The Cultural Tutor Profile picture
Mar 7, 2024 25 tweets 9 min read Read on X
These are eight slightly different versions of The Great Wave Off Kanagawa from eight different museums.

So which is the real one? That's the thing — they're all the real one.

Here's a brief history of art's most famous wave... Image
The Great Wave Off Kanagawa is part of a series called Thirty Six View of Mount Fuji, created in 1831 by Katsushika Hokusai.

And so it is only one of hundreds of fabulous designs produced by Hokusai.

Here are four more from that 1831 series. Image
And The Great Wave is not a painting — it's a woodblock print in a style called "ukiyo-e".

The artist would make an ink drawing on paper, to be pasted onto a wooden block and then engraved.

This engraving was used to print multiple copies of the original design. Keyblock for a print by Utagawa Yoshiiku, from 1862
The roots of ukiyo-e are important.

Traditional Japanese art, heavily influenced by that of China, was never about pure "realism" in the same way as European art.

Rather, it sought to capture the essence of a place, the mood of a moment, almost like visual poetry. Mount Fuji in the Autumn by Kanō Tsunenobu (1690)
And it could be startlingly minimalist, like the mysterious and dreamlike Pine Trees Screen by Hasegawa Tōhaku, from 1595.

Such art was usually monochromatic, painted with ink on silk — and notice how little of the screen is actually painted here. Image
Western technoques of perspective entered Japan via Dutch merchants in the 17th century.

But Japanese artists didn't imitate Western painting — they synthesised its methods with their own traditions.

Notice how Ōkyo uses vanishing point in his quasi-abstract Cracked Ice Screen: Image
Hishikawa Moronobu was one of the first artists to develop what has become the highly distinctive ukiyo-e style.

He drew on these disparate themes — Chinese styles, traditional Japanese forms, Western methods — to create something new and cohesive in the 17th century: From A Compendium of Model Gardens
Crucial about ukiyo-e prints is that they were a deeply commercial form of art — they were not "high art", but art for the people.

The middle classes of Edo, Japan's capital, were living lives of increasing luxury, and ukiyo-e prints were both a reflection and part of that. Woman Admiring Plum Blossoms at Night by Suzuki Harunobu
A key moment had come in the 1740s when Okumura Masanobu introduced full colour into the previously two or three-toned prints, a technique known as "nishiki-e".

From one design thousands of prints could be produced and sold. Large Perspective Picture of Evening at Ryōgoku Bridge by Okumura Masanobu (1748)
So a novel, popular artform was born, all about depicting the lives of people who were buying these prints.

And that traditionally stylised depiction of reality endured — artists were unafraid to simplify or alter the real world to craft an impression of a moment. Fireworks at Ryōgoku Bridge by Toyoharu (1770s)
Many ukiyo-e prints depicted the women of the legalised red-light districts in Edo — a sign of the era's hedonism and prosperity.

Take Utamaro's many series with titles like "Beautiful Ladies" or "The Physiognomies of Women": Takashima Ohisa Using Two Mirrors to Observe Her Coiffure on the Night of the Asakusa Marketing Festival by Kitagawa Utamaro (1795)
Or kabuki actors, a form of Japanese theatre involving dance, sumptuous costumes, and stylised drama.

The somewhat mysterious Sharaku produced many such designs in the 1790s.

Theatre-goers could buy prints of their favourite actors, not unlike modern posters. Nakajima Kanzō as Negoto no Chōzō by Sharaku
Hence the name ukiyo-e, which means "Images of the Floating World."

The Floating World was a metaphor for the luxuries, pleasures, and ease of this new urban lifestyle.

So ukiyo-e prints became big business, with hundreds of publishers competing to cater to this market. Sumo Wrestling Scene by Kunisada (1851)
But in the 1840s licentiousness in art was restricted by government reform — and so ukiyo-e turned to landscape.

It was in this situation, combined with a growing domestic travel and tourism industry, that Hokusai rose to prominence.

He even made fishing prints: Image
In 1834 Hokusai made a series called A Tour of the Waterfalls of the Provinces.

He harked back to traditional Japanese landscapes, infused with Buddhist ideals about nature, and presented it with his own, striking visual language.

A world away from European art at the time. Image
Another of the landscape ukiyo-e masters was Utagawa Hiroshige.

With Eisen he produced The Sixty-Nine Stations of the Nakasendō in 1842, a series of views from a major road through Japan.

These were places and scenes with which many people would have been familiar: Image
Beyond landscapes and scenes from urban life, ukiyo-e prints also featured images from mythology and folk tales.

This design was created by Utagawa Kuniyoshi, another of the great 19th century ukiyo-e artists. Saito Oniwakamaru Fights the Giant Carp at the Bishimon Waterfall by Kuniyoshi (1840s)
One of the best designers of this sort of ukiyo-e was Tsukioka Yoshitoshi.

His prints of ghost stories, legendary generals, and warriors brought an unprecedented complexity of form and sense of drama. Image
And, sometimes, ukiyo-e were incredibly playful.

You can see why they had such broad appeal; there was something for everybody.

In some sense these prints are almost like popular entertainment before radio, television, cinema, or the internet. Cats Suggested as The Fifty-three Stations of the Tōkaidō by Kuniyoshi (1850)
So you can see that the difference between a painting and a print isn't trivial.

An oil painting, for example, exists in one place at one time.

Imitations can be made, but without quality photography there can be no truly accurate copies — there is, fundamentally, only one. Image
Unlike prints, which by their nature don't have a single form, but exist as thousands of versions.

Hence museums around the world have slightly different versions of the Great Wave off Kanagawa, all of which are original prints of Hokusai's design.

A different sort of art. Image
After the Meiji Restoration in 1868 Japan opened its borders to international travel and trade — this followed a 250 year period of strict isolation.

Via trade ukiyo-e prints soon flooded Europe, and they quite literally changed the history of art. Image
With their heavily stylised realism, vivid colours, focus on mood, unusual angles, and depiction of ordinary life, ukiyo-e prints were a direct inspiration for the Impressionists and all who followed them.

Van Gogh collected and even made his own copies of Hiroshige prints: Image
One of the last great masters of ukiyo-e was Hasui Kawase, a 20th century artist who led the "Shin-hanga" movement, which sought to revive the methods of traditional ukiyo-e.

His prints are, true to form, fabulously atmospheric and visually striking snapshots of life and nature. Image
So The Great Wave Off Kanagawa isn't a painting but an ukiyo-e print designed for popular consumption and mass distribution — a difference crucial in its appearance, nature, and influence.

None of which prevents it from being one of the most stunning works of art ever created. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Cultural Tutor

The Cultural Tutor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @culturaltutor

Aug 31
We spend more than 90% of our time inside, so why do we design so many of our interiors like this?

Grey carpets, white walls, harsh lighting.

It's generic, boring, and genuinely bad for our physical and psychological health... Image
Not all interiors look like this, but too many do, and more all the time.

Grey carpets, white walls, harsh lighting, neutral colours for details, everything plastic, shiny, and rectangular.

This has become the standard for new buildings (and refurbishments) around the world. Image
A common response is that some people like it, or at least don't mind it.

Maybe, but that's the problem.

The sum of all tastes is no taste at all, and if our aim is simply to make things that people "don't mind" then we end up with blandness. Image
Read 22 tweets
Aug 21
The world's most famous neoclassical buildings are kind of boring and generic when you actually look at them.

It's even hard to tell them apart: which one below is Versailles, or Buckingham Palace?

So here's why neoclassical architecture (although it's nice) is overrated: Image
Buckingham Palace, despite being one of the world's most famous and visited buildings, is essentially quite boring and uninspiring from the outside.

There's a certain stateliness to it, but (like most big neoclassical buildings) it's really just a box wrapped in pilasters. Image
The same is true of Versailles.

Again, it's evidently pretty (largely thanks to the colour of its stone) but there's something weirdly plain about it, almost standardised.

Plus the emphasis on its horizontal lines makes it feel very low-lying, undramatic, and flat. Image
Read 26 tweets
Aug 17
These aren't castles, palaces, or cathedrals.

They're all water towers, literally just bits of infrastructure relating to water management.

Is it worth the additional cost and resources to make things look like this... or is it a waste? Image
These old water towers are an architectural subgenre of their own.

There are hundreds, mostly Neo-Gothic, and all add something wonderful to the skylines of their cities.

Like the one below in Bydgoszcz, Poland, from 1900.

But, most importantly, they're just infrastructure. Image
We don't think of infrastructure as something that can improve how a town looks and feels.

Infrastructure is necessary to make life convenient; but also, we believe, definitionally boring.

These water towers prove that doesn't have to, and shouldn't be, the case. Image
Read 24 tweets
Aug 8
If one thing sums up the 21st century it's got to be all these default profile pictures.

You've seen them literally thousands of times, but they're completely generic and interchangeable.

Future historians will use them to symbolise our current era, and here's why... Image
To understand what any society truly believed, and how they felt about humankind, you need to look at what they created rather than what they said.

Just as actions instead of words reveal who a person really is, art always tells you what a society was actually like.
And this is particularly true of how they depicted human beings — how we portray ourselves.

That the Pharaohs were of supreme power, and were worshipped as gods far above ordinary people, is made obvious by the sheer size and abundance of the statues made in their name: Image
Read 23 tweets
Aug 6
This is St. Anne's Church in Vilnius, Lithuania.

It's over 500 years old and the perfect example of a strange architectural style known as "Brick Gothic".

But, more importantly, it's a lesson in how imagination can transform the way our world looks... Image
Vilnius has one of the world's best-preserved Medieval old towns.

It's a UNESCO World Heritage Site, filled with winding streets and architectural gems from across the ages.

A testament to the wealth, grandeur, and sophistication of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. Image
Among its many treasures is the Church of St Anne, built from 1495 to 1500 under the Duke of Lithuania and (later) King of Poland, Alexander I Jagiellon.

It's not particularly big — a single nave without aisles — but St Anne's makes up for size with its fantastical brickwork. Image
Read 18 tweets
Jul 31
Tell your friends! Your enemies! Your lovers!

The Spanish edition of my new book, El Tutor Cultural, is now available for pre-order.

It'll be released on 22 October — and you can get it at the link in my bio.

To celebrate, here are the 10 best things I've written about Spain: from why Barcelona looks the way it does to one of the world's most underrated modern architects, from the truth about Pablo Picasso to the origins of the Spanish football badge...Image
What makes Barcelona such a beautiful city? It wasn't an accident — this is the story of how the modern, beloved Barcelona was consciously created:

Image
And, speaking of Barcelona, here's why the renovation of the Camp Nou is — although necessary — a shame:

Image
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(