shamelessly

Brazen lies are easier to believe than modest ones.

This will help you identify those who are anxious to be deceived. They are people who, once committed, would rather be lied to than accept the truth that they were fooled. Image
Make use of the ambitious

Understand the dreams of those who wish to achieve influence in society.

Entwine the success of your ideology with their plans, and you will become indispensable to their dreams. Image
Damage the prestige of all institutions.

Systematically denounce existing authority as a way to foster universal disbelief and desperation for change. Image
Build momentum.

You must harness that social energy that drives people to take actions they would never do on their own initiative.

It is what makes plotters carry through an insane idea despite their best attempts to sabotage or delay it. Image
Pretend it’s nothing.

When the ugliness starts, dismiss it as rambunctiousness—pranks—a form of play which only the unfashionable could mistake for serious. This allows it to countinue and grow until it is far too much to control. Image
Go beyond the turning point

When your allies who incite radicalism see chaos erupt, even they may feel appalled.

You must make them recognize that it is worse to have planned a conspiracy and failed than to carry one out

Then, to cover their error, they will ram it through.
In the decisive moment, use symbolic means of destruction

To succeed, a radical movement must use a recognized and preferred mechanism of unrest native to the country.

In Russia, that meant fires.

In America, it may be boycotts, riots, vigilantism.
Expect chaos.

In a conspiracy, surprises are inevitable.

It is common for the most adventurous and reckless to hasten that moment of crisis.

You cannot train a group of men to create havoc, and then expect them to follow your every order.
The aftermath: embarrassment

When the crisis is past, the elite will wonder why they complied with the madness of a mob.

Few will want to understand what happened. Most will rather leave it behind.

For this reason, the real architect of the outrages may remain forever hidden. Image
Found this thought-provoking?

Please give it a share and follow @bfcarlson. Subscribe to my newsletter for more. bfcarlson.com

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Benjamin Carlson

Benjamin Carlson Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @bfcarlson

Sep 21
What can an unfree society teach you about freedom?

In 6+ years living in China as a journalist, I was informed on, spied on, tailed when traveling.

This is nothing compared to what Chinese go through if targeted.

Here are 14 lessons—and warnings—that many need to hear: Image
People will adapt to oppression sooner than they will rebel.

It's human nature to seek the path of least resistance.

There's a reason that subversives tend to be social misfits.
Image
Image
The most effective censorship is first legal, then social, then internal.

Once people have learned to avoid certain topics ("that's too sensitive"), they cease to have anything to say on it. Image
Read 17 tweets
Sep 15
Why do bright people convert to a self-destructive ideology?

It's happened before.

One of the best analyses is the 1953 book, Captive Mind.

Ask yourself if any of this familiar: Image
The author, Nobel-winning poet Czeslaw Milosz saw the change firsthand

After the war, Polish elites were subjected to Soviet power

Many embraced Stalinism

Milosz was stunned to see patriotic men go from battling Germany to renouncing hopes of independence

How does it happen? Image
1 It's easier to submit than resist

He tells the story of Murti-Bing, a philosophy in pill form.

Murti-Bing gives easy answers. Those who take it obtain peace.

Intellectuals swallow it in droves.

Too late they discover the pill came from an invading empire

Nobody resists. Image
Read 14 tweets
May 31
In 1991, the FBI ran a background check on a man being considered for President George HW Bush's Export Council.

His name: Steven Paul Jobs.

The FBI spoke to friends and peers who described darker aspects of his character.

Here's what you can learn from his FBI file: Image
The interviews were conducted after Jobs left Apple Computer, during the period he ran NeXT.

When the FBI called, Jobs’ secretary told them they had to wait three weeks to interview him. He would not see them even for one hour.
1. He alienated friends.

The FBI interviewed several people who specified that they were no longer Jobs’ friends.

One admitted he felt “bitter words and alienated” toward him. While he described Job as honest and untrustworthy, he questioned Jobs’ morality. Image
Read 9 tweets
May 4
This is stunning: A majority of Americans believe life today is worse than it was half a century ago.

What was different — and better— about the lives of people in 1973?

And what is worse about today? Image
Americans' nostalgia for the past extends across groups, with varying degrees of intensity. Image
The bestselling books of 1973. Image
Read 5 tweets
Apr 26
The CIA has long tried to use the media to manipulate the American public.

In this 1983 clip, ex-agent Frank Snepp explains the techniques the CIA used in wartime to mold the narrative at home.

1. Spreading Disinformation
2. Exploiting Leading Journalists

In Vietnam, says Snepp, the CIA courted reporters from the New Yorker and top newspapers to build trust.

Agents gave false facts wrapped in truth to create desired narratives.
3. Trading Intelligence

The CIA collected information from journalists in exchange for giving information. This was a "frequent transaction," Snepp says.
Read 8 tweets
Apr 13
70 yrs ago today, Allen Dulles, launched the CIA's mind control program MKULTRA.

In 1953, Americans were shocked by Soviet/Chinese brainwashing of US soldiers in Korea.

The response: a top-secret, and ultimately twisted, effort to "control human behavior."

This is the story:
The CIA, founded 1947, had two missions: stop attacks on USA, and halt Communism's advance.

Two years later, the USSR blew up its first nuke, catching the CIA by surprise.

By 1954, a secret report urged: US must give up fair play & learn to 'subvert, sabotage, and destroy.'
Then came the Korean War.

GIs came out of prison camps brainwashed: loyal to enemies, confessing to false war crimes, refusing repatriation.

With drugs, propaganda, and new techniques, the Communists seemed to have mastered mind control.

What could be done? Image
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(