Just a book on a display table at Barnes & Noble, published by Stanford, with this on the back cover:
“Neither a democratic political party nor a terrorist group, Hamas is a multifaceted liberation organization, one rooted in the nationalist claims of the Palestinian people.”
“Demonized in media and policy debates, various accusations and critical assumptions have been used to justify extreme military action against Hamas. The reality of Hamas is, of course, far more complex.”
The book is “Hamas Contained” (a grimly ironic title post-10/7) by Tareq Baconi.
If he had said it’s “not just a political party or a terrorist group,” I’d have been with him. It’s also other things.
But notice how he slips in the “it’s not a terrorist group” line through the side door.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I noted earlier that Inea Bushnaq, the New York woman in Mamdani's Nakba Day video, is from a Bosniak family (Bushnaq = بشناق = Bosniak) that settled in Ottoman Palestine in the 1880s – the same time the first modern wave of Jewish settlers arrived.
As Nuseir Yassin, founder of Nas Daily who grew up in the Galilee village of Arraba, wrote:
"Elders in my Arab village in Israel told me the richest Palestinians sold their land and left first. 80 years later, their grandkids now claim to be displaced victims..."
In Arieh Avneri's extremely meticulous "The Claim of Dispossession" (Routledge, 1984/2017), he notes:
A member of the Bushnaq family, Dr Mustafa Bushnaq, a landowner and member of the Arab Executive, sold the land in the Tulkarem area on which nearby Kfar Yona was established...
Upon visiting Beersheba in 1948, "Ben-Gurion... admired the fine stone buildings, the Arab houses... He liked them so much so he decided to live there. After his death in 1973 he was buried at Sde Boker..."
I've been reading and writing about this place a long time.
Never have I heard the allegation that Kibbutz Sde Boker, built on a desolate plot in the southern Negev and some *50 km* south of Beersheba, is essentially just an abandoned Arab home in Beersheba's old city.
Sde Boker is nearly an hour's drive from Beersheba. In Israel that's considered a long drive. Back in the 40s or 50s it must have taken several hours.
Israel-Palestine historiography is becoming uniquely immune to the most tenuous link to reality.
Mamdani's tweet is propaganda, not history. It's hard to know where to begin.
Perhaps by noting (again) that the "Visit Palestine" poster so beloved of Mamdani's Dismantle-Israel crowd was created by Franz Kraus, an Austrian-Jewish refugee from Hitler, in 1936. Here In Tel Aviv.
More about Franz Kraus:
Born 1910 in Graz, Austria; died 1998 in Tel Aviv.
Arrived in Mandate Palestine from Berlin in 1934, a year after Hitler's rise.
I'm excited to share my first piece with @TheFP: On the invented history depicted in the Oscar-shortlisted film "Palestine 36" (which, as it happens, has nothing to do with my book "Palestine 1936")
"Directed by Annemarie Jacir, with major funding from the British Film Institute, BBC Film, Qatar’s Doha Film Institute, and the Turkish state-run media TRT, Palestine 36 defies—and at times invents—the historical record to rewrite the past in service of a contemporary agenda..."
"It presents the Arab Revolt as a morality play of colonial cruelty and Arab resistance, while rendering its primary targets, the Jews, voiceless pantomime figures...
It is an absence that erases the Jewish community in an act of historical revisionism verging on fantasy."
I’ve read the NY Review of Books for many years, but this is journalistic malpractice:
“Seventy-six years ago, Zionist militias drove more than 750,000 Palestinians from their homes.”
1948 was vastly more complex than this nonsense sentence.
The word “tendentious” doesn’t quite cut it:
“Between 1947 and 1949 armed Zionist militias roamed through Palestine, ethnically cleansing the inhabitants of more than five hundred villages, massacring many, and forcing out an estimated 750,000”