Just in: White supremacist Robert Rundo will be released from jail after a federal judge dismissed all criminal charges over violence at pro-Trump rallies.
Judge Cormac Carney believes Rundo was selectively prosecuted instead of "members of Antifa and related far-left groups."
I was in the courtroom this morning when Judge Carney announced his decision.
He rejected prosecutors' request to keep Rundo in jail pending appeal to the 9th Circuit (which currently is considering booting Carney from another case entirely).
I'm camped in courthouse lobby waiting to see if Rundo actually does walk out of here.
"I don't think it's right that Mr. Rundo spends another minute in custody," Carney said.
But @USAO_LosAngeles already filed appeal notice. How fast can prosecutors do an emergency motion?
I noticed a spike in hits on my website for Judge Carney after his recent 2nd Amendment ruling.
He left the chief judgeship over racist comments then threw a fit over his colleagues' pandemic trial ban that could result in him being booted from a case. legalaffairsandtrials.com/p/doj-asks-9th…
Judge Carney also is retiring from the bench in May, as soon as he turns 65.
I remember he was doing a trial a while back and he told the attorneys he absolutely needed to take a specific day off because it was the only day he could do a retirement benefit workshop.
I’m pretty sure the lawyer who said he’d walk out of the courthouse is wrong because he’ll need to go back to jail to be booked out etc, so I left.
Here’s a photo of Judge Carney on the witness stand. He included it in an order he wrote explaining why the 9th Circuit was wrong to reverse his dismissal of a case over the pandemic trial ban. The DOJ cites it when arguing he’s too personally invested and needs to be removed.
I interviewed Judge Carney in his chambers for a Los Angeles Daily Journal profile in 2018.
The subhead on the article fits today's news: "U.S. District Judge Cormac Carney is unafraid of making controversial calls in criminal cases."
While we're on the subject of Judge Carney, I would be remiss not to remind the masses that he was the judge on Cardi B's mixtape art lawsuit i.e. he's the one who called "Gangsta Bitch Music, Vol. 1" "a larger visual commentary on sexual politics." legalaffairsandtrials.com/p/cardi-b-to-g…
Judge Carney's order grants a motion from Rondo's public defenders to dismiss his indictment because of selective prosecution
Prosecutors filed their emergency motion with the 9th Circuit 30 minutes ago.
They want the court to stay Judge Carney's dismissal order and keep Rundo in jail "because Rundo presents a grave risk of flight, as well as a danger to the community."
Full filing. It seeks 9th Circuit action by tomorrow.
"Due to the district court’s order, Rundo will be released imminently (if the Bureau of Prisons has not already released him), at which point he will be under no bond conditions or travel restraints." s3.documentcloud.org/documents/2443…
From my text messages: “Judge carney refuses to stay his decision pending review? After he dismissed once before? Totally insane.”
Update: Buzz not stopping. (Still nothing from 9th; I don’t expect anything until tomorrow.)
From the article: Carney is close friends with Judge David Carter, whose own high-profile decisions include influential orders regarding Donald Trump’s and John Eastman’s criminal culpability in the 2020 election aftermath and attempted insurrection. legalaffairsandtrials.com/p/white-suprem…
New this morning: The 9th Circuit has halted Rundo’s release.
Stay just issued on U.S. District Judge Cormac Carney’s order from yesterday.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Regarding what exactly Jonathan Majors was convicted of, there's some misinformation out there, including from me.
Both assault charges related to what happened inside the car, and the harassment charges related to what happened outside. He was acquitted on anything having to do with intent.
This means Majors WAS convicted related to Jabbari's finger injury. Jury ruled it was reckless but not intentional, but the assault is for the finger injury.
Majors' attorney is assuming a lot about jury deliberations when she says jurors didn't believe Jabbari about what happened because they said no intent.
The jury convicted Majors of third-degree assault recklessly causing physical injury, and it's for what happened in the SUV.
The same lawyers who represented Cassie in her quickly settled lawsuit against Diddy have sued him again, this time on behalf of a woman who's staying anonymous.
This complaint has a "trigger warning" on the front page, too, just like Cassie's did.
Here's the full complaint:
"This is now the fifth lawsuit filed against Mr. Combs in the last three weeks. Incredibly, the allegations brought by Ms. Doe are in many ways even more egregious than those brought by his prior victims." documentcloud.org/documents/2419…
"Unlike many victims who have come forward after decades, Ms. Doe can prove that she not only met Mr. Combs on the night in question, but was in his studio, in New York City, with him on that night. Remember when viewing these, Ms. Doe was 17 years old."
Young Thug’s lawyer Brian Steel is giving his opening statement this morning. He gave Thugger a quick handshake before he got up from the defense table.
I’ll be watching today. Follow this thread for updates.
“Jeffery Williams was born into an environment, a community, a society that was filled with oppression, despair, hopelessness and helplessness.”
Steel skillfully used this intro about Young Thug’s background to transition into criticism of police and credibility of witnesses.
The prosecutor objected and asked for a sidebar to explain her objection. It had to have something to do with Steel’s statements about police and witness credibility, but Judge Granville does not appear to have told him to stop. It’s all based on Thug’s childhood and upbringing.
I just watched Cesar Pina's live. It's incredible that he blabbed like that.
"I am surprised by the amount of people that are on this live right now."
Like, say, the feds who are bringing felony charges against you that could put you in prison for at least several years?
He's talking about his "haters" and the 20 lawsuits against him, not seeming to understand that a federal wire fraud charge is a lot more serious than a lawsuit and even 20 lawsuits, and @USAO_NJ prosecutors are going to turn out to be the biggest haters he's ever encountered.
Pina acknowledges his criminal charge by talking about how the lawsuits are going to be put on hold. He really doesn't seem to grasp the severity of a federal wire fraud charge and how maybe he shouldn't be talking like this.
Before their sexual encounters became national news, MLB pitcher Trevor Bauer and the woman who accused him of rape discussed what happened in a 27-minute call covertly recorded by police.
Lindsey Hill: "I'm just kind of trying to understand, like, do you think that's OK, like? Or, like, how could you think that's OK? If you, you know, like, if that makes sense."
Trevor Bauer: "Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. I understand."
FULL RECORDING:
I got the recording Monday night and soon fell into a silo while grappling with the magnitude of what I had.
It was tempting to throw the recording online immediately, but there is so much more to this case and all the litigation.
My last article on John Eastman’s California State Bar hearing included this hopefully helpful summary of Judge Carter’s email orders. Full piece in the archives: legalaffairsandtrials.com/p/judge-in-joh…
Eastman mentioned his SCOTUS petition when I asked him about Carter’s rulings after the first day of his state bar hearing back in June. Here’s the full discussion.