The best comparator for what Israel is doing now in Gaza is not anything previous in Palestine. It’s Israel’s 1982 invasion of Lebanon.
There, as here, Israel engaged in a bloody long-term attack with the purported goal of ending Palestinian resistance from Lebanon once and for
all and establishing a Lebanese government that would give Israel “forty years of peace.”
The result? Israel lost any global sympathy quickly, especially after the Sabra and Shatila act of genocide. Israel’s puppet government fell almost immediately. Israel occupied a portion
of Southern Lebanon for 20 years, at the end of which it withdrew with nothing gained. In the wake of its occupation came Hizballah, one of Israel’s most potent consistent enemies. On the way to gaining nothing, Israel killed tens of thousands, mostly civilians.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
As someone who very gradually made my way from anti-occupation liberal Zionism to anti-Zionist support for Palestinian rights, I pinpoint the key moment of my transition as learning about the Nakba. 1/6
Liberal Zionists march side by side with Palestinians and non-Palestinian anti-Zionists in fighting settlements, checkpoints, the siege on Gaza, and the Israeli army’s brutality. But they part ways when talking about eventual solutions, or when talking about refugees. 2/6
The reason is the blind spot of the Nakba. Liberal Zionists see the post-1967 wrongs and the day-to-day violence. But they have not understood that the foundations of the state are built on similar wrongdoing in 1947. 3/6
There’s a fiction in law that lawsuit damages “make the plaintiff whole,” that compensation makes things as good as it beforehand. But it doesn’t work like that. Nor do the crimes of colonialism and mass murder. Decolonialism is complicated. Wrongs are never fully righted. 1/
Algeria is perhaps the greatest decolonial success in modern history. Narly all the French pied noir left Algeria after its independence. But French is still an official language, and the traces of French rule remain strongly in other ways. 2/
Land back campaigns of Native Americans focus on particular areas of recently stolen land. No one argues for full decolonization of America and non-native Americans emigrating to Europe (though some unfairly try to portray land back that way). 3/
If Israel needed to disenfranchise all Palestinians to maintain Jewish power, it would. But like the Jim Crow south, it maintains the facade of democracy while ensuring Palestinians have no self-determination. A 🧵
Under Jim Crow, Black people technically had the right to vote. The barriers that Jim Crow put to suppress the vote—poll taxes, literacy tests, white primaries—were not absolute. In some states almost no Black people could vote, but in others a minority still voted.
Jim Crow succeeded because it suppressed the Black vote enough that the votes did not matter. If white power was maintained. 15% of Black people voting in gerrymandered districts could not overcome white power even where Black people were the majority.
65 years later, Israel has finally released documents about the Kafr Qasim massacre. We can expect damning, if unsurprising, new information in the coming days. One of the few massacres taken seriously and condemned even within Israel, but of course no one was held accountable.🧵
After the Nakba, Israel granted citizenship to most Palestinians within the Green Line, but it considered them hostile citizens. Palestinians were largely forced into separate towns and placed under martial law. This would continue until 1966. 2/11
In 1956, Israel, England, and France launched war against Egypt to retake colonial control of the Suez canal. Israel was afraid of Jordan coming to Egypt's aid, so the day it started the war it declared a 5 PM curfew on the Palestinian towns near the Green Line. 3/11
A great example of just how much Zionism is entangled with colonialism is the 1920 Battle of Tel-Ḥai, which Zionists claim as the first battle for a Jewish state but which was in fact part of the Syrian/Lebanese war against colonial France. 1/11
In the aftermath of WWI, Britain and France divided up the Levant between them into "mandates," supposedly different from colonies (but which France treated as colonies). France acted to prevent Faisal from forming an independent Arab state in Syria so as to form a mandate. 2/11
In early 2020, Faisal repudiated British and French colonization and in March declared an Arab Kingdom of Syria over roughly what today are known as Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, and Palestine (inc. Israel). This led to a four-month war that France ultimately won. 3/11
Israeli discourse over “Arab crime” has now moved to a campaign to extend the martial law tools Israel employs in the West Bank to Israel as well. This gives away the game: the denial of WB Palestinians’ rights has always been about their ethnic origin, not citizenship. 1/7
Among the tools the news reports the government has been considering, specifically against Palestinian Arabs in Israel proper with Israeli citizenship, to curb domestic crime: 2/7
Ending search warrant requirements. In the West Bank, the Israeli army can enter any Palestinian home at any time for any reason. IDF uses real civilian homes for training exercises in home invasion, or invade homes in the middle of the night to “make their presence felt.” 3/7