You want to know how I feel about all this ink I have to spill about the Middle East & its conflicts?
I wish I didn't have to do any of it. I wish I could be in Tehran, Beirut, Tel Aviv or Gaza, writing about poetry, cinema and wine, just as I did when I was a teen in Tehran
I wish I never had to know what are different types of drones and missiles, who is Hezbollah and who is Hamas and what murderous impulses motivates Khamenei or Netanyahu or Haniyeh.
I wish I didn't have to imagine the pain of children in Gaza or families of hostages in Ashkelon
I wish my timelines were filled with fights not about killing of children and whether it's justified but about whether you like Mehjoee or Kiarostami, whether Nazar Qabaani's love poetry is cheesy, whether you are a Murakami or an Ishiguro kind of person
I wish when a shopkeeper in Madrid or Atlanta asked me where I am from and I said 'Middle East', they said: oh, I love your poetry, your food, your cinema, your novels. I wish that's what we were known for.
I wish I and thousands like me were not driven from our homeland just because we don't like the rulers. I wish I could be getting drunk in the vineyards of my uncle near Arak, I wish my Egyptian friends could teach in their own country whenever they wanted.
I am not alone in these wishes in this wretched region. One day enough of us will set the agendas for the guns to drop silent and for us to breathe again.
When Gaza will be known first for its great beaches, Tel Aviv for its great cafes, Tehran for its excellent bread.
We are in an abyss now and it's hard to imagine a different world is possible. But we are too hopeless to ever give up on hope.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Posts like this are really fascinating because they really show what a bizarre relation anti-Zionist American Jews have to Israel & how politically rotten it is.
So Israel needs to be defined by the absolute worst crimes committees by its soldiers? Which other state +
in the world will survive this test?Which state in the world doesn't have egregious crimes done by its soldiers? Why does Corey Robin not think of all the heroic or stellar work done by Israel's artists, doctors, activists? or quotidian proletarian life of its workers & teachers?
Besides, what on earth's name does it mean to pledge to 'never support this state'? never going there? So you can just ignore that it exists?
Excuse me, your brave ethical act 'as a Jew' is to ignore the country where half the world's Jewry live and make their lives?
Remarks by @PahlaviReza in the Italian parliament today had many positive points. Most importantly he affirmed the need for 'national reconciliation' and offering an "exit strategy" to regime forces.
He insisted that majority of IRGC forces are salaried people not implicated in crimes. He warned that Iraqi-style De-Baathification led to the rise of ISIS and wont be useful for Iran. He also warned against turn to violence.
For transitional justice in future of Iran, he urged using South Africa's TRC and warned against the will for 'revenge' and 'cycles of violence' that could lead to civil war.
آقای رضا پهلوی در صحبتهای امروز خود در رم نکات مثبت متعددی را مطرح کردند که به نظرم باید مورد تایید تمام نیروهای دموکراسیخواه باشد. مهمتر از همه تاکید او بر «آشتی ملی» و لزوم ارائه «راهبرد خروج» به نیروهای سپاه و سایر نیروهای ج.ا بود
ایشان مثلا گفت: «روند تغییر در ایران، باید شامل آشتی ملی و راهبرد خروج هم باشد. به باور من، اکثر اعضای سپاه حقوقبگیرهایی هستند که نقشی در رفتار جنایی و سرکوب نداشتهاند و نباید فکر کنند که امیدی برای بقا ندارند. ما نباید کاری کنیم که در عراق در فرایند بعثیزدایی انجام شد»
«و باعث شد نصف نیروهای حزب بعث به داعش بپیوندند… قرار دادن سپاه در فهرست تروریستی، باعث میشود شمار بیشتری از نیروهای آن به ملت بپیوندند. ما خطاب به آنها میگوییم، به مردم بپیوندید و دست از این حکومت بکشید.»
I still can't believe this happened in the United States of 2023.
A scholar shows a respectful medieval depiction of Prophet Mohammad and she loses her job AND is labeled Islamophobic by the university's shameful administration.
Even after the fact, when faculty tried to stand up to this nonsense, they were told to shut up.
CAIR claims to stand for civil rights.
This is what it thinks of academic freedom in the United States of 2023?
"Controversial stuff about Islam" (which in this case was just a respectful medieval image of the Prophet) doesn't belong in UNIVERSITIES but 'local libraries'?
Decades of failed experiments show there are no magical substitutes for political parties and civic mass organizations.
If you want to change things, you have to get into politics. And if you want to do politics, you are going to need organizations.
The rest is BS.
In our region, Iraq, Lebanon and Algeria are three places where despite relative freedom of association, proponents of change and so-called 'revolution' have failed to build durable, serious and mass political organizations.
Here is the news for you intellectuals and activists of these countries: You can write as much poetry as you want about beauty of 'horizontal' action and meaningless video-clips about how much you love your city, etc.
If you don't build political orgs, you won't achieve change
There is much to sympathize with in this essay by Ukrainian sociologist @Volod_Ishchenko; chiefly his attempt to challenge a version of Ukrainian nationalism built on ethnic particularism, disavowing all historical entanglements with Russian culture +
and denying the universalistic aspects of Ukrainian Soviet history. He is indeed right that this identity politics of culturalist 'decolonization' is one that the Left needs to oppose.
But where Ischenko fails is that he seems to shockingly skirt the pressing issue of the moment
That is, the Russian invasion and the Ukrainian resistance for sovereignty and nationhood against a ruthless imperialist attack.
He, of course, mentions the invasion and its effects on Ukrainian society but he doesn't center it as one should.