THREAD explaining why seizing Russia's assets is a crossing the Rubicon moment for the West.
1/ Property Rights.
The principle that forfeiture of property before conviction is illegal is one of the longest and most cherished in the Western capitalist tradition. It underpins the basic dimensions of our democratic society. As Wiki notes, the US Constitution's Fifth Amendment guarantees that "no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law", a phrase that was derived from Magna Carta.
It was instituted in large part to protect citizens from the overreach of the state.
Due process includes the observation of habeas corpus, the idea that everyone is innocent until proven guilty.
2/ State and central bank immunity.
Ah, you may think. These are not the assets of individuals. These are mainly state assets of either the Russian central bank, the Russian Finance ministry or the Russian Sovereign Wealth fund (though, actually, there are also Russian bank assets and individuals in the mix). Seizing their assets is entirely different.
Well no. The principles of sovereign and central bank immunity are, arguably, even more entrenched in the system.
Take as an example the case of the Afghanistan Central Bank (DAB). On February 21, 2023, the United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York held that DAB is a central bank entitled to jurisdictional
immunity under the Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act and that the court is constitutionally constrained from permitting creditors to seize DAB funds.
Why is it such a big deal? Because sovereign continuity is considered fundamental in the rule-based global order, with the only permitted exception for outright confiscation being for sovereigns that are officially at war with each other.
3/ Reputational issues
It's worth noting that while the assets are widely reported to be situated at Euroclear, in reality, this obscures the fact that Euroclear is merely their custodian. The assets are, according to sources familiar with the situation, mostly sovereign bonds that have been pledged as collateral to the Bundesbank. The corresponding euro liquidity remains frozen on account. If that is true, this explains why the ECB is among the staunchest of opponents to the seizing, and why the Germans in particular are so against the move.
The optics of the Bundesbank, of all the central banks in the world, doing the seizing provides Russia with a highly exploitable propaganda narrative. Not just that the West can't be trusted to preserve sovereign immunity and property rights, but that the Germans are up to their old WW2 tricks in terms of unfairly seizing assets.
But more pertinently, the seizing would skewer any hopes the euro has of surpassing the dollar as the world's top international reserve currency.
On the flipside, defying US/UK pressure to seize the assets could be the making of the euro.
ECB Policymakers will also be acutely aware that seizing Russian assets will build the market and sovereign case for holding reserves in alternative assets like gold, but also (following in the footsteps of El Salvador) bitcoin.
It's worth noting, the National Bank of Poland, one of the biggest champions of seizing the Russian assets, has been aggressively moving more and more of its reserves into gold since the war broke out. More broadly, central banks have been among the biggest net buyers of gold the past year.
Could gold and bitcoin highs be benefiting from such repositioning? I wouldn't discount it.
5/ The workarounds
The 'Wheelbarrow'
Rather than letting the collateral go to waste while it's in our care, this would involve rehypothecating it to raise liquidity for Ukraine, which would be invested in such a way as to create growth and profit. Then when everything's over, the collateral can be returned and nobody is any wiser. A bit like "borrowing" someone's wheelbarrow to sow your fields, then putting it back but still benefiting from the crops that grow in the meantime.
It's just an advance against reparations
This would involve dispensing the assets on behalf of Ukraine at will, on the basis that when the war's over, (and we've won), we can claim it against the reparation bill we will send to Russia. But this is a bit like a landlord spending a tenant's deposit because they are fairly confident the property will undoubtedly get trashed. So high on the hubris meter.
We'll just take the interest
An iteration of the Wheelbarrow, but with much less of a punch. Still complicated.
The tax smokescreen
Asset confiscation is sometimes disguised in the former of extraordinary taxes levied by governments unexpectedly. But this is easier to enforce on private individuals or corporates, and markets still tend to see through the ruse.
Forget about the perception of legality
Drop the perception of legality and suffer the consequences. Or declare war and confiscate according to the Trading with the Enemy Act. (Though that act only applies to Britain).
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵The curious case of the visa outsourcing firms undermining Schengen 🧵1/ The top line on the Polish German border dispute is that Poland has been engaged in a bribes-for-visa corruption scandal, which has seen 1000s of illegal migrants flow into the EU despite the ruling party’s tough official stance on border control and migrants.
2/ This is all true enough and you can read about it👇. But Poland is facing a high stakes election in October which means much of the signal in the story may be being lost. This I think pertains to a much more significant story about Visa processing firms.
3/ Time to familiarise yourself with Dubai-based VFS Global, the world’s leading visa facilitation company that’s now owned by Blackstone and which provides visa facilitation services not just to Poland but about 61 different governments. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/VFS_Global
🧵Today is Nikola Tesla's birthday🐦⬛, July 10. It's also my birthday ... woo hoo. So I've decided to commemorate the day with a longish Twitter thread about the Tesla brand you've never heard of, plus a whole bunch of related curios. Full story is here: the-blindspot.com/its-july-10-so…
1/ Until Elon Musk pumped up the brand value of Tesla, it's fair to say Nikola Tesla's discoveries in the field of electromagnetic engineering and physics had for most of the 20th century been overshadowed by those of his contemporary Thomas Edison.
2/ Despite his many accomplishments, Tesla passed away in 1943 at the age of 86, alone and reportedly penniless, in a room he had rented at the Hotel New Yorker in Manhattan. teslasociety.com/hotelnewyorker…
🧵Bloomberg's Matt Levine writes today about the bank deposit franchise, and how the traditional bank model assumes deposits can be treated as long duration liabilities because customers are loyal and deposits sticky...
2/ But if that's true then all efforts to encourage open banking (so as to make it easier to switch bank accounts) and to bring about "frictionless" finance were inevitably going to pose a risk to financial stability.
3/ With that in mind, this paper based on CFTC swaps data from Lihong McPhail, Philipp Schnabl, and Bruce Tuckman is really worth your time. Not only did they clock this deposit franchise factor ages ago, they unearthed that it was entirely wrong to assume that banks hedge their… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
🧵In the latest Leaked Lunch podcast I sit down with former UBS Libor trader @robilypj to hear his side of the famous interest rate rigging story. We discuss the circumstances leading up to his arrest, the impact the affair had on his well-being and family, what time in prison… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
2/ For those who don’t know the background, Tom Hayes was charged with conspiracy to defraud in 2012, eventually being convicted in 2015 for 11 years. He served five and a half years in prison, at times in some of the UK’s highest security facilities.
3/ Tom tells me about the day he first realised something was not right: “One day, I was pulled off the desk at 11am and walked into a room of the great and the good of senior managers in the city, including the CEO… and he turned around and told me, I was losing my job for… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
If there’s one thing you read today it must be @andyverity’s sensational account of what really happened with Libor rigging. New evidence reveals coordinated manipulation by international central banks. thetimes.co.uk/article/1d409a…
Here are a few of the most shocking extracts from the leaked phone calls (now being serialised in The Times) that show traders - some of whom ended up going to jail - were being coerced into misrepresenting rates by the highest authorities.
And here’s Mark Dearlove, son of former MI6 boss Sir Richard Dearlove, being used as the messenger to pass on the Libor lowballing diktat from government to traders who didn’t want to do it, and in some cases whistleblew but ended up in jail regardless.
**Big** multipolar drop from ECB's Christine Lagarde this afternoon signalling the potential suspension of independent-minded cbanks in favour of aligned interdependence focused on national security objectives (i.e. potential transition to a war economy) ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date…
Here are some key quotes: 1/ "We are witnessing a fragmentation of the global economy into competing blocs, with each bloc trying to pull as much of the rest of the world closer to its respective strategic interests and shared values"
Translation (IMHO) "there's a war coming, and you're either with us or against us."