Leslie Kajomovitz Profile picture
Mar 24, 2024 7 tweets 8 min read Read on X
Dissecting Gaza's Casualty Figures: Debunking Media Myths with Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health's Report

The latest report from the Gaza Ministry of Health, for March 19, 2024, has provided crucial insights that debunk widespread misinformation regarding the casualty figures in the recent conflict. Contrary to sensationalized media reports claiming 30,000 deaths, the official report confirms 17,571 confirmed deaths, a significant difference that sheds light on the exaggeration of figures.

What makes this report particularly important is that it includes confirmed deaths that also account for individuals missing or trapped under the rubble. This further discredits claims of thousands more unaccounted for and emphasizes the accuracy and transparency of the Ministry of Health's data.

Additionally, comparing this report with data from The Shirin Observatory, known for its meticulous record-keeping of each victim, reveals intriguing details. Out of the 17,571 confirmed dead, only 3% are children under 9 years old, totaling around 150. This translates to less than one child per day since October 7, challenging narratives of widespread child casualties.

Moreover, the age distribution of the deceased is telling, with ages between 18 and 40 accounting for 70% of the dead. This suggests that the majority of casualties are fighters rather than civilians, contrary to claims portraying a high number of civilian deaths.

Another myth dispelled by the report is the notion that 70% of the victims are women and children. In reality, the gender split among confirmed deaths is 44% female and 56% male, highlighting the need for accurate reporting and careful examination of data before drawing conclusions.

It's worth noting that while the Ministry of Health's report provides solid evidence, the United Nations (UN) and certain media outlets have need to be criticized for creating false narratives based on zero evidence. The same reports they quote actually confirm the numbers presented by the Ministry of Health, highlighting a failure in basic journalism and fact-checking.

The Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health's detailed report not only provides clarity on casualty figures but also underscores the importance of fact-checking, responsible journalism, and questioning narratives that lack substantial evidence.
Unraveling the 30,000 Myth: Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health Confirms 17,571 Dead

Recent reports from the Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health have brought clarity to the casualty figures in the recent conflict, revealing that the actual number of confirmed dead is 17,571 out of which 150 are children under 9. This stark contrast to the false narrative of 30,000 casualties circulating in media reports underscores the importance of accurate and verified information in conflict reporting.

The Ministry of Health's report directly challenges exaggerated claims and sensationalized figures, highlighting the discrepancy between factual data and speculative reporting. It's crucial to note that while the report acknowledges "media reports" of casualties to make the math to 30,000 work, there is a notable absence of specific records or identification of individuals in these reports.

It includes confirmed deaths that also account for individuals missing or trapped under the rubble. This further discredits claims of thousands more unaccounted for.

This discrepancy raises questions about the reliability and credibility of the so-called Gaza media reporting, especially when it comes to casualty figures. Without concrete evidence or verifiable data, the inflated numbers presented in media reports lack substantiation and contribute to misinformation and sensationalism.

The Ministry of Health's focus on confirmed deaths, totaling 17,571, provides a clear and reliable picture of the human cost of the conflict. This factual information is essential for understanding the true impact of the conflict and avoiding the spread of false narratives that can distort public perception and fuel unnecessary panic or outrage.

In conclusion, the confirmation of 17,571 dead by the Gaza Ministry of Health serves as a crucial reminder of the importance of relying on verified data and avoiding sensationalized reporting that can mislead and misinform the public.Image
Debunking the 70% Women and Children Myth: With Gaza Ministry of Health Reveals Gender and Age Breakdown

Amidst the the recent conflict, there have been widespread media reports suggesting that 70% of the casualties are women and children. However, a closer look at the data provided by the Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health and The Shirin Observatory it paints a different picture, debunking this myth and providing clarity on the gender and age breakdown of casualties.

According to the Hamas Ministry of Health's report, the gender split among confirmed deaths is 44% female and 56% male. This stark contrast to the reported 70% figure highlights the inaccuracies and misrepresentations in some media reports. The actual gender distribution underscores the need for accurate reporting and fact-checking to avoid perpetuating false narratives.

Furthermore, the age breakdown of casualties from The Shirin Observatory reveals important insights. Children under the age of 18 account for 19% of the total deaths while children under 9 are only 3%, (150 total), challenging claims of a disproportionate number of child casualties. Among the underage victims, male casualties make up 60% of the reported dead, further emphasizing the need for nuanced and accurate reporting that takes into account all demographic factors.

This gender and age breakdown provided by the Gaza Ministry of Health serves as a valuable tool for understanding the true impact of the conflict and dispelling misconceptions propagated by sensationalized media reports. It highlights the importance of relying on verified data and conducting thorough analysis before making sweeping statements about casualty figures.

The discrepancies between media reports and official data also raise concerns about the spread of propaganda and misinformation. Both the media and international organizations like the United Nations (UN) must prioritize accuracy and transparency in their reporting to ensure that the public receives reliable information.

It is imperative that they refrain from spreading unfounded claims and instead focus on presenting verified facts to the public. In conclusion, the Ministry of Health's revelations regarding the gender and age distribution of casualties debunk the 70% women and children myth, emphasizing the importance of responsible reporting and factual accuracy in conflict coverage.Image
Debunking the Myth of 13,000 Children Dead: Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health Confirms Real Numbers

In recent discussions surrounding the conflict, there have been alarming claims that 13,000 children have died. However, a careful examination of the confirmed reports from the Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health reveals a different reality, debunking this myth and shedding light on the actual numbers of child casualties.

According to the data when also crosschecked with The Shirin Observatory, 150 children under the age of 9 have tragically lost their lives. Additionally, approximately 4,900 children between the ages of 10 and 17 are among the confirmed dead. These figures, while heartbreaking, starkly contrast the exaggerated claim of 13,000 child deaths.

Furthermore, the age breakdown shows that children under 18 account for 19% of the total deaths, with 3% being children under 9 and the rest between 10 and 17. This debunks the notion that half of the deceased are children, as reports inaccurately suggested. The accurate statistics provide a more nuanced understanding of the demographic impact of the conflict.

It's crucial for the media to rely on verified data and factual information to avoid spreading misinformation and contributing to the sensationalization of casualty figures. By debunking myths like the claim of 13,000 children dead, the media can foster a more informed dialogue and promote responsible reporting.

In conclusion, the confirmed numbers from the Gaza (Hamas) Ministry of Health regarding child casualties debunk the exaggerated claims and emphasize the importance of accuracy and transparency in conflict reporting, urging the UN to cease spreading propaganda and the media to uphold journalistic integrity.Image
Unveiling Gaza's Casualty Demographics: Insights into the Age Distribution of the Deceased

Amidst discussions about the casualties in Gaza, a crucial aspect often overlooked is the age distribution of the deceased. Recent reports from the Gaza Ministry of Health reveal that 70% of the confirmed dead fall within the age range of 18 to 40. This statistic sheds light on the high possibility that a significant proportion of these individuals are fighters.

The age distribution data challenges narratives that portray the majority of casualties as civilians, particularly women and children. While every loss of life is tragic, understanding the demographics of the deceased is essential for a comprehensive analysis of the conflict's impact.

The predominance of casualties among individuals aged 18 to 40 suggests a heavy presence of combatants or individuals actively engaged in conflict-related activities. This underscores the complexity of the situation and emphasizes the need for nuanced reporting that considers all aspects of the conflict's human toll.

By highlighting the age distribution of casualties, we aim to encourage a more informed discussion about the realities on the ground in Gaza. It's crucial to recognize the diverse demographics of those affected by the conflict and avoid oversimplifications that may distort the true nature of the situation.

In conclusion, the data on age distribution among Gaza casualties points towards a high possibility that a significant portion are fighters, highlighting the multifaceted nature of the conflict and the importance of accurate and comprehensive reporting.Image
Conclusions

❌Debunking the myth of 30,000 dead: Recent data from the Gaza Ministry of Health confirms 17,571 casualties, challenging exaggerated claims.

❌Disproving the 70% women and children narrative: Gender split among casualties shows 44% female, 56% male, contradicting reports of a 70% female casualty rate.

❌Clarifying the 13,000 children claim: Children under 18 account for 19% of total deaths, with 3% under 9 years old and the rest between 10-17, debunking exaggerated child casualty figures.

❌Notable age distribution: 70% of confirmed dead aged 18-40, indicating a significant presence of fighters among the casualties.Image
Sources:
Ministry of Health Report


The Shirin Observatory
vizrt.expert/nextcloud/inde…
shireen.ps/martyrs/year/2…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Leslie Kajomovitz

Leslie Kajomovitz Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @lkajomovitz

Nov 29, 2024
🧵UN PARTITION PLAN: UN Resolution 181
The Question of Palestine, the Creation of the Jewish State, & Steps Towards Undoing Its Creation

On November 29, 1947, the United Nations approved the UN Partition Plan. Since that moment, the UN has repeatedly used this date to take steps toward undoing the creation of the Jewish state, while Israel's independence has been labeled "a Catastrophe."Image
November 29, 1947: United Nations approves UN Resolution 181, UN 's Partition Plan of Palestine. The Resolution was non-binding.

Jews Accepted and celebrated while Arabs rejected it by declaring a "Holy War"
May 14, 1948: Jews declared independence, triggering a war of extermination against the newly established Jewish state. The United Nations failed to condemn the attack. Since then, the United Nations has systematically ignored the safety and security of the Jewish people and state, repeatedly denying their right to exist.
Read 31 tweets
Nov 26, 2024
😳UN's Francesca Albanese seems to have forgotten for a moment that she is on national television and not giving a speech to terror-supporting groups! She appears to have called all Israelis terrorists and then tried to correct herself—not very successfully.

thread of lies during @PiersUncensored on the works, but had to post this, stay tuned for the thread
And since she was on the subject of what Israel could do after October 7th, let's not forget that she believes anything Israel does is illegal. @piersmorgan, how do you invite someone with such views to your show as an "expert"? Your research team needs to do a better job vetting your guests.
And on the subject of what Israel could do after October 7th, we know nothing Israel does is legal, of course nothing it has done since October 9th is "legal", but lets go to her ignorance as an "expert".

International law does not limit a state's ability to exercise self-defense within its own territory. Key international legal principles that support this include:

- Article 51 of the UN Charter, states have the inherent right to self-defense in response to an armed attack. This includes the right to address imminent threats that originate from outside their borders.

- Geneva Conventions (1949, Common Article 1): While the conventions primarily govern the conduct of hostilities, they acknowledge the inherent right of states to protect themselves from external aggression.

- UN Security Council Resolution 1368 (2001): Adopted after the 9/11 attacks, this resolution explicitly recognized the right of states to self-defense under Article 51 in cases of terrorism originating from foreign territories.

@piersmorgan, Francesca appears to have never passed the bar exam in Italy, with no public record of her even taking the exam. She is neither a registered nor a licensed lawyer and has never practiced law. As you can clearly see, she works for the UN yet does not know the UN Charter or the Geneva Conventions she is supposed to base her reports on and has no understanding of the relevant UN resolutions regarding the subject.

In simple terms, she is not qualified to speak on the matter. Once more, your research team did not do their homework.... I would suggest if you ever want to have Francesca Albanese on your show again, that you invite her for a debate with @UKLFI Natasha Hausdorff
Read 11 tweets
Nov 8, 2024
🧵When I hear "we are back to the 1930's", all I have to say in response, at least in 1938, the headlines didn’t lie #Kristallnach #AmsterdamPogrom #NeverAgainIsNow Image
Read 8 tweets
Oct 24, 2024
Who wants to wish the UN a Happy Birthday? 🥳🥳🎊
I will be celebrating #UNDay by sharing their "shiniest" moments since their establishment throughout the day.

The United Nations was officially established 79 years ago, on October 24, 1945, following the ratification the UN Charter by the majority of its signatory countries, including the five permanent members of the Security Council. Was the UN doomed from the start?Image
1945: From its formation the UN has faced challenges upholding the UN charter and its values from the start. Allegations of multiple Soviet spies working in the UN, particularly the presence of individuals such as Alger Hiss, who was accused of being a Soviet spy. Alger Hiss, a U.S. government official who played a key role in the establishment of the UN. Hiss served as a State Department official and was heavily involved in international diplomacy, including helping to draft the UN Charter. #UNDayImage
1946: The UN failed to address early Cold War tensions, particularly the Soviet Union's refusal to withdraw from Iran, displaying the UN’s lack of authority and use #UNDay Image
Read 25 tweets
Aug 23, 2024
Norway, the land of the #NobelPeacePrize has decided that terrorism and human slaughter is the new way to achieve peace. It is time to rename it to the #NobelTerrorPrize

Every single nomination is either a person connected to terrorism or organizations with links to terror organizations such as UNRWA. Why is @NobelPrize even accepting the nominations?Image
Read 5 tweets
Aug 20, 2024
🧵Since the @UN decided to exclude Israelis from their exhibit for International Remembrance day for the victims of Terrorism. I would like @antonioguterres @UNLazzarini to look at 5 of the victims who's bodies were recovered today. #IntlTerrorVictimsDay

Chaim Perri🕯️, Avraham Munder🕯️, Nadav 🕯️Popplewell🕯️, Yagev Buchshtav🕯️, Yoram Metzger🕯️

May their memories be a blessing🕯️Image
@UN @antonioguterres @UNLazzarini Eliyahou Haddad was murdered yesterday with an axe🪓 by Palestinian worker Mohamed Dridi who confessed the motive was "He was a Jew"
This is what your schools create with your indoctrination, people who axe people to death because they are Jews
@UNLazzarini @antonioguterres Image
@UN @antonioguterres @UNLazzarini December 2020..
Esther Horgan52-year-old mother-of-6 found in a forest in northern Samaria with signs of violence, murdered by Muhammad Kabha, 40 year old Palestinian terrorist

@antonioguterres @UNLazzarini
Image
Image
Read 33 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(