Lots of commentary in past 36hrs about why PL charges under PSR rules against EFC and NFFC appear to be being expedited, while Man City's 115 charges (from an investigation dating back to 2018) linger, TBD on a now-agreed but not public timetable 1/n
Everton (for a second time) and Forest have been charged for "simple" failures to balance their books around the "acceptable" losses of £105m over a 3-year ruling period. 2/n
Whereas Man City's 115 charges effectively amount to accusations they were conducting financial fraud on a grand scale over a long period, and hoodwinking not just the PL but UEFA, and not co-operating. 3/n
We know from Football Leaks and other sources that the City hierarchy's view has long been they'd “rather spend £30m on the 50 best lawyers” and sue Uefa “for the next ten years” than accept a punishment. THIS is plutocracy. 4/n
They HAVE spent millions on lawyers. The've used every legal avenue possible to stall the process. When I was an MoS reporter in 2021 we used an external QC to gain access to "open justice" and attend court as City tried to stymie the PL's investigation. 5/n
If Man City's supposed mountain of irrefutable evidence of their innocence is ready to go, then bring it on and get it sorted. For the benefit of everyone. 6/n
They could have cooperated almost SIX years ago when the PL first started investigating them, and they didn't. That's their prerogative. It's not great on the optics but they don't care about optics. 7/n
There is also a massive (MASSIVE) political element to this case. Sheikh Mansour is the deputy PM of a significant political ally of the United Kingdom. Imagine if he and his club were shamed by multiple guilty verdicts. Unprecedented and unpalatable. 8/n
I'll be submitting further FOIs to try to establish the extent of British government involvement in the PL vs City case, but others so far have been fruitless. The stakes are SO much higher than whether a football club broke some football rules. 9/n
Some (some) City fans go to extremes to convince themselves there's no case against City. Despite having been fined 90m euros (later reduced to "only" 30m) for major breaches of financial rules, and dishonesty, and non-cooperation. Before 115 PL charges. 10/n
I've reported on City my whole working life. I knew, and know, people inside the club at all levels. I've been Khaldoon's guest in their directors' suite (albeit before I called them out). I have multiple sources who told me what really happened. 11/n
Man City's hierarchy realised around 2010 that they needed "accelerated investment' before UEFA's FFP came into force. Their solution was cooking the books. That was evident from their 2014 punishment onwards. It's all been in plain sight. 12/12
Goodnight. X
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
10 years ago this week, we published an investigation by @MarthaKelner and me, revealing there was a doping and cover-ups plot underway in Russian sport, naming lab boss Grigory Rodchenkov at the heart of it.
🧵
1/n
@marthakelner It was the biggest story I’ve ever broken, and I can’t imagine doing another with such significant ramifications.
(Oh, and it was totally ignored, not least by the IOC, who were given evidence and couldn’t be arsed to act).
2/n
@marthakelner It was a batshit crazy tale: WADA-appointed lab boss had been arrested for drug-dealing, tried to stab himself to death in the heart, sent to a mental institution, all of this secret, then covered up, then sent back to work to corrupt the Sochi Games.
3/n
Reminded today quite how massive Man Utd are as a football club, with the response to an article asking simple questions about Sheikh Jassim and his resources and motivations attracting wacko replies from thousands of people the world over
Many of the replies / comments to last night's thread and article have been casebook studies in the power of sportswashing (a terms I find problematic for various reasons). Some (far from all) MUFC fans rabidly defending / championing a stranger.
That Man Utd are so far ahead of the rest of English football as a global brand (honourable runners-up being Liverpool) isn't in doubt by any serious, credible metric. But Holy Heck - the collateral lunacy that comes with it...
So little is known about Sheikh Jassim, the Qatari bank manager who lodged a £4bn bid to buy Man Utd on Friday night, that even spokespeople working for him don’t know his age, whether he is married or how he made a supposed fortune of billions. A 🧵
1/n
Plenty is known about his dad, Qatar’s PM from 2007 to 2013, Sheikh Hamad, aka HBJ, who in several meetings with Prince Charles a few years ago gave the UK’s current king £2.6m in cash in suitcases, a holdall and in Fortnum & Mason carrier bags.
2/n
Both Sheikh Hamad and son Jassim (one of his 15 kids by two wives) went to Sandhurst. At 23, in 2005, Jassim was made chairman of one of Qatar’s biggest banks, QIB. Intriguing is his reported "lifelong" passion for Man Utd
3/n
Sheikh Jassim's NINE TWO Foundation (through which he hopes to buy Man Utd) doesn't appear to have any current presence. Bid apparently in region of £4bn plus investment. Is NINE TWO a reference to Class of 92? Sue him @GNev2 for copyright infringement
@GNev2 Bloomin' Qatari sheikhs, coming over here, stealing our nicknames. This geezer isn't remotely wealthy enough on his own to have £4bn for a bid and maybe £2bn more on investment. Obvious front for a state-backed & funded project on the face of it.
It's Jan 2031 & we've just had the "best World Cup in history", in Saudi Arabia, in December 2030, according to FIFA Pres Infantino. After a vote by chairman of Premier League clubs, 17 of which are now owned by Sheikhs and SWFs, PL will relocate to the Gulf.
The ALLEGATIONS are basically: Man City cooked their books for years, made inappropriate manager and player payments, dodged FFP and didn't co-operate with PL investigations
For anyone saying "Nothing will happen", well this IS something happening. A massive raft of charges arising from Man City systematically cooking their books for years, as some of us have repeatedly reported.
In the 3 World Cup 2022 matches before USA-Wales, the official attendances have been 67,372 (in a stadium with capacity of 60,000); 45,334 (in a stadium holding 40,000) and 41,721 (in a stadium holding 40,000).
Amazing, not least given all the empty seats.
I'm not saying Qatar 2022 is built on lies and propaganda and mistruths that are so obvious it's embarrassing, like 3 workers have died in 10 years building the 2020 infrastructure, but .... okay, I am saying that.
According to FIFA (known liars) the capacity of the Ahmad bin Ali Stadium where Wales played USA tonight is 40,000.