The CDC wants to stop telling people to isolate for five days when they are sick with COVID. This is a reckless, anti-public health policy that contravenes science, increases disease spread, and puts everyone at greater risk. 🧵
The truth is COVID is still killing and disabling way too many people, and too many are locked out of society and can’t even access medical care safely due to high levels of COVID transmission. We still need strong isolation guidelines and better public health protections. /2
People look to the CDC for science-based guidance. But this policy change goes against the science and will cause more misinformation, misleading people to think that they can’t spread COVID if they “only” have “mild” symptoms. /3
The CDC claims that levels of immunity warrant a shift, but this is misinformation. It’s true that we are in a different phase than 2020, but thousands are still dying from COVID every week, millions have Long COVID, and every reinfection puts people at increased risk. /4
This is a reckless and fatalistic comment. While it’s true that many people conceal their sickness, the solution isn’t to make doing the wrong thing acceptable. Public health shouldn’t be a race to the bottom. /5
Instead of throwing its hands in the air and rubber-stamping disease spread, the CDC should be keeping its isolation guidance, while doing a lot more to normalize the wearing of N95 masks, which would reduce the harm from those who are going out when sick. /6
This is logic is highly flawed. Governments should push for increasing structural supports like free N95 masks, more paid sick leave, and clean air infrastructure. These policies would do more to help workers, than green-lighting policies that would make workers more sick. /7
Using only “clinical symptoms” to determine when to stay home doesn’t make sense as you can spread COVID without symptoms, and studies show many people hide or underplay their symptoms, which leads to disease spread. /8
The main force driving the CDC’s COVID isolation policy change isn’t science, it’s business groups. And it will lead to increased exploitation of workers, and make workers more sick. /9
The last time the CDC weakened its COVID isolation guidance, it did so due to pressure from airline CEOs. The same corporate pressures are causing the CDC to go against science and public health now. /10
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
BREAKING: The United States has recorded its first fatal case of H5N1 bird flu.
The death was reported by the Louisiana Department of Health. The patient contracted H5N1 after exposure to a combination of a non-commercial backyard flock and wild birds.
Please note that there still is no evidence of person-to-person transmission, which is why public health departments assess the *current* risk as low to the general public. People who work on poultry or dairy farms are most at risk.
Protective measures you can take include:
- Avoiding sick or dead animals
- Avoiding uncooked food product
- Wearing a well-fitting mask, gloves, and other PPE
- Getting your seasonal flu vaccination (to reduce the risk of coinfection)
As a scientist who is the director of science communication for the medical center of a major university, my advice is:
Please don't rely on an economist who has spread misinformation about COVID to advise you about how to effectively message on public health.
Oster's work has been embraced by right-wing think tanks such as the Manhattan Institute and the Cato Institute. Her audience is affluent parents who seek permission to disengage from the social contract and ignore harmful impacts to the working class and people of color.
Here's a horrendous example of COVID misinformation spread by Emily Oster in 2020, which has been proven wrong by research many times since. Please do not listen to any of her advice about public health.
The current admin has failed to adequately address the ongoing and long-term impacts of COVID. They have been rightfully criticized and should continue to be held accountable.
However, a Trump win will make things worse, resulting in many more deaths and people becoming sicker.
Trump will accelerate mask bans, restrict vaccine availability, reduce healthcare access, stop clean air efforts, block Long COVID treatment funding, dismantle health agencies etc.
The outcome of the election will critically impact COVID and public health policy for decades.
What’s tragic is that the CDC’s own study showed that most people are likely to take precautions like wearing a mask when they are alerted that COVID transmission levels are high.
However, most people are unaware of true transmission levels.
Hearing people being turned away from CVS because they say the bridge program doesn’t cover the updated vaccines. A Washington Post reporter also heard this from the CDC.
Why has the CDC not updated their website to make this clear, and why are there not more stories on this?