I grew up thinking that doing farm work made you a farmer
If you filled your time with farm work you were a serious farmer
…
It’s bullshit
I now think you become a farmer when it’s your money on the line and when you make it work financially
The most irritating and stupid people in farming are those that have never actually made a farm profitable
Sure they’ve done plenty of work, but they’ve never actually had to work out what works and what doesn’t
I don’t listen to them anymore
Our farm made a loss when we inherited it (don’t mean that disrespectfully, but it did) and it needed changing to make it survive
It has to be profitable on its own and is
And for one or more of my children to keep it going it will have to change even more in the next few years
And yet a lot of farming people hate change… and anyone that does it
But that’s their problem, my job isn’t to make others feel comfortable or to fit in… it’s to give our farm a future
If you are young or starting out with your farm business almost the worst thing you can do is what everyone else does
Be brave
Try new things
Learn new stuff
Ignore old codgers - especially the ones who haven’t got a viable business, they don’t know shit
Yes, find mentors who are excellent at what they do
But that isn’t the old grumblers on the road side
Have a nice day x
Also someone should invent hats for people at farming conferences and events
You have to wear the hat when saying ‘that will never work’ - but it has a screen on it that shows your profit and loss stats and your soil organic matter
I’m not listening if it’s in the red
Also, 95% of times when people say ‘that won’t work on my farm’ the person is wrong
They just mean ‘there is no goddamn way I’m doing that because it makes me uncomfortable’
A lot of people would rather fail in ways that make them fit in than win in ways that make them not
Farming often isn’t rational or a business
It’s a culture or way of life - so much of what is nice about it comes from that
But it’s also a mess and a problem when farms fail, because rational thinking and bravery about change is missing
I see it with youngsters
The blood drains from their faces when you tell them that maybe the things they like doing aren’t profitable
They want to do the same stuff they’ve grown up with regardless of whether it works anymore in terms of £
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Privately being told some really sad stories about farmers trying to do more for nature in their Higher Tier CS schemes and being turned down
Can’t emphasise how much this sucks - these are farmers being rejected who want to deliver MORE NATURE
Imagine the psychology of this - you spend hours and hours and sometimes thousand of pounds developing a nature restoration scheme for the farm and the goverment bodies turn you down cold
After a lifetime of being criticised as farmers for nature loss
You then can’t do nature restoration
And have to focus on production
Why would any farmer subject to that ever engage again with nature restoration?
Loved meeting Polish farmers this week. The most encouraging thing is that most of their amazing wildlife was trashed in the 1990s - It came back because they changed the way they farmed and managed land
It’s a mix of agro-ecological (no chemicals or synthetic fert) extensive livestock farming, wilder rivers and lakes, strict conservation regulations and forest management, and reintroduced species that recreate missing habitats twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
It’s not all sweetness and light…
The farmers are having a nightmare with adapting to wolves (losing sheep and calves), find beavers a nuisance and are heavily subsidised for losses, and not pursuing production above all else
When he was pointing in the right direction he was a force of nature - and a formidable warrior for it
He was an absolute rascal.
A man of fierce (sometimes dodgy) beliefs but went at life like a terrier and I couldn’t help but like him. telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/3…
Had some great chats with him
You never knew what he’d come up with next - and had a strange knack of making impossible things seem possible
Condolences to Robin’s family and friends.
I’d spend half our phone calls laughing, or being persuaded to join some noble cause or other, and the other half trying to say polite NOs for when he was chasing a mad idea
He never took umbrage when I said NO
And when I thought he was right, he do remarkable things
He said I was going in to Higher Tier and I was alright
Actually I’m TRYING to get in to it - it’s expensive to apply for (about £700 in fees so far), and you need @NaturalEngland staff to judge you as being good enough - and to have the capacity - they often don’t have this
Credit to @NaturalEngland their local staff are excellent but under massive pressure
And we’ve been doing ambitious environmental things for 15 years so we have a head start - so fingers crossed we get in
Amazing to me to see how different farmers and some environmentalists see this
The idea that upland farmers will all go green and lower inputs if you drop their income from the state is one of the strangest/most unlikely ideas I’ve ever heard - but clearly sincerely held
It seems to be based on the idea that farms are what they are because of the past subsidies
And taking those away will lead to everyone falling in to line with low input greener business models
It’s like a pyramid scheme of assumptions
More likely is people faced with loss of income change their businesses to try and fill the hole - some may go low input and green, but many will intensify and try and produce more livestock