EBL Profile picture
Nov 9, 2023 25 tweets 8 min read Read on X
I call for patience with Erik ten Hag.

Manchester United's tactical display last night was their *BEST* of the season. Don't let the fact that they went down to 10 men fool you otherwise.

They were sensational with 11 men & it was ENTIRELY down to Erik ten Hag!

MEGA-THREAD! 🚨 Image
Manchester United built play in a 4-2-4 shape with a heavy emphasis on the double pivot of McTominay & Eriksen making passes and getting involved in the build-up.

It was refreshing to see United build play with players in close proximity & with the midfielders heavily involved. Image
So often this season we have seen United build play with a sole focus on Onana and the four defenders ahead of him to build play.

This left a complete disconnect between defence and attack due to the lack of midfield involvement.

This resulted in consistent long balls high.
However, instead of United building with one too many players between the lines and not enough second players in midfield, ten Hag demanded positional rigidity from Eriksen and McTominay in the pivot.

They rarely ventured forwards, and it saw United play 'connected football'..
The positional discipline was also excellent in advanced areas as Bruno Fernandes, for example, stayed high and in between the lines alongside Højlund in the opposite half space with Garnacho wide on the left and Rashford wide on the right.

Again, positional rigidity was clear. Image
This saw United consistently and effectively progress play between the lines whilst also possessing a major threat in transitional situations as Bruno often received facing the opposition goal with runners ahead of him.

Then, when play broke down, they counterpressed superbly. Image
Instead of United's deep-lying midfield being empty due to having two #8's between the lines & none deep, McTominay & Eriksen's positioning enabled United to remain compact in defensive transition with the advanced players able to apply immediate pressure when turnovers occurred. Image
Not only that, but United's settled pressing structure was similarly compact.

Ten Hag set his team up in his typical 4-4-1-1 off-ball shape with Bruno and Højlund man-marking the #6 and pressing the ball-side centre back, but the inversions of Garnacho were key in the press. Image
Here we see Garnacho invert to prevent Copenhagen from having a 3v2 centrally against Bruno & Højlund (pic 1).

This left the opposition fullback on the far side free but Dalot, where possible, pushed high to press him (pic 2).

This enabled United to press in man-to-man fashion.
Image
Image
Dalot was not able to reliably back up the press in settled play, though, as sometimes he had to mark Copenhagen's winger.

However, in those moments Garnarcho primarily continued to invert anyway as he could shadow mark the opposition fullback when he pressed inside. Image
Where United's press was most impressive was from Copenhagen's goal kicks as they matched up in man-to-man fashion, and this is an entirely new strategy from Erik ten Hag!!

Instead of letting the opposition play to one side and matching up, United man-marked all over the park.
We see that man-to-man press here as Garnacho starts centrally to create a 3v3 vs Copenhagen's #6 and two centre backs, McTominay and Rashford match up with their respective men on their side of the pitch, and on the far side (out of shot) Dalot presses the opposition right back! Image
This forced Copenhagen to go long where United were again matched up in man-to-man fashion in defence.

Such an approach from Erik ten Hag is incredibly refreshing to see as United are often overloaded numerically in the press from opposition goal kicks, but not last night! Image
However, as a result of Garnacho only inverting to press the opposition centre back sometimes, Copenhagen could use their 3v2 overload in central areas in settled play to sustain some attacks of their own.

Here United defended in a 4-4-2 block where the #6's man-marked the #8's. Image
As far as game plans and performances go, Erik ten Hag was not lying when he said the first half an hour was the best 30 minutes of Manchester United's season, and that is ENTIRELY down to his tactical adjustments in and out of possession.

He deserves massive credit.
We all know how the game ended up, but a freak red card doesn't change the fact that Erik ten Hag addressed and SOLVED Manchester United's primary issues this season in this game.

No longer are they as disjointed in and out of possession.

They were cohesive, balanced & compact.
However, despite the tactics undeniably being 100x superior than what they have been all season, the fluidity of the build-up *could* cause problems in the future.

Ten Hag likes his centre backs to rotate with the fullbacks in terms of who occupies the standard centre back role.
So, for example, here we see Harry Maguire in possession with Evans central and Dalot tucked in on the far side.

Maguire is about to recycle to Onana, so this is the cue for Evans to *stick* positionally and Dalot to *retreat* into a 'makeshift' left centre-back role. Image
We see that play out in the first image below.

We also saw it consistently with Harry Maguire and even Varane when he came off the bench.

It essentially results in United having a back 3 (including Onana), a situational #6, and the double pivot ahead of them in a 3-3-5 shape.
Image
Image
United's inverted centre back can be useful for 'wall passes' as Onana plays into the feet of them before they lay it off to the fullback, but it causes more problems than it solves...

Sometimes the distance the fullbacks have to cover is large forcing Onana to play to one side. Image
It can also result in the blockage of passing lanes into players further up the pitch.

Not only that, but Varane, Evans, Maguire, and Lindelöf are not comfortable receiving with their back to goal as a situational #6.

They don't have the natural turning radius of a midfielder. Image
When Lisandro Martinez, for example, plays it can work, or when Luke Shaw plays at centre back it can work, but no other centre back is comfortable inverting.

A collection of these issues can complicate United's build-up making it clunky and often not in close proximity.
That will undeniably improve with Lisandro Martinez, Luke Shaw, and even Malacia back in the squad, but for that build-up structure to reliably work United will have to improve the technical quality of their defence.

HOWEVER, aside from that, the tactical plan was perfect!
We can express frustration at some individuals for lax defensive moments, for example, or at the officials for making some extremely questionable calls which cost United dearly, but we cannot doubt the quality & improvement of Erik ten Hag's approach.

It was his best all season!
What is most important for Erik ten Hag and Manchester United now is that he *sticks* to the principles that made United so good with 11 men.

They must continue to operate with another player in midfield alongside the #6 as it solves many issues in and out of possession! Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with EBL

EBL Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @EBL2017

Oct 2
Arsenal are not identifiable through one set tactical shape.

It's best to separate the new iteration of Arteta's Arsenal into three simple categories:

- The build-up,
- The offensive triangle on the left,
- And the offensive triangle on the right.

All of which form 'one' unit. Image
Thomas Partey drops into the first line of build-up to overload PSG's first line of pressing. Calafiori becomes the spare man and Arsenal find him.

Partey drops into the first line of build-up, Gabriel becomes the spare man.

Rice drops, Partey moves up, now he's free.


Image
Image
Image
Image
David Raya steps out to create a +1 in the build-up.

This gives license to one of Arsenal's fullbacks to push higher up the pitch, with that being Calafiori in this moment.

Interestingly, Trossard is on the right and Martinelli is in the half space.

Let's explore that. Image
Read 16 tweets
Sep 30
Arne Slot's Liverpool have some tactical issues, both with and without the ball.

A thread 👇 Image
When Liverpool build in a 4-3-3, Slot asks a lot of his players.

The absence of a second pivot player increases the distances between the teammates which means short, sharp, and snappy combinations in close proximity are not always possible.

The reliance on individuals is high. Image
Liverpool have some of the best players in the world so can absolutely evade pressure, but they are not bulletproof in this phase.

The passing distances are large which increases the chances of turnovers which leaves Gravenberch isolated in defensive transition.

Not ideal..
Image
Image
Read 12 tweets
Sep 28
Mikel Arteta's Arsenal have evolved.

Arsenal are no longer easily identifiable tactically.

So often we have seen Arsenal use positional play principles, and they are still there, albeit in an entirely different way.

Below, I review "The New and Improved Arsenal".

THREAD! 🔴⚪️Image
'Rigidity' is a concept that centres around the consistent occupation of specific zones on the pitch.

Fluid rigidity, however, is a related but different concept that centres around the consistent occupation of specific zones on the pitch with freedom to alternate between zones.
Mikel Arteta have consistently used 'fluid rigidity'.

This was seen in each phase against Leicester.

As ever, Arsenal built play with Raya creating a +1 in the build-up, a 4-2-4 when Raya was not involved, and a 3-2-5 higher up the pitch (with Timber/Calafiori moving high).

Image
Image
Image
Read 20 tweets
Sep 23
Manchester City vs Arsenal ~ a tactical review like no other.

A thread designed to educate.

🔵🔴Image
Smart people watch City versus Arsenal and see that Arsenal came to press with aggressive intent but were forced back.

The very same people would have expected that to happen, just like as Arteta and Arsenal would have.

Two big questions - how and why were they pinned back?
In picture A we see Arsenal press in man-to-man fashion.

In picture B we see Arsenal press in man-to-man fashion.

In picture C we see Bernardo overload Arsenal's press by dropping into the first line, dribbling, & forcing Arsenal back.

Bernardo took tactics into his own hands.

Image
Image
Image
Read 18 tweets
Sep 22
Manchester United were flawlessly coached from a tactical perspective against Crystal Palace.

This was one of the very first times Erik ten Hag's team controlled the game with AND without the ball to the same level as City & Arsenal.

It shows Erik ten Hag CAN succeed..

THREAD!Image
One of the biggest issues Erik ten Hag's Manchester United have faced from a tactical perspective has been their lack of positional discipline in possession.

So often we see players popping up all over the park and rotating, but too much of that breeds unfamiliarity and chaos.
Against Palace, however, United were the opposite of ill-disciplined positionally.

Their structure was excellent as they consistently attacked in a 3-2-5 shape.

Mazraoui tucked inside to form a back 3, Dalot inverted into midfield, & Eriksen + Bruno were high between the lines. Image
Read 21 tweets
Sep 15
Spurs 0-1 Arsenal.

With several key starters injured, Señor Mikel Arteta cooked up a tactical masterclass of the highest order 💯

THREAD! 👇Image
The idea that Arteta's Arsenal simply 'played a low block and grinded out a result' is one that makes me laugh.

The same narrative persisted when they went to the Etihad and ended City's 57-game scoring run at home.

The reality is Arsenal are incredibly brave in their approach.
The idea that 'brave' solely consists of consistently playing out from the back and pressing high is a false one.

Contrary to popular belief, Arsenal did both of those things, but they were very disciplined and calculated in their ENTIRE approach..

Let's assess their tactics 👇
Read 30 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(