Ed Conway Profile picture
Dec 12, 2023 13 tweets 5 min read Read on X
⚡️INERTIA⚡️
The magic ingredient at the heart of our power systems.
It's also one of the obstacles to replacing fossil fuels with renewables.
In short, a REALLY big deal!
But most folks have never heard of it.
It's widely considered too complex.
So. Here's your idiot's guide
🧵
Key thing here is to remember that for most of history most of our power has come from turbines spinning.
Steam turbines in coal and nuclear power stations. Gas or hydro turbines.
When you think of the electricity grid, think of lots of big wheels turning, all around the country.
Image
Image
And here's the slightly 🤯 thing: every single turbine around the country is spinning at exactly the same frequency.
Every one.
50hz.
It's like an enormous orchestra across the land, all playing the same tune at exactly the same tempo.
Sidenote:
There's no reason it HAS to be 50hz. In US the system runs at a frequency of 60hz. It's just convention. Main thing is getting all turbines running synchronously.
Side-sidenote: Japan actually has two separate systems, one 50hz, the other 60hz due to historical accident Image
As those turbines turn the copper coils in the generators attached to them turn through a magnetic field at 50hz and generate AC power.
But here's the thing. They don't just generate power. They also provide something known to electrical engineers as inertia.
THE magic ingredient
Perhaps the best way to think of inertia is via a spinning top.
Picture a very heavy spinning top, turning v fast. If you nudge it it moves a bit but carries on spinning.
Now picture a much lighter spinning top. Nudge it and it falls over.
Inertia is somewhat similar...
Having loads of big heavy turbines spinning at precisely the same rate all across the country helps the grid maintain frequency. If there's an outage it's far easier to prevent the lights going out if you have lots of inertia.
No one spent much time thinking abt this til recently
But then along came net zero.
Now everyone is phasing out those old coal/gas power stations and replacing them with wind turbines & solar panels.
But there's a problem. A big problem. They don't provide inertia.
Leaving places like the UK, with lots of wind turbines, in a pickle
If the UK were getting 100% of its power from wind & solar then there would be no inertia. The system wouldn't work.
We've had a sneak preview of this recently during Covid.
Lots of wind, low demand. The grid operators actually had to fire up gas turbines JUST to provide inertia
And while batteries and power electronics can help a bit, there are some who say that this is another reason why we'll ALWAYS need gas in the power system. Which raises a question. What to do?
It so happens the answer might be in a room on a road in the outskirts of Liverpool.
Inside this small facility are two big soundproofed rooms and inside them are two massive 40 tonne flywheels, turning at 1500rpm. They're powered by the grid (eg they actually TAKE power away) but they send back INERTIA.
They are replicating what happens in conventional turbines!
The @StatkraftUK facility only came online this year. But it's a glimpse of something important. A potential solution for the inertia conundrum.
If we want 100% renewables we'll need lots of these spinning wheels alongside the wind/solar power
🍿Of course, inertia is only one small part of this puzzle. It's just one ingredient in a film we've just made at @SkyNews about the future of the power grid and its aim to reach net zero.
Been working on this for a while. Do share if you enjoy!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ed Conway

Ed Conway Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @EdConwaySky

Dec 9
🧵
What does a trade war look like?
Much of what you've heard about tariffs is prob soundbites from politicians & economists.
But what does a trade war actually FEEL like at ground level?
We've spent the past year working on a film on just that.
Here's some highlights
👇
Best place to start is with this👇
It may look like a lump of metal but don't be fooled.
This is a die: a sort of mould used to shape plastics. Looks simple but it's super-engineered - designed to withstand enormous pressure.
Without dies like this there's no manufacturing... Image
Dies and moulds are the unsung champions in modern mass production.
One of the single most impressive things about Tesla's manufacturing processes is what @elonmusk calls the Gigapress: a massive machine that shapes metal. And at the heart of the gigapress are enormous dies. Image
Read 24 tweets
Dec 1
The PM keeps repeating the figure £16bn in relation to the OBR's latest forecasts - giving the impression that this would have left a big hole in the public finances. What he fails to acknowledge is that that this is LITERALLY ONLY ONE PART OF THE STORY.
Here's why...
Yes: the OBR downgraded the fiscal numbers by £16bn (actually £15.6bn) due to weaker productivity (red bar below).
But it also simultaneously UPGRADED them by a whopping £32bn (blue bars).
This chart from @TheIFS shows it pretty clearly👇 Image
Banging on about the £16bn productivity - as the PM did repeatedly in his press conference today - without also mentioning the £14bn inflation UPGRADE and the £17bn of other UPGRADES seems... pretty misleading to me.
It's simply NOT the full picture...
Read 5 tweets
Nov 21
NEW
UK abolishes its "de minimis" rules which exclude cheap imports below £135 from paying tariffs.
A massive deal for the fast fashion/cheap Chinese imports sector: this is the so-called loophole used to great effect by SHEIN and Temu.
Should also bring in some tariff revenue Image
For more background on this, here's our investigation from earlier this year on de minimis and what it means in practice - including a glimpse inside the planes carrying these imports into the UK 👇
The flip side to this policy is:
a) stuff (yes, a lot of it is tat but even so) will get more expensive
b) it primarily hits lower income households
c) as you'll see from my thread, de minimis was a lifesaver for small regional airports. Its demise is v bad news for them...
Read 4 tweets
Oct 21
NEW
"Data center alley" in North Virginia.
Home to the biggest cluster of server centres in the world.
Here, more than anywhere else, is the global epicentre of AI.
It's where the recent AWS outage happened.
And we've secured rare access INSIDE one of the data centres...
The inside of one of the centres, run by Digital Realty, one of the biggest datacenter companies in the world.
Extremely high security. Long, long corridors, flanked by rooms in which those servers are operating.
This is the very heart of the biggest economic story right now Image
And inside one of those rooms, here is one of the supercomputers powering the AI boom. This Nvidia DGX H100 is the physical infrastructure making AI a reality. Image
Read 8 tweets
Oct 16
🚨EXCLUSIVE
The firm at the heart of Britain's critical minerals strategy has ditched plans for a rare earths refinery in the UK, and will build it in the US instead.
It's a serious blow to the Chancellor and her plans for "securonomics" ahead of next month's Budget👇
Not long ago Pensana was being hailed as key to Britain's industrial future.
It had plans to ship rare earth ores to the UK and refine them in a plant just outside Hull, creating 126 jobs and bringing in hundreds of millions of pounds of investment... Image
Its Saltend site was where the then Biz sec Kwasi Kwarteng launched the govt's official critical minerals strategy a few years ago, saying: "This incredible facility will be the only of its kind in Europe and will help secure the resilience of Britain's supplies into the future" Image
Read 8 tweets
Sep 2
📽️Is Britain REALLY facing a 1970s-style fiscal crisis?
Why are investors so freaked out about UK debt?
Is this REALLY worse than under Liz Truss?
Who's to blame? Rachel Reeves? The Bank of England?
And would a bit of productivity really solve everything?
📈 Your 6 min primer👇
OK, so let's break it down.
Start with the chart everyone (well, everyone in Whitehall) is talking about.
The 30yr UK government bond yield. Up to the highest level since 1998. And it's still rising.
Does this mean the UK is facing a fiscal crisis? Let's look at the evidence Image
First let's compare the UK to other G7 countries.
There's two ways to do this.
First, look at absolute levels👇
And it looks pretty awkward for the UK.
Pre-mini Budget we were middle of the pack. That changed post-Truss. And now, under Labour, the UK is even more of an outlier. Image
Read 18 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(