Prof Julia Steinberger Profile picture
Feb 17 13 tweets 2 min read Read on X
It's becoming clear to me how generalised Western Islamophobia has prevented "us" (media, politicians, public...) from truly understanding the violent, extreme Zionism that rules Israel. For instance:
1⃣ we recognise indoctrination of children by ISIS, but not by Zionist orgs.
1/
But Zionist organisations teach children false history and indoctrinate them into violence against Palestinians and Arabs more generally.
2⃣ we recognise violent terrorism as 'belonging' to Islam, but we fail to recognise the long patterns of violent terrorism ...
2/
associated with Zionism, including Nakba(s), domestic & international assassinations, harassment, participation in various conflicts.
3⃣ we understand how extreme factions in the Muslim world can take over entire societies and control them by propaganda, fear, ...
3/
and violence (Iran, Afghanistan ...), but for Israel, we assume that it is a liberal, progressive democracy, without recognising the very same aspects of anti-democratic extremist violence and coercion at play.
4/
I am sure there are other examples. My point is that our pervasive Islamophobic framework of Muslim = violent, backwards, indoctrinated, fanatic, and Jewish = liberal, educated, democratic, progressive, advanced, misleads us in understanding what is happening within Israel.
5/
This occurred to me in seeing how absolutely fanatical & glibly, triumphantly anti-human so many Israeli accounts on here are. It reminded me of the worst corners of far-right neo-Nazis, Trump & Putin supporters. These are people who sound as though they are indoctrinated ...
6/
into a cult of absolute fanaticism and violence. And my conclusion is that they *are* indoctrinated, that mainstream Zionism is such a violent fanatic ideology, but that somehow the Western world is incapable of recognising it as such because of our knee-jerk Islamophobia.
7/
And because our media and politicians are incapable of recognizing mainstream Zionism as a violent, fanatic cult, with a long history of indoctrination, terrorism and social control, they follow along and are (almost) all complicit in genocide.
8/
As usual, I am probably slow in figuring this stuff out. But it's why history of different Jewish movements, the violent history of Israel, and the takeover of what is now mainstream Zionism matter so much. They are the reality. Nothing is so dangerous to a cult as reality.
9/
I should add that as a half Jewish child, with Israeli family friends, I was exposed to some of this (land without a people for a people without a land, some children's books, etc). It took contact and friendship with Palestinians to learn that this was not, by far, ....
10/
the whole story. Many people here are learning a different history, but it is still not being communicated or acted upon by (most of) our media or politicians.
And another question no one dares to ask: what happens to millions of indoctrinated Zionists? What deradicalisation
11/
program could possibly work at that scale? These are people joyfully convinced & complicit in the worst violence. Facing reality would shatter their selves, their ways of life, the foundations of their existence. Many former Zionists will have to spend a considerable ...
12/
chunk of their lives working to figure this out: with what support, with what organisations?
Anyway. Free Palestine, and may the violent blot of Zionism be lifted from everyone in our lifetimes.
End/

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Prof Julia Steinberger

Prof Julia Steinberger Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JKSteinberger

Feb 14
Speaking of UK institutions sliding into fascism, the new social media policy of my former employer, @UniversityLeeds is a piece of work.

Based on this policy, a whole bunch of vital communication would be banned.
1/
hr.leeds.ac.uk/info/83/social…

Image
Image
1⃣ Campaigns like fossil fuel divestment could not call out "Petroleum@Leeds", the Leeds institute funded by fossil fuel companies and advancing their interests, since it would (absolutely rightfully) bring the university into disrepute.
2/ Image
2⃣ Campaigns for Palestinian human rights, and Boycott-Divest-Sanctions could not draw attention to a Leeds Uni chaplain going to participate in ongoing genocide as a reservist for the IDF, ditto.
3/ Image
Read 8 tweets
Feb 12
Honestly it is hard to do any kind of work right now, between the accelerating of planetary destabilisation and the breakdown of any pretence of international law and human rights.
It's hard to breathe, even.
There has to be a way of working towards good. There has to be.
1/
One thing that has been very striking is that the neoliberal (or whatever this is) world order is in some ways even worse than aristocracy or theocracy. With aristocracy or theocracy, from time to time, by chance, a few decent people occur who can shift things for the better.
2/
But this world order selects for selfishness, ruthlessness, sacrifice of others. So the ruling elite have nothing: no ethics, no compassion, no principles at all. Just a self-justifying belief that they got to the top by merit and violence, and that others deserve to suffer.
3/
Read 13 tweets
Feb 4
Which is one core reason why the green transition must also be a sufficiency and equity transition: the less energy we use, the less of these minerals need to be dug up.
And also why the database @OurWorldInData should include material use. The choice *NOT* to account ...
... for materials is an explicitly political one. For CO2 emissions, we see some decoupling with GDP, even if it is not universal or fast enough. For materials, there is none. Accounting for materials puts the lie to green growth. Material use is a core part of environmental...
... and social exploitation and harm. Refusing to account for the material impact of economic activities is not a scientific choice, as @OurWorldInData has tried to pretend, but an ideological one, designed to obscure scientific evidence against green growth.
Read 4 tweets
Jan 9
3 full months of ACCELERATING genocide in Gaza & there is something that paralyses me: what could possibly ever cause anyone, apart from the most exceptional monster, to justify this?
I know Hannah Arendt answered this question. I know the monster is banal & unexceptional.
A 🧵.
I know/knew people who support this. I know/knew people who soft-pedal their criticism out of regard for the perpetrators. I know/knew people who are trying to play 'greater good' long term games in their reasoning. I know/knew people like this. I should understand. I don't.
2/
I am trying to categorise the arguments I have heard.
1⃣ "I feel scared/attacked." Here, the person sees themselves as a victim being defended by the genocide of others, that sees any/all attacks on Israel as intolerable, with the total elimination of Palestine as response.
3/
Read 13 tweets
Dec 14, 2023
Lots of people (not that many actually lol) are asking me my opinion on COP28. Here it is.
1. Loss and Damage fund major breakthrough thanks to Hana Al-Hashimi, no thanks to Al Jaber.
2. OF COURSE fossil fuel companies and petrostates will do everything to stop climate action.
🧵
I wrote about this earlier this year and don't have much to change. ""We continue to witness the rise and triumph of the fossil fuel industry over our societies."

3. I don't want to write about climate any more because the climate science community ...
2/ climatica.lamarea.com/climate-2023-j…
Image
... frankly by and large are chickenshits who refuse to give a rats ass or speak up against human rights violations, and it makes me trust my colleagues a whole heck of a lot less and it makes me unwilling to talk about "climate" and "sustainability" and "degrowth" ...
3/
Read 5 tweets
Dec 10, 2023
I have something unformed to say, and it's not safe to speak without the right dose of nuance these days. It makes understanding worse, or entails disproportionate consequences. But here goes:
Palestinians have a right to self defence, including violence. But violence sucks.
1/
I am seeing a lot of people, both pro-Palestinian and tired/uncreative around climate, advocate for potential further violence as a means to an end. And none of these people have (a) first-hand experience of violence (b) the slightest strategic notion of how it might help irl.
2/
It's all just grief and despair and a desire to put everything "back on the table", some kind of edginess. Also a romanticising of past resistance which had violent parts. This last one I can understand, because we are taught history SUPER badly on all sides.
3/
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(