The Cultural Tutor Profile picture
Feb 4, 2024 23 tweets 12 min read Read on X
This is the Lonely Castle, a 2,000 year old tomb in Hegra, an ancient city in Saudi Arabia.

It's a perfect example of "rock-cut architecture" — when you carve a whole building out of stone.

And there are plenty more places like it, all around the world... The "Lonely Castle" at Hegra, Saudi Arabia
There is something instinctively awe-inspiring about rock-cut architecture.

To carve a building out the living stone of the earth feels elemental.

Nothing artificial here, only solid rock. Everything is part of one great whole. Monolithic, ancient, mysterious. Ad Deir, Petra
It's also a technical marvel.

This is construction in reverse — rather than building up bit by bit you are removing parts, taking away rather than adding.

Just as a sculpture is carved from a single block, this is architecture-as-sculpture... sculpture you can walk inside. Bhima Ratha, Mamallapuram, Tamil Nadu, India
Over the millennia four types of rock-cut architecture have emerged.

First... tombs.

Like these, made in the time the of ancient Kingdom of Lycia over two thousand years ago, in modern-day Turkey, as a rock-cut necropolis for kings and princes.

Image
Image
Image
Sometimes carving tombs out of the rock was necessary because of a lack of other durable materials — an advantage of rock-cut architecture is that it will last.

As at Hegra in Saudi Arabia, where the so-called "Lonely Castle" was built by the Nabataeans two thousand years ago. Image
What king would not want their tomb to outlast the generations to come?

Like Darius the Great, King of the Persian Empire, whose colossal tomb survives — along with several others — at the rock-cut necropolis of Naqsh-e Rostam in Iran.

This is two and a half thousand years old. Image
The second type of rock-cut architecture is the most common: temples and churches.

Like Lalibela in Ethiopia, where King Gebre Meskel had fourteen churches carved from the hills, connected by tunnels and passages, to recreate his own Jerusalem in the 13th century.
Image
Image
Christians who lived in Cappadoccia, Turkey — a region with a rich heritage of rock-cut architecture — had little choice but to carve churches for themsleves into its hillsides.

Simple at first, when hiding from Roman persecution, but later on a grander scale. Image
The strange thing about many of these rock-cut churches is that they are designed as if they had been built normally.

The same columns and capitals are used, the same vaults and arcades, even though it wasn't necessary.

A peculiar form of architectural skeuomorphism.
Image
Image
In any case, nowhere has rock-cut architecture been perfected and developed as in India — here there are more rock-cut buildings than anywhere else on earth.

The most famous example is the vast complex at Ellora, a place that defies explanation and fires the imagination.
Image
Image
But Ellora isn't unique.

India is filled with places like it, whether whole temples with multiple stories cut into mountainsides or large boulders sculpted down and hollowed out.

For centuries it was normal to carve temples from the earth rather than "build" them.
Badami Temples
Undavalli Caves
The Ajanta Caves are another fabulous example — a vast network of cave-temples, monasteries, and shrines, all richly painted and filled with sculpture.

These artists and architects have bequeathed beautiful cultural treasures to posterity.

Image
Image
Image
Some of the oldest rock-cut architecture in India is the Barabar Caves, dating back to the reign of Ashoka the Great in the 3rd century BC.

They feature unusual interiors where the stone has been polished to perfection so that it has a mirror-like surface.
Image
Image
The examples go on and on — there are literally thousands of such temples in India.

Pandavleni Caves
Pandavleni Caves
Mahishasuramardini Cave Temple
The third type of rock-cut architecture is urban — when we carve a place to live, a settlement, into the stone.

Petra is the best example of urban rock-cut architecture, and is indeed the most famous example of rock-cut architecture full stop. Image
And for good reason — this is a rock-cut city.

It was created by the Nabataeans, an ancient kingdom who traded and fought with, among others, the Romans.

This was their capital, complete with tombs, temples, a theatre, a water management system, and more.


Image
Image
Image
Image
Not far away is another Nabataean town usually called "Little Petra".

Though not as large it is still an impressive place, and speaks to the power and sophistication of the Nabataeans.

Here there is a dining room carved into the sandstone... with ancient paintings on the walls.
Image
Image
But not all rock-cut cities are quite so grand.

Cappadoccia, mentioned already, has been home to rock-cut settlements for millennia, partly because of its soft stone.

Here were carved houses of all sizes, castles, churches, and even toilets.

Image
Ortahisar Castle
Image
The fourth kind of rock-cut architecture is sculpture.

Rather than using a single block of stone... artists carved whole mountainsides instead.

Mount Rushmore is an example, or Abu Simbel in Egypt, made for Ramesses II in 1200 BC, an eternal monument to the mighty. Image
Rock-cut sculpture has a particularly rich heritage in China — like the Leshan Buddha, which was the largest statue in the world for one thousand years. Image
But, even if not quite as large, the rock-cut art of the Longmen Grottos are perhaps more impressive.

The amount of sculpture here (and elsewhere in China, for example at Dazu) is almost incalculably large, all of it varied and exquisitely crafted. Image
Of course, the line between rock-cut sculpture and any other form of rock-cut architecture is easily blurred... but is that not the beauty of it?

These are miracles of engineering, design, architecture, and imagination. Cave 26 at Ajanta
Rock-cut architecture feels like a unique form of building, a category of its own wholly unlike anything else.

These monoliths were time-consuming, expensive and difficult... but they have lasted for millennia and speak to us across that gulf of time.

Wondrous. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Cultural Tutor

The Cultural Tutor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @culturaltutor

Jun 19
This 143 year old church in Glasgow is going to be demolished and replaced with a block of 32 flats.

New homes are needed, but this is surely not the way to do it. Image
Image
The Hillhead Baptist Church in Glasgow, built in 1883, is not an extraordinary historical building.

It's a typical and relatively plain neoclassical (using the word colloquially) church, made of stone.

But it's still rather pretty and it's been around for a very long time. Image
It was given listed status in 1970 and concerns over its condition were raised in 2000.

In 2004 the congregation left and it bounced between proposed developers (deteriorating all the while) until 2017, when the current developer took over.

The roof was removed in 2022. Image
Read 22 tweets
Jun 18
Which would you want to live in? Image
Art Nouveau was about imbuing every single part of a building, including all its furniture and fittings, with the curves of nature.

Rather than being inspired by the past, by historical decorations, this was about finding a new and authentic source of ideas. Image
But they didn't just imitate nature; the designers of Art Nouveau adopted its general principles.

And the result is that every single thing they designed makes you feel like you've never seen it before.

A century later and even their fireplaces still look futuristic. Image
Read 13 tweets
Jun 10
Who's to blame for boring architecture? Image
Politics and architecture don't map onto one another very well; trying to understand what leads to good architecture through political "isms" doesn't really get us anywhere.

While the USSR was building a baroque metro system, the USA was building modernist skyscrapers: Image
So the architecture debate is very strange, because opposing "sides" feel obliged to defend things that don't match their other views.

Some people want more "traditional" architecture, and others defend "modern" architecture.

These are, broadly speaking, the supposed "sides". Image
Read 25 tweets
Jun 8
Taking decoration away from buildings is like creating a world where trees never have any leaves: Image
The biggest difference between how we build now and how we used to build (in terms of appearance) is that we no longer decorate anything.

There are thousands of other changes (regulations, materials, size) but this is the one that people notice. Image
And this was, partly, a conscious aesthetic choice.

If you look at the early modernists like Adolf Loos and Le Corbusier, they are very open about their belief that decoration was no longer necessary.

As Loos said, famously: Image
Read 25 tweets
Jun 3
The truth about minimalism: Image
"Minimalism" is badly misunderstood, but that's not really anybody's fault, because we're living in a time where it feels like minimalism is the dominant aesthetic.

Everything from buildings to bollards are designed the same way: simple, no details, little variety or colour. Image
And so, because they're simple, we call it "minimalism".

But minimalism was never just about keeping things simple.

The point of minimalism is using beautiful materials to make useful things (like this chair), not making things as bland and greyscale as possible. Image
Read 25 tweets
Mar 3
Friedensreich Regentag Dunkelbunt Hundertwasser is the best modern architect you've never heard of.

His philosophy was simple. As he said:

"The straight line is godless and immoral."

If there's any building you can think of, he made it look like something from a dream... Image
Accommodation at a children's hospital in Essen, Germany, from 2005: Image
A kindergarten in Frankfurt, opened in 1995: Image
Read 23 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(