Bad History Takes Profile picture
Mar 29 5 tweets 1 min read Read on X
Japan wasn't colonized in any meaningful sense by "Western" powers at any point in its history. European merchants were present in Japan during the period depicted and they even owned some land, but they were very much subject to the will of local daimyo and later the shogun. 1/ Jacobin says "FX's series "Shōgun" takes place at the time of first contact between European colonizers and indigenous Japanese people. In the process it shows something rarely seen on screen: the shocking hubris of the colonizer and dehumanization of the colonized," and shares an article titled "Shōgun Exposes the Brutal Realities of Colonization."
Eventually the Portuguese were expelled and only the Dutch were allowed to trade in Japan, and their movement was very limited. Now then, Japan did have to deal with American, British, French, and Dutch gunboat diplomacy in the 19th century, but Japan still wasn't colonized. 2/
And due to the Meiji restoration and rapid modernization, Japan was able to escape the worst parts of "Western" imperialism and became an imperial power in its own right. Which went... uh... not great for anyone involved to put it mildly. 3/
Speaking of which, the Meiji restoration and relations with the "West" before the restoration are a very interesting topic. I'd recommend checking out Joshua Provan's (@LandOfHistory) "Wild East" for more info on Japanese relations with the British. 4/
Contributed by @luke_d_ismas and @Dauntlesssix6

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bad History Takes

Bad History Takes Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @bad_histories

Jun 27
There were not sixty to ninety thousand black Confederate soldiers. There were black militiamen in the 1st Louisiana Native Guard, but the unit was quickly disbanded and saw close to no action. A small black unit was being formed in Viriginia in 1865 but didn't see action. 1/6 @Across_Dixie says, "Lincoln said the war wasn't about slavery. To say the war was about slavery is to attempt to rewrite history. Hopefully these brave black men were included," above pictures of a memorial commemorating the supposed sixty to ninety thousand black Confederates and a picture of Lincoln with the quote from the Greeley letter.
For the vast majority of the war, black people could not serve as Confederate soldiers. Only utter desperation changed that in 1865, and, even then, it was only on a limited basis.
Black people could be found in Confederate armies throughout the war, however. As slaves. 2/6
Now then, the op is partially correct. US war aims during the Slaveholders' Rebellion did not involve emancipation. Initially. That changed as the war progressed.
However, the whole point of "secession," and thus southern war aims, was the preservation of slavery. 3/6
Read 8 tweets
Jun 4
So this isn't true. Medieval Europeans did bathe and wash themselves fairly regularly. Was it as frequent as it is for modern people? No. There wasn't the infrastructure for that. But, there were a lot of public bathouses, and we have many depictions of Europeans bathing. 1/3 An image shows a black person bathing a white person and is captioned  "Did you know? African Moors taught Europeans how to bathe and the other hygienic rituals required in order to build a healthy society. These rituals, unique to the Roman Empire in Europe, completely vanished at its fall. At that time most people in Europe did not take baths for years and it was normal."
The "Moors" of Al-Andalus were generally quite advanced in many respects, and living in Al-Andalus would probably have been more pleasant than living in most Christian parts of Spain at times, but that is a large generalization of several centuries in a very dynamic region. 2/3
Anyways, you don't need to denigrate other civilizations to make the "Moors" come across as advanced. They are plenty interesting enough on their own without massive exaggerations.
A short article on European bathing habits:
3/3daily.jstor.org/scrub-a-dub-in…
Read 4 tweets
May 24
I don't think "everyone" dreams of fighting in a "last stand." That's a very weird thing to dream about.

As one may expect, this thread has some... interesting examples. 1/10 ThinkingWest says "Everyone dreams of fighting in a "last stand"--battling an overwhelming force against all odds.  Here are the 10 greatest last stands in Western history to fuel your dream *thread emoji*"
First off, the Franks weren't facing constant assaults on their positions for 7 days, which is what this makes it sound like. There were several days of skirmishing, but the battle itself happened on one day.
Second, Tours didn't ensure a Christian Europe. 2/10 ThinkingWest says  "5. Tours, 732  Tours was a last ditch effort to quell the Umayyad invasion of France. Led by Charles Martel, the outnumbered Franks held a defensive phalanx formation for 7 days atop a wooded hill, eventually wearing their opponents down.  The battle ensured a Christian Europe."
That's not how history works, and the Umayyad campaign that year was already close to ending. Their objective probably wasn't the wholesale conquest of France, but our sources are inconsistent. And the Umayyads invaded again a few years later with some success. 3/10
Read 10 tweets
May 17
Yes, Yasuke was a real person. He's a really interesting historical figure, and I'd suggest looking into him if you've never heard of him. Black people were very rare in Sengoku period Japan, but there's no reason Yasuke can't be a protagonist in an Assassin's Creed game. 1/4
Assassin's Creed has so, so many actual issues if you care about historical accuracy. It is absolutely wild that some people are making a big deal about being able to play as an actual historical figure while claiming to care about historical accuracy and immersion. 2/4
*SPOILERS FOR AC ODYSSEY AHEAD* Will they portray him 100% accurately? Ofc not. It's an Assassin's Creed game. They portrayed Aspasia as an evil mastermind that controlled the entire Greek world. That's worse and less accurate than almost anything they could do with Yasuke. 3/4
Read 4 tweets
May 16
The only one of those that was remotely close to a counteroffensive against Western imperialism was the invasion of Czechoslovakia, but that's being insanely generous and asserting that anti-Soviet self-determination is automatically Western imperialism. 1/4 Rocko says "The Soviets were famously engaging in counter offensives when they invaded Poland, Czechoslovakia and Afghanistan."  This is just objectively correct. Any historian who isn't an unhinged NATO fanatic will concede at least some or all of these examples."
Calling the 1939 invasion of Poland (which was fighting the Nazis) a counteroffensive against Western imperialism is... a choice. Tbf, they could be talking about the 1919-1921 Polish-Soviet War, but I'm pretty confident that wasn't what @ConspiracyBull1 was talking about. 2/4
If we're talking about the 1919-21 war, Poland was not great. They shouldn't have invaded Ukraine. But the Soviets weren't fighting to defend Ukraine. They were fighting to absorb Ukraine and, later, Poland. The invasion of Afghanistan was more out of concern about Islamism. 3/4
Read 5 tweets
Apr 21
I can't believe I'm coming to the defense of Alex Jones, but yes, Hitler was responsible for millions of deaths (even ignoring all of the atrocities). Hitler started the war by invading Poland. France and the UK followed their treaty obligations. Germany wasn't a victim. 1/4
9mmSMG says "Hey Alex, who declared war on who? How many attempts at peace were rejected by Churchill? Why did Rudolf Hess fly on a solo mission of peace only to be locked away and tortured for 46 years? Do you realize Rothschild owned Churchill wanted the eradication of Germany? Do you know of ghr atrocities in Dresden? Do you know about the ethnic cleansing of Germans post war? The red rape of Germany white women and children were violated by the filthy red army? No. Great post, you hypertensive, red faced, midwit."
SchizoTruth says "Thank you for the emotional outburst Jones. Whilst I only posted a few historical photos, I would like you to explain to me how exactly Hitler got 24 million Germans killed, as that would imply he, instead of the UK and France, had declared war. Feel free to share your evidence. Moreover, for what exact reason had the British Empire refused Germany's (numerous) peace offers, which did not demand the UK to cede any of its land and why did the UK oppose a referendum in Danzig?" in response to Alex Jones blaming Hitler for the deaths of 24 million Germans and 80 mil...
France and the UK should be criticized for not coming to the defense of Czechoslovakia in 38 and not doing more to aid the Poles once the war started. They should not be criticized for finally standing up to Nazi aggression. Peace with the Nazis was no longer an option. 2/4
Yes, atrocities were committed against German civilians. Which was bad. That doesn't suddenly mean that the Nazis were the good guys.
Also, Rudolf Hess was not tortured, and he wasn't even there on the orders of Hitler. Hitler's actual peace offers were unacceptable. 3/4
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(