Hedi Viterbo Profile picture
Oct 30, 2023 25 tweets 13 min read Read on X
Hamas says it would release all Israeli hostages in exchange for the #Palestinians imprisoned by Israel.

But what do we know about these imprisoned Palestinians?

A thread 🧵

1/25

#Palestine Image
First of all, more than a thousand (non-citizen) #Palestinians are currently imprisoned in Israel without charge or trial, in so-called "administrative detention."

Neither they nor their attorneys know the allegations against them.



2/25 btselem.org/administrative…
Image
"In administrative detention, a person is held … without having committed an offense, [because] … he or she [allegedly] plans to break the law in the future. … [That person faces] unknown allegations with no way to disprove them."



@btselem

3/25 btselem.org/administrative…
Image
Under Israeli law, "administrative detention" can be extended every six months – with no set limit.

Extensions are reviewed by an Israeli military court, behind closed doors, based on secret materials not disclosed to the defense attorney.



4/25 btselem.org/publications/s…
Image
Israeli military judges don't verify the secret allegations against Palestinians.

One former judge admitted in an interview: "all my information comes through the [Israeli] General Security Service agents. … I didn't doubt what they said."



5/25
Image
In theory, Palestinians can appeal these judicial review decisions.

In reality, such appeals almost never succeed:



6/25 scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/vjtl/vol45/iss…
Image
Without a fixed prison sentence, these Palestinians can't anticipate their release from prison and plan their lives accordingly.

They're kept in a stressful cycle of hope toward each judicial review, and despair following continued incarceration.

7/25 Image
Israel also recently detained thousands of Gazans who were lawfully working in Israel (with work permits).

According to @Gisha_Access and other NGOs, "these arrests were made … without cause":



8/25 gisha.org/en/illegally-d…
Image
So, as we've seen, thousands of Palestinians are incarcerated in Israel without charge or trial.

But there are also thousands of other Palestinians in Israeli prisons, who've been convicted by Israeli courts:



9/25 btselem.org/statistics/det…
Image
Most of these Palestinians have been convicted by Israeli military courts, whose conviction rate is 99.76%.

In other words, once their trial starts, Palestinians are almost destined for conviction.



10/25 haaretz.com/2011-11-29/ty-…
Image
Israeli military court hearings for Palestinians are extremely short.

For example, according to @YeshDin, hearings for authorizing continued remand until completion of trial last less than two minutes on average:



11/25 yesh-din.org/en/backyard-pr…
Image
Palestinians are rarely released on bail during their trials.

In one hearing, the court typist's computer was caught on camera with the following template text:

"I order that the defendant be remanded for __ additional days, until __."



12/25 facebook.com/avigdor.feldma…
Image
Although Palestinians' mother tongue is Arabic, Israeli military court hearings are conducted in Hebrew.

There are soldiers serving as court interpreters, but their professional training is lacking, and part of their role is to ensure order and proper conduct in court.

13/25 Image
Hundreds of Palestinians in Israeli prisons are below the age of 18. Most of them have been tried in Israeli military courts.

Israel is the only country to routinely prosecute an entire population's children in military courts.



14/25 btselem.org/statistics/min…
Image
For the sake of comparison, the number of Palestinian children in Israeli detention in a single year exceeds the total number of people held by the United States at the (in)famous Guantánamo prison since 2002.

15/25 Image
Over the years, I've analyzed hundreds of Israeli military court cases concerning Palestinian children.

None of these cases ended in an acquittal.

The average prison sentence was nearly 8 months (and many were longer, obviously).

16/25 Image
The most common charge against Palestinian children is stone throwing – an act punishable by 20 years in prison.

(this is the relevant Israeli military statute: )

17/25 idf.il/media/zh2jx5pd…
Image
Other outlawed acts include:

- Unauthorized demonstrations;
- Displaying unauthorized flags or symbols;
- "Tring to influence public opinion in a way that might harm public order."

All of which are punishable by 10 years in Israeli prison if committed by Palestinians.

18/25 Image
Palestinians from #Gaza and the #WestBank are transferred to prisons inside Israel.

According to critics, this practice violates the Fourth Geneva Convention (specifically Articles 49, 76, and 80):



@Addameer

19/25 addameer.org/publications/d…
Image
Palestinians in Israeli prisons are systematically denied family visits and family phone calls.



20/25 addameer.org/key_issues/fam…
Image
Palestinians in Israeli prisons also suffer from overcrowding.

And the Israeli parliament recently approved measures that would reduce their living space even more:



21/25 haaretz.com/israel-news/20…
Image
According to @MCourtWatch, Israel has detained about 800,000 Palestinians since 1967.

This is the equivalent of a fifth of the current Palestinian population of #Gaza and the #WestBank.



22/25 militarycourtwatch.org/page.php?id=a6…
Image
But this is just a rough estimate, because Israel doesn't publish clear and accurate information about Palestinians in its custody.



23/25 militarycourtwatch.org/page.php?id=K2…
Image
Israel’s mass incarceration of Palestinians mirrors the transformation of the Palestinian territory into, in effect, a colossal prison.

Indeed, Israel severely restricts Palestinian movement within, between, from, and into #Gaza and the #WestBank.



24/25 researchgate.net/publication/31…
Image
There's more information on imprisoned #Palestinians here:

1.

2.

3.

4.

25/25 jadaliyya.com/Details/36384
qmro.qmul.ac.uk/xmlui/bitstrea…
cambridge.org/gb/academic/su…
cambridge.org/gb/universityp…
Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Hedi Viterbo

Hedi Viterbo Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @HediViterbo

Jul 30, 2024
Palestinians are reportedly being raped in Israeli custody.

Israeli forces have a long record of sexually abusing #Palestinians (and others).

A thread 🧵

(Content warning: severe rape & sexual assault)

1/30

#Palestine #Gaza #WestBank Image
During a massacre in 1948, Israeli forces raped several #Palestinians.

Documents that were previously available in the Israeli state archive mention "3 rapes", including one of a "14-year-old girl".

2/30 Image
But Israel has hidden some of these previously public documents.

In an interview with @haaretzcom, officials admitted that they deliberately concealed documents to protect Israel’s reputation, discredit critics, and prevent Palestinian unrest:



3/30 haaretz.com/israel-news/20…
Image
Read 31 tweets
Jul 29, 2024
A court in the U.S. recently commuted the sentence of an Israeli diplomat's son.

Why? Because he's joining the Israeli military.

This reveals a lot about the U.S. and Israeli legal systems.

A thread 🧵

1/13

#Palestine #Palestinians Image
The Israeli, who lives in Florida, was convicted of intentionally running over a police officer with his motorcycle and causing him incapacitating injuries.

He also has two previous run-ins with the local police:



2/13
Image
But the 19-year-old Israeli told the Florida court:

"I have chosen to serve in the … [Israeli] military. I am looking forward to the … discipline that I will learn".



3/13
Image
Read 13 tweets
Jul 19, 2024
The #ICJ (International Court of Justice) has just declared the Israeli "occupation" to be illegal.

But this terminology conceals a much worse reality:

Israel's regime of control isn't "occupation". It's "settler colonialism".

A thread 🧵

1/10

#Palestine Image
Under international law, "occupation" is a temporary form of control.

Israel's control over the #WestBank & #Gaza is almost 60 years long. One in 20 Israelis lives in the #WestBank.

That's not "occupation".

2/10 Image
Also, the word "occupation" gives the wrong impression that the #WestBank & #Gaza are separate from Israel.

The truth: For decades, Israel/Palestine has been a single territory, subject to varying degrees of Israeli control.

3/10 Image
Read 10 tweets
Jun 17, 2024
Israel's export of weapons has now reached an all-time high.

These weapons were tested on #Palestinians.

So, what do we know about Israeli arms export?

A thread 🧵

1/10

#Palestine #Gaza #WestBank Image
According to Israel's former Minister of Interior Security, Uzi Landau, "Israel is a laboratory for fighting terror".

The "laboratory" – #Gaza and the #WestBank – enables Israel to develop and test the weapons it later sells to other countries.



2/10 washingtontimes.com/news/2002/jun/…
Image
The CEO of the Israeli Ministry of Defence recently said:

"Many countries in the world are seeing the success of Israel's arms systems in the war [in #Gaza], … and are buying Israeli weapons to defend their [own] citizens".



3/10 finance.walla.co.il/item/3671361
Image
Read 10 tweets
Jun 3, 2024
Right-wing figure Nigel Farage recently cited on TV "recent surveys saying that 46% of British Muslims support #Hamas".

The mainstream media has repeatedly quoted this false claim – without refuting it.

So here are the facts 🧵

1/8

#Islamophobia Image
As we'll see:

- In the poll that Farage was citing, 72% of British Muslim respondents said they DIDN'T have positive views of Hamas.

- The organization that commissioned the poll has been described as having an "anti-Islam agenda".

- The poll is statistically unreliable.

2/8 Image
So, here's how British Muslim respondents actually described their views of Hamas:

32% - neither positive nor negative
28% - positive
24% - negative
15% - don't know / unfamiliar

In other words, 72% of them DIDN'T have positive views of Hamas.

3/8 Image
Read 8 tweets
Apr 14, 2024
When #Israel recently assassinated 13 people in Iran's diplomatic building, this was described as an act of "deterrence".

#Iran's retaliation has also been described as an attempt to "restore deterrence".

But what does "deterrence" REALLY do?

A thread 🧵

1/10

#Palestine
Image
Image
A few years ago, I made several arguments about Israel's "deterrence" tactics:

First, acts of deterrence often DON'T prevent national security threats.

Instead, they create GREATER threats.

2/10 Image
For example, if Israel's bombing of the Iranian embassy compound was supposed to deter #Iran, then it achieved the exact OPPOSITE.

Iran's retaliation was unprecedented: launching hundreds of drones and missiles.

3/10 Image
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(