Vandie Profile picture
Mar 21, 2024 16 tweets 5 min read Read on X
In order to understand the history of North America, it's good to review the three very different approaches each of the major colonial powers took with regard to the Indians:

1. French - Trade
2. Spanish - Assimilation
3. English - Land Ownership

Let's go over each: Image
1. French

The French were the greatest traders with the natives. Obviously they envisioned the fleur-de-lis flying over all of North America, but this was to support their primary interest which was mercantile. French trappers and traders wandered the furthest as a result. Image
French weapons dealing caused ceaseless consternation to the English and Spanish, who more tightly regulated trade and had to deal with the result of heavily armed tribes. Many conflicts between the French and their neighbors in the New World could be traced back to this. Image
But this also meant that the French typically enjoyed the best relations with the Indians. French trappers were the most welcome in Indian villages continent-wide and our best ethnographic accounts of first contacts usually come from French sources. Image
It wasn't a coincidence that Lewis and Clark found Charbonneau at the Mandan villages on the Missouri.

Osborne Russell wintered with a Frenchman at a Shoshone camp at present day Ogden, Utah in 1840.

French names all over North America attest to their roaming. Image
2. The Spanish were famously interested in the New World because of the three Gs - God, Gold, Glory. What this meant in practice was a cultural policy of assimilating with the native Indians. The new mestizo race of Latin Americans was born of this widespread mixing. Image
The most religiously devout of the three, the Spanish sent many missionaries who genuinely wished to convert the natives and improve their lives. These Jesuits, Dominicans, and Franciscans worked to spread Catholicism and European culture and practices throughout New Spain. Image
The pre-Columbian populations of Mesoamerica were orders of magnitude larger than the populations north of the Rio Grande. Even after multiple waves of epidemics killed off 90% of the population, there were still many millions of Indians who remained.
What this meant was that there was always going to be a massive population of natives who couldn't possibly be ethnically cleansed or exterminated without great cost to the new Spanish rulers.

Intermarrying happend almost immediately between the Spanish and Aztec elite.
When the Spanish moved into New Mexico in the early 1600s, they brought Aztec and Tlaxcalan families from central Mexico, and the leader of the expedition was married to a great-granddaughter of Montezuma himself. Image
The Spanish crown regularly chastised and punished Spaniards who were too cruel to natives. A Dominican friar named Bartolome de las Casas was a social activist in the 1500s who agitated for humane treatment of the conquered peoples, and was influential at court.
3. The Anglo interactions with the indians were primarily centered on land use issues. Coming from a strong tradition of English common law which emphasized the property rights of landowners, this English worldview of exclusionary land use was antithetical to the native one. Image
English settlers were primarily motivated by land ownership, as opposed to trading, proselytizing, or commodity extraction. Obviously this meant that they had the most intractable conflict with the Indians. The conflict ended only with complete subjugation of the indians. Image
The Anglo did intermarry with Indians to some degree, but the intensity of violence and the small numbers of natives relative to New Spain meant that it never manifested very strongly racially.
However, the Japanese, who fought both the English and Americans in the Pacific theater of World War 2 often remarked at the differences in fighting styles of the two races. They attributed a certain ferocity and stubbornness to the presence of Indian blood in the Americans.
This is only the most cursory summary of North American colonial history, and certainly exceptions are widespread, but I think it's helpful to understand the broad strokes as we examine how these peoples clashed and moved about North America during the Age of Exploration. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Vandie

Vandie Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @VanDiemen_

Jun 26
There are so many obviously incorrect things in this thread that ESL latinas doing flips at 120% leverage could point them out. Dead wrong multiple times, zero domain knowledge. Clearly just screenshotting zillow and making stuff up. I regret that I have to be the one to deboonk:
First he confuses the listing agent with the owner. Carl Armknecht is the listing agent. It says it right there "Listed by:"

Salt Lake Improvement Initiative LLC is the listing brokerage.

The guy saw "LLC" at the bottom of the listing and wrote a whole thread on "corporations own houses bad."

Retarded.Image
The owner is easy to find. Literally everyone who knows anything about how RE works knows to just go to the county assessor's parcel map.

Oh that's weird. It says here that the owner of record is actually F99 Income Fund, LLC. I can see that they own 5 other houses around SLC.Image
Image
Image
Read 12 tweets
May 26
I grew up in a very middle class area, and have since moved into one of the wealthiest neighborhoods in my state. One thing I've noticed is that the people here raise their children very differently than most Americans, so here are just a few very general trends I've seen: 🧵 Image
1. Rich people use contracts with their children. This can be for help buying houses, loans, setting up businesses. It's not because they're scrooges, it's because they recognize that the power of a contract is in managing expectations and avoiding conflict down the road.
2. Wealthy Americans tend to live by their children. They prioritize family and have the means to help kids stay close, usually through down payments on houses. It's super common to see rich kids live in the best neighborhoods within walking distance of mom and dad.
Read 12 tweets
May 7
One of the more interesting takeaways from War Before Civilization is that trade between groups almost always leads to war. This is true at both the tribal and the civilizational level.

It's a constant source of friction. Yes it can increase wealth, but it comes with conflict. Image
Human nature is such that dealmaking leads to disputes. Some parties will inevitably try to come out ahead at the expense of their counterparty. Some will cheat. There may be miscommunications or offenses taken.

And disputes can sometimes only be settled by violence.
Some primitive societies would set up arrangements where different groups were allowed to monopolize certain goods. Some would make the pottery, some would make bows, some would make axes, etc. Taboos developed around only certain bands being allowed to make their special items.
Read 8 tweets
Apr 17
"They don't build them like they used to."

X is filled with takes on the quality of modern residential construction, with the assertion typically being that it was better in the past.

I think that this is partially true, mostly wrong, and misses some key points.

🧵 Image
1. Survivorship Bias

The houses from the past that people see today are the ones that have survived depreciation, aging, abandonment, and natural disaster. Their owners over the years have felt that they were worth the effort and cost to maintain them. Image
These homes are usually timelessly beautiful and in enduringly desirable locations, creating emotional bonds with owners over generations who feel a responsibility to maintain them.

A lot of these houses were also the homes of the Top 1% of society who could afford quality. Image
Read 24 tweets
Jan 22
I found an atlas from 1933 in a thrift store and it had some of the most beautiful maps I've even seen. I scanned the best ones in hi-res, here's a thread:

1. Central America, showing the Panama Canal Zone as US Territory. Image
2. Australia

Depicts Papua New Guinea as part of Australia. Image
3. British Isles

Ireland is independent by this point, and the map uses a lot of Gaelic names. London is smaller than it would be depicted on a modern map. Image
Read 14 tweets
Jan 3
The Rock Springs Massacre was an attack by American miners that killed 28 Chinese in Rock Springs Wyoming in 1885. Angered by wage suppression and incited by organized labor, the whites shot, burned, and mutilated the Chinese men, driving them all completely out of town: Image
Chinese had been coming to the United States in large numbers since 1850. During this period they made up roughly 10% of the population of California and were primarily employed in mining and railroads. They famously helped build the Transcontinental Railroad across the Sierras. Image
Almost exclusively men migrated to America. They would work for years and send the money to family back home. Chinese merchants booked the passages across the Pacific and showed up in San Francisco where they dropped the immigrants off. Almost all were from southern China.
Read 25 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(