On January 30, 1948, Nathuram Godse passed into eternal infamy by firing three fatal shots at Mahatma Gandhi from an automatic 9mm Beretta pistol at the Birla House in Delhi. That Godse and most of the assassination plotters were from Maharashtra has been used to unfairly tarnish the state and its people as being ranged against the Mahatma.

However, these narratives ignore the fact that Gandhi had a complex yet deep association with Maharashtra. His critics, such as Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, who was an accused in the Gandhi assassination case but was acquitted by the trial court, and Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar, hailed from Maharashtra. But so did his mentor Gopal Krishna Gokhale. Gandhi’s staunch followers, such as ‘Acharya’ Vinoba Bhave, who is regarded as his spiritual successor; freedom fighter, author and social reformer Pandurang Sadashiv Sane ‘Guruji’; and Sitaram ‘Appasaheb’ Patwardhan, who was referred to as the ‘Konkan Gandhi’, were also Maharashtrians.

Read on to know more about the deep connect between Mahatma Gandhi, Maharashtra and the Marathi language.

The contribution of Maharashtrians to Gandhi’s struggle in his early days—after arriving in Mumbai from South Africa in January 1915—is also little known. Soon after his return to India, Gandhi contacted his friend from his days in England—barrister Keshav Ganesh Deshpande, who was based in Baroda. It was Deshpande who introduced Gandhi to a teacher, Dattatreya Balkrishna aka Kakasaheb Kalelkar, in what would be the beginning of a life-long association.

Deshpande’s associate Vitthal Lakshman aka Mama Phadke also joined forces with Gandhi. Kedarnath Appaji Kulkarni, a resident of Pali in the erstwhile princely state of Bhor, which straddled the present-day Pune and Raigad districts, also became an associate of Gandhi. The scholar-author Y.D. Phadke says Deshpande, Kalelkar and Kulkarni were being pulled towards the activities of the armed revolutionaries, but took to Gandhi’s path after realising that using violent means would not help the cause of independence.

#MahatmaGandhi #mahatmagandhiji #Gandhi #Gandhiji #NathuramGodse #Maharashtra #Marathi #Pune #Godse #history #heritageImage
Image
When Gandhi launched his Champaran Satyagraha in Bihar in 1917 against the exploitation of indigo farmers, a Maharashtrian couple, Avantikabai and Baban Gokhale, taught at schools in the area and created awareness among the villagers. Some other Marathis who were associated with Gandhi in this period include Narayan ‘Pundalikji’ Katgade and Shankarrao Deo.

Kalelkar says Gandhi also made efforts to learn Marathi. In South Africa, Gandhi had acquired functional knowledge of Tamil as he had to work among Tamil indentured labourers. He had also learnt Urdu. After returning to India in 1915, he decided to learn Marathi. In December that year, he replied to a letter by an office-bearer of the Servants of India Society, Pune, in Marathi.

The letter from the society was in English. Gandhi would dictate his reply aloud in Gujarati and Kakasaheb Kalelkar would translate it into Marathi. Kalelkar says he asked Gandhi to sign off with the standard line: ‘Lobh asawa hi vinanti’ (May your love or warmth continue). Gandhi interpreted the word ‘lobh’ as greed and replied, “Actually, it should be lobh nasava”. Kalelkar explained that in this particular context, lobh implied love or warmth.

Later, Gandhiji realised that there were Maharashtrian families in his ashram and started reading ‘Manache Shlok’ by Samartha Ramdas Swami in his daily prayer meetings. He could understand spoken Marathi but was unable to attain fluency when it came to speaking the language.

During his interment at the Yerwada Jail in Pune in 1930, Gandhi took the opportunity to polish his Marathi and translated seven abhangs of the Bhakti saint Tukaram from Marathi to English. He was deeply influenced by the poet-saint. In Yerwada Jail, Gandhi asked Kalelkar to teach him Marathi. Kalelkar taught him using textbooks and Gandhi made substantial progress. When it came to handwriting, he was influenced by the references in ‘Dasbodh’, written by Samartha Ramdas, to how it should be.

A narrative, albeit a stilted one, suggests that Gandhi and Lokmanya Bal Gangadhar Tilak, the pre-eminent nationalist leader of that era and the first pan-Indian mass leader, were opposite poles. But Tilak appreciated Gandhi despite any differences and referred to him as a ‘Mahatma’ in his introduction to a biography of Gandhi written by Avantikabai Gokhale in 1918. This is the first biography of Gandhi in Marathi.

After Tilak’s sudden demise in Mumbai on August 1, 1920, Gandhi was among those who shouldered Tilak’s bier, a metaphor for him taking on the Lokmanya’s baton after his demise. An account, the provenance of which may be uncertain, says that when Gandhi tried to touch the vimana (a bamboo chair used for the final journey of saints and religious figures) with Tilak’s mortal coils, a voice from the crowd tried to prevent him from doing so, saying: ‘You are not a Brahmin’. Gandhi stopped, thought for a moment and then replied: ‘Public servants have no caste’. The other bearer of Tilak’s mortal body was Maulana Shaukat Ali, the leader of the Khilafat movement.

That day, Gandhi also returned his ‘Kaiser-E-Hind’ title and launched the Non-Cooperation Movement, indicating that one leader had passed on and another had immediately taken his place.

Tilak had not left a political heir, and attempts by his associates to evolve a collective leadership eventually came to naught. Gandhi gradually cemented his position as the supreme leader of the Congress and broad-based it to include the masses, sought religious reform and emancipation of untouchables. This was resented by some Brahmins, who formed the core of Tilak’s support base. They felt that they were being sidelined. Gandhi’s espousal of non-violence, albeit in a militant form, was looked down upon by those who believed in Tilak’s muscular nationalism.Image
Image
Image
As sociologist Ashis Nandy notes, Gandhi worked to simultaneously subvert the Brahmanic and Kshatriya orthodoxy and the British colonial system. He threatened to alter the basic characteristics of Indian society by making its cultural periphery its centre, which went against upper-caste interests.

Though many Tilakites, such as Kakasaheb Khadilkar, accepted Gandhi’s leadership, some others like B.S. Moonje and N.C. Kelkar held out and were contemptuous of the Mahatma’s ways. The growing communal cleavage between Hindus and Muslims and the emergence of Savarkar’s leadership in the late 1930s added grist to this sentiment. The general opinion of the Tilakites towards Gandhi can perhaps be summed by the comment of Tilak’s guru ‘Brahmarshi’ Annasaheb Patwardhan: “Changla, parantu akheris shamloch.” (Good man, but eventually a wimp).

In the 1930s, the social alliance between Congress leader N.V. ‘Kakasaheb’ Gadgil and Keshavrao Jedhe, a doyen of the non-Brahmin movement, ensured that the non-Brahmins and adherents of the Satyashodhak movement in Maharashtra joined the Congress in large numbers. This social alliance between Brahmins and non-Brahmins is referred to as the Jedhe-Gadgil pact. Gandhi’s non-Brahmin (Modh Baniya) origins may have played a significant part in attracting the non-Brahmins and the Marathas to the Congress. This helped the non-Brahmins overcome their scepticism of Brahmin politicians. The Bahujans gradually became the backbone of the Congress in Maharashtra. It was in this decade that the Congress achieved the status of a mass-based party in the state.

Gandhi’s leadership and the growing presence of non-Brahmins in the Congress, coupled with the parallel growth of organisations like the Hindu Mahasabha, Democratic Swaraj Party and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, gradually estranged a section of Brahmins from the Congress. This, coupled with the gradual and systemic indoctrination of young minds towards right-wing ideologies and against Gandhi's creed and the rising riding of communal violence during the Partition era, laid the seeds of Godse’s infamous act in 1948.Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dhaval Kulkarni (धवल कुलकर्णी) 🇮🇳

Dhaval Kulkarni (धवल कुलकर्णी) 🇮🇳 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @dhavalkulkarni

Dec 30, 2023
This is a long thread on the #restaurants I have eaten in 2023. This covers #Mumbai, #Delhi and #Pune.

#Food #food #MumbaiFood #Pune #PuneFood #Mumbai #Delhi #DelhiFood #eatingout #khaugiri #khawayya #hotel #hotels #foodscene

Hotel Gomantak Yashwantashram:

No frills joint located bang outside the Grant Road (West) railway station. Good place for coastal foodImage
Moti Mahal Restaurant, Dariyaganj, New Delhi

The place where butter chicken is said to have originated. The butter chicken you get here is different from the 'tandoori chicken shreds served in oily gravy' stuff that is served elsewhere. Try the brain curry and kababs too...

Must visitImage
Image
Image
After eating at Moti Mahal, top it up with desserts from Cool Point Shahi Tukda across the road. Try the shahi tukda and kheer

#NewDelhi #OleDelhi #Delhi #Food #desserts Image
Read 33 tweets
Sep 28, 2023
The outrage over the refusal of a Gujarati-dominated housing society to allow a #Maharashtrian woman to rent an apartment/ office at Mulund in #Mumbai is not the first such instance of housing apartheid directed at #Marathi speakers in their own capital. The roots of this discrimination run deep in #history.

Some political activists got together and ensured that the father-son duo in the Mulund society apologised to the woman. But soon, it will be back to business for them. At least, until the next outrage…

Even today, there is no clarity over whether that silly "rule" which was cited as the basis for the denial has been rolled back.

Thread

#Marathi #Maharashtra #MarathiIdentity #Marathipan
One must note that while the liberal intelligentsia is quick on its feet to denounce any expression of nativist, pro-Marathi sentiment in Mumbai, they often ignore similar regional and linguistic chauvinism, sub-nationalism and xenophobia in their own states. They also fail to acknowledge that opportunities are often secured through networks linked to caste, linguistic and regional identities with merit per se taking a back seat.

#Mumbai was a part of #Maharashtra in the geographical, historical, and socio-cultural sense. #Marathi speaking groups like the Agaris, Kolis, Bhandaris, Pathare Prabhus, Pachkalashis etc populated the clutch of islands that make today's Mumbai. These indigenous residents had to eventually pay the highest price for Mumbai's 'development.'

Marathi merchant princes and entrepreneurs like Rama Kamat Lotlikar and Jagannath 'Nana' Shankarseth Murkute, and the middle and labour class have built Mumbai brick by brick over the centuries and so have people like Nagu Sayachi and Raosaheb Papanna, who spoke Telugu but were culturally Maharashtrians. Economic migrants from other states came here later because they saw opportunities here and because they felt Mumbai was the mythical El Dorado, the city of gold.

Anyone denying this reality are living under a rock, or perhaps, they are THE rock.
The Samyukta Maharashtra movement had to fight tooth and nail to ensure that Mumbai was retained as part of Maharashtra and was not hived out as a union territory or merged with Gujarat as big money and capitalists wanted it to. The point to be noted is that the leaders and foot-soldiers of Samyukta Maharashtra also included the Telugu-speaking working class and journalists and activists like Va. Ra. Kothari, a Jain, who were Maharashtrians by conviction and belief. Maharashtra secured Mumbai on 1 May 1960 after the martyrdom of 106 people. Those who wanted to usurp Mumbai by hook or crook have certainly not forgotten this "slight!"

Mumbai had a strong working-class movement. This was broken down after mill owners, politicians, bureaucrats, builders, and the underworld colluded to sell off lands on which the textile mills stood. This was a barbaric case of dispossession. The mills were syncretic spaces and supported a strong manufacturing ecosystem. This was broken down. The communal strife in Mumbai during the 1990s owes much to this. The same story repeated itself when it came to the engineering units.
Read 7 tweets
Jul 11, 2023
Malabar Hill is the most prestigious & well-guarded neighbourhood in Mumbai. It houses ministers, bureaucrats & the elite. The Raj Bhavan is also located here. In the 1970s, there was a robbery in Raj Bhavan, that too from the Governor's bedroom! #thread #MumbaiPolice #history





Nawab Ali Yavar Jung was the Governor of Maharashtra from 1970-76. Then, the Governor used to stay in Pune during the monsoons.
When Ali Yavar Jung returned to Mumbai from Pune, he was shocked to find that his cupboard in his bedroom in the Raj Bhavan had been raided. His suits, shervanis and clothes had been stolen. His Padma award medal had also been stolen.
Read 18 tweets
Jul 2, 2023
The latest episode of #Maharashtra’s Game of Thrones saw #AjitPawar split the #NCP & become the deputy chief minister. Let us analyse the impact on the major players in the game
#SharadPawar #MaharashtraPolitics #NCPSplits #politics #BJP #ShivSena #DevendraFadnavis #EknathShinde
Eknath Shinde:

The ruling coalition in Maharashtra is now dealing with a problem of plenty. It now includes three parties, the #BJP, chief minister #EknathShinde’s #ShivSena, and now #AjitPawar and his men from the #NCP.
Ajit Pawar’s defection comes as a setback to Shinde as now, the BJP has a more dependable ally in Maharashtra. This has significantly reduced the elbow space available to Shinde.
Read 24 tweets
Jun 30, 2023
#Hindutva zealots like #SambhajiBhide claim that #MahatmaGandhi's last fast in January 1948 was meant to force India to pay #Rs55crore to #Pakistan. It is also claimed that Gandhi indulged in #Muslim appeasement, but what is the reality?
#thread #history #Gandhi #NathuramGodse
The fast was a moral form of protest to ensure communal amity and cessation of hostilities between Hindus and Muslims in India. Gandhi also wanted to ensure the safety of the Hindu and Sikh minorities in Pakistan.
Gandhi planned to ensure that the Hindu and Sikh refugees in India went back to their homes in Pakistan, just as he wanted India’s Muslims to stay back in this country.
Read 38 tweets
Jun 28, 2023
Heard #SambhajiBhide's unhinged rant against #MahatmaGandhi & #MahatmaJotibaPhule. Bhide claims that Gandhi and Phule were anti #Hindu & were given the 'Mahatma' title by the Christ Seva Sangh from Sweden. This thread is meant to set the record straight
#history



It was in a function on 11 May 1888 in the Koliwada hall at Mandvi in #Mumbai that the masses conferred the 'Mahatma' title on #Phule to honour him for his selfless service.
#JotiraoPhule
It was in 1910, the year of his assassin #NathuramGodse's birth that #Gandhi was first referred to as a 'Mahatma' by his friend Pranjivan Mehta in a letter to Gandhi's guru Gopal Krishna Gokhale.
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(