Taleed El-Sabawi, JD, PhD Profile picture
Mar 28 14 tweets 4 min read Read on X
Jordan should be trending right now. Protests have been blocking traffic; men have flooded the streets in such large numbers that even the repressive military force in Jordan can’t beat them into submission (something they frequently do); Protesters are chanting for Jordan to open its borders so they can march to Al-Aqsa. The political unrest in Jordan has been at a boiling point for years now.

High rates of unemployment particularly among young men; significant inflation; high housing costs; low wages; skyrocketing gas prices, electricity, groceries…hardly any industry. Repressive import taxes.

And a monarchy that pockets millions of US government aid in exchange for US military access. The monarchy is now holding on by a thread. 🧵 1/
Expect the Jordanian forces to increase their violence against protestors. Expect the U.S. to send in reinforcements in some shape or form—If the monarchy falls, it will not be a U.S. co-opted government that will organically take its place. It will not be an Israel friendly government. Expect the U.S. to meddle as they always have & to do everything they can to keep the monarchy in place. 2/n
Even a UN Ceasefire isn’t enough to make Israel ceasefire or the U.S. to call for Israel to ceasefire. The calculus has changed. The people are reminded yet again how the governments of the world have failed them. Expect more of this around the world. 3/n
Every time there are protests in Jordan, I call my family in Amman to get a sense of how serious it is, because my grandparents are in Amman. Since October, every time I call they have brushed it off as young men being young men. Skirmishes with the armed guard as usual. But today was different. They spoke about not being able to drive in the streets, of the chaos, of the sheer number of human bodies, of the determination to do something to help Gaza—something has changed. This time, it feels different. 4/
Additional important context: Jordan was created in 1946. When Britain divided up the Arab World into nation states. Before that there was free movement & a greater degree of one-ness. So when Jordanians say they there is no difference between us and the Palestinian people or that we are the same people , it is because the British creation of nation states was a Western government forcing the Arab people into its Western constructs. 5/n
There are already plans to start again —at Maghreb tomorrow (sunset)—at the Israeli embassy and doing a sit-in again until dawn, interspersed with prayers. Tomorrow will mark day 5 of protests in Amman.
Looks like the Jordanian monarchy’s security forces has started disappearing protestors/organizers.😞 8/n
@account14678123 @fath0039 There would of course be a transition period to a democratically elected government but it could still happen!
@UmTara_Talal and I do not base what I say on “hearsay” but rather first hand witness accounts & videos. Have you seen the protests? Do you live around them? Have you witnessed what is going on?
Now if you are saying that this won’t result in political change or that Abdullah will not abdicate the throne—that this won’t make a meaningful difference—you could very well be correct. And I do not necessarily know that it will either. As I said in another tweet, it is too early to tell. It is, however, something the world should be paying attention to and watching.
Let me be clear—I don’t expect anything to happen in Jordan overnight. And there is no reason that push for democratic reform has to be accomplished by violence. There are instances in history when giant masses of peaceful protestors have been able to push for policy change & democratic reforms. What I’m saying is—these protests are worth keeping an eye on to watch for attempts by the U.S. to interfere to protect the monarchy and attempts by the monarchy to violently repress the protestors. If these protests continue with the same fervor & if they grow in numbers…then there may be political change. 9/n
@theRealHDumpty @sandraspitzy The U.S. chose to back SiSi… after the coupe 🤷🏽‍♀️.
It made the WaPo:
👇🏽 Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Taleed El-Sabawi, JD, PhD

Taleed El-Sabawi, JD, PhD Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @el_sabawi

Mar 16
Ok some important background/context on Fatah as a political party for those trying to make sense of what is going on…I’ll update this 🧵 if I think of any additional useful context.
1. Although this did not used to be the case, Pres. Abbas (the West Bank’s lackluster leader —of the Palestinian Authority) controls the Fatah party. They have tried to get him to step down for years & those that do are…silenced.
2. Abbas has been on the take from 🇮🇱 for years. (How else do his kids live lavishly abroad?). And Biden proposed that Abbas be the new leader of Gaza —so that should tell you all you need to know right there 🤣
3. Abbas has been known to be a 🐀 & cooperates & helps 🇮🇱 make arrests of any dissidents.
4. Abbas is extremely unpopular in the West Bank right now. Dec poll shows that 90% of those surveyed want him to retire. (see this article for explanations as to why: )
5. Abbas has refused to allow for election since he was elected in 2005. 1/nal-monitor.com/originals/2024…
6. When they had elections 20 years ago, when Hamas was elected in Gaza, the candidates from the competing party was Fatah. 🤷🏽‍♀️ Now—was it a fair election, ie not tampered with etc. 🤷🏽‍♀️ Idk.

7. Fatah doesn’t consider itself a political party…rather a “liberation movement”. But after they signed the Oslo Accord & Arafat was killed Abbas dumped the keffiyeh & put on a suit. Signing the Oslo Accord, meant giving up the armed resistance and this caused tremendous discord in Fatah & many many activists left the movement at this time. 2/n
8. Fatah was founded by Yasser Arafat, Khalil al-Wazir, Salah Khalaf, and Mahmoud Abbas in the 1950s to liberate historic Palestine through armed resistance. It had a military arm—al-Asifah.

9. In the 1960’s the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) was formed. It is a political organization that included members of the various resistance & liberation groups. At outset it was formed by the Arab League & some accused it of being co-opted by Arab leaders.

10. Fatah joins the PLO. Arafat is elected as chairman of the PLO in ‘68.

11. To get the vibe of the PLO & Fatah under Arafat in the 1970s👇🏽(screen shot)



3/namerica.aljazeera.com/articles/2013/…Image
Read 13 tweets
Mar 10
I keep seeing politicians say that they wanted a ceasefire deal before Ramadan. Let me explain why that is -- why some politicians are afraid of the people rising up during Ramadan.

One of the central purposes of Ramadan is ask us to experience hunger and thirst and then to experience what it is like to not be able to eat or drink to quench the thirst or quell the hunger.

It is for an entire month, not just a day or a week, because it is to remind us that for some, this hardship is enduring.

It is encouraged that iftar meals, breaking of the fast every night, be shared with neighbors and friends so that no one goes hungry.

If one is unable to fast because of a medical condition, they can feed another person for a day -- the emphasis is again on remembering those who must go without food or water. 🧵1/n
It is estimated that 1/4 of the world's population is Muslim, many of whom will be fasting for Ramadan. And while they are fasting, they will be thinking of the Palestinians in Gaza who are being starved.

When they cannot take a drink of water to quench their thirst, they will be thinking of the Palestinians in Gaza who cannot drink water because there is none to drink.

When they break their fast at iftar and are enjoying a meal in the evening, they will be thinking about the Palestinians in North Gaza who may be eating animal fodder to break their fasts. Not only will they be thinking about the Palestinians in Gaza, they will be experiencing just a small sliver of the hardship that Gazans are being forced to endure--and even that will feel nearly unbearable to them. Politicians are scared because shared living experience could be enough to see the toppling of Western backed regimes across the world. 2/n
An old friend contacted me yesterday; she is a devout American Catholic. She asked me if it was ok to drink water during the day during Ramadan. She said that this year she was going to try to fast for Ramadan, because it was the least that she could do --since Palestinians were being forcibly starved.
And this, my friends, is the type of act that scares our politicians the most. A devout American Catholic fasting with an American Muslim during Ramadan, sharing a sliver of living experience with the Palestinians in Gaza--

It is one thing to see hunger and thirst, and it is an entirely different thing to experience it, even for just 12 hours a day. 3/n
Read 4 tweets
Mar 6
Ya’ll thought I was being paranoid when I said Homeland Security was monitoring students and facultys’ personal communications. Biden literally put out a memo telling Homeland Security to do this & it was mentioned in his directive on anti-semitism. Anyone on a university campus or working for one should assume that some government contractor is reading all their texts.
As I mentioned in the comments, this is push to instruct Homeland Security to spy on students & faculty at universities & colleges was from Israel’s Foreign Ministry & Diaspora Affairs Ministry that established a task force in Nov. 2023, & created “Israel's strategy against antisemitism on US campuses”. Here is their “multifaceted plan” which they made public. Remember Israel defines Anti-semitism as criticism against Israel.🧵2/n
Source: ynetnews.com/article/rk5ppr…
1. The Consciousness Axis: Actions against organizations on college campuses. 3/n Image
Read 10 tweets
Feb 23
I’m starting a thread here of alternatives to GoFundMe for people who are just starting new campaigns to help people in 🇵🇸Palestine 🇵🇸 evacuate. GoFundMe is holding funds hostage. Use these alternatives for new campaigns. Pls get the word out.🧵 1/
but if you transfer funds to PayPal, transfer it to a bank account first, then transfer it to Gaza. 3/gogetfunding.com
Read 4 tweets
Feb 19
Spoke to Kareem’s sister today. She wanted to share more of his story. Please donate what you can. $5, $10, $20. 👇🏽 Please share widely on other social medial platforms, text messages…mobilization, small dollar donations and mutual aid is all we have left when our government fails us. 🧵 With Kareem’s story, he is suffering from severe & debilitating PTSD. 1/

gofund.me/98c41320
Kareem is only 11 & has lived through 3 wars. He suffered from PTSD from the constant bombing, but it has gotten so bad that he now blacks out when he hears the bombing & runs. His family is extremely concerned because he ran away & it took 7 hours before they found him the last time there a bombing nearby. He cannot sleep, control his urine, & has begun to self-harm. He needs psychiatric treatment & help yet there are no psychiatric hospitals left in Gaza. 2/
(Donate here: )gofund.me/98c41320
(Donate here: )
His father, Dr. Hamood, has served as a trauma doctor in Gaza for 36 years & has served tirelessly at Al Shifa. His home has been destroyed. His family has hardly material belongings as they have been fleeing from the constant bombardment. He is staying with 40 people in 1 room. (I would share pictures but since doctors are being targeted by IDF, I don’t want to disclose his whereabouts). He wants nothing more than to help his son get medical care he needs. 3/gofund.me/98c41320
Read 7 tweets
Nov 18, 2023
Ok let’s talk about the use of the word “martyr” to represent شهيد.

I’m not a linguist. The following is not an academic discussion, but based on my lived experience in the US & summers in Amman, Jordan.

(Many brown American kids who are first generation, summer with their grandparents to learn language, tradition & culture. And to maintain relationships with extended family.)

Gaza’s dialect of Arabic was my first language, concurrent with English. I learned both as an infant. My brain thinks in both Arabic in English.
🧵/1
A couple important premises:

1. Most words in Arabic do not have a 1 word literal translation.

2. Arabic is a figurative language. It’s poetic. We speak a lot in metaphors.

3. We don’t use a lot of adjectives & adverbs because there is so much richness in one Arabic word & the context in which it is said that we deliver more meaning with less words.

Sucks when you are to translate. I get it. But also—stop being lazy.

Arabs, stop pandering to English speakers & degrading the full meaning of the Arabic language just to pick a 1 word translation. Yes, it means that English speakers are going to have to do more thinking about what exactly a sentence means, but that is important.

Also, most 1 word to 1 word translations were strategically picked to further political agendas & stereotypes.

Ok, let’s play a game first. /2
Let’s first try to translate English words to Arabic. Let’s say you want a term of endearment to say to a loves one. I’m going to use the male gendered form & transliteration. Here are some choices: (there’s more)

1. Habeebi = root word is “love”… meaning= “my love”

2. Roh-hee = my soul/my essence/my being

3. Am-ri = my moon

4. Ha-ya-ti = my life

5. Al-bi = my heart

Now, most translators will translate all of these words to “sweetheart” 🙄😳. Does that cheapen the translation or what?

Why? Translating a sentence to say… “My moon, can you please go to the store?” Would be jarring to a Western audience.

Ok on to “martyr”. /3
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(