Surprised Eel Historian, PhD Profile picture
Apr 12 8 tweets 4 min read Read on X
Did you know that the US government once tried to transplant east coast eels to California? Weird but true!

It's a fun story. Train loads of eels! Crashes! Loss! Pyrrhic victory!

So. Settle in, friends, for a thread about some well-trained eels. 1/8 Meme. Photograph of an eel out of water. It looks very grumpy, and you would too if you were about to be kidnapped and taken by train to California.  Meme text reads: "Talk about your coastal eelites"  NB: This thread is too long for me to do much narrative alt-text. It would take me all day. So for today, just enjoy the story of the eels that went on a roadtrip.
Freshwater eels aren't native to the US Pacific Coast. All the eels in N. America come from the Sargasso Sea, & swim in waters that empty into the Atlantic or Gulf of Mexico.

There are lots of lampreys on the W. coast. But no native eels.

But they wanted some. Like you do. 2/8 Image of the California state flag, showing a bear and star. The bear has a text bubble above it's head, which reads: "I wish I had an eel."  The bear looks like it's done ok without eels. It's not starving. But that doesn't change the longing in its heart. Ursine's gonna ursine.
So in 1873 the famous fisheries expert Livingston Stone, working for the US Fisheries Commission & the CA Fisheries Commission, got to work.

He got 1,500 eels from Martha Vineyard, & 40,000 eels from the Hudson River, put them in an "aquarium car" on a train, & headed west. 3/8 Meme. Photograph of Livingston Stone. The picture is faded, but you can tell that he's an extra-white fellow. His eyes look like half-frozen water, and his beard and mustache are so 19th C. that you swear he was an actor at a steampunk con.  Mext reads: "Who says you can't Trains eels?"
The train got to Omaha in good shape, but somewhere out on the Great Plains tragedy struck. The train crashed, and all the fish were lost.

This put Stone back to square one, though apparently it improved fishing in Nebraska. 4/8 Ad for fishing on the Elkhorn river showing a fish, a train, and fishing reel. The fish is way bigger than the train, and seems to be floating above it. It has it's mouth open like it's singing opera, but its eyes are screaming death. The reel is bigger than the fish. The world that this image shows is nightmare future where giant flying fish terrorize our transportation infrastructure, and the only way to stop a bad buy with a giant fish is a good guy with an even more giant reel.  Text reads: "Elkhorn River Dozens of exotic aquatic species"
Undeterred, Stoned tried again the next year. This time he got 2,000 eels from the Hudson, & 1,500 small eels from NY Harbor.

The harbor eels all made it, & were introduced to San Francisco Bay.

Only 12 of the Hudson eels survived, and they went into the Sacramento River. 5/8 Meme. Painting of a steam train along a canal bank, with children fishing in the foreground. The train is billowing smoke and steam, and is a little piece of speedy industrialism in a tranquil scene. The children are looking up a the train, which seems massive. They are likely entranced by the train.  Just wait, kids. The giant flying fish of the Elkhorn are going to blow your minds.  Meme text reads: "This eel train is bound for glory"
In 1879 Stone was back at it, shipping west 3,000 NY eels & 500 eels from New Jersey.

The NY eels were thrown out en route, as they didn't look like they'd make it. But all 500 NJ eels made the trip, & were released into the Sacramento River & Alameda Creek. 6/8 Meme. Picture of an eel underwater, looking at the camera. The eel looks kind and fun, and you wish you had more friends like it.  Meme text reads: "Talk about bein' Transcontinenteel"
And finally, in 1882, J.G. Woodbury of the CA Fisheries Commission brought west 10 large eels. They all made it.

And that was the end of it. Californians caught eels off and on for a while, but the numbers fell off, & the effort was eventually deemed an inexplicable failure. 7/8
What they didn't know was that the eels needed to return to the Sargasso to breed, which wasn't going to happen from CA. And even if some intrepid eel had made the trip, the elvers wouldn't return to the Sacramento area.

Sometimes the eels win, folks.

As it should be. /fin Meme. Photograph of an eel under water. It's mouth is open and it looks sassy as hell. It looks like it just made a comment about your sweater and now the whole lunch room is laughing at you.  Meme text reads: "Next time I need a return ticket, Hoss"

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Surprised Eel Historian, PhD

Surprised Eel Historian, PhD Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @greenleejw

May 4, 2023
Do you have a broken down old horse you want to sell? Need to make it seem young again?

Then, friend, you need an eel! In medieval & early modern England, horse sellers practiced feaguing: inserting a live eel into the horse's rectum to get the animal to act more lively. 1/5 Meme. Still from the movie ...
John Miton wrote about this in school, in 1628, saying that several of his skinny classmates would be good as horse suppositories. He said they'd make "scraggly horses...livelier and quicker than if they had ten live eels in their bellies.”

Classic stuff, Milton. 2/5 Meme. B&W drawing of John M...
In later times eels went out of style, and horse sellers began to use ginger, instead. We still have the phrase "to ginger up" as a part of our popular lexicon.

This comes up a couple of times in Terry Pratchett's books (among other places).

But before ginger, it was eels. 3/5 Meme. Movie poster from the...
Read 5 tweets
Apr 13, 2023
Congrats! You're the King of England! And you love you some eels.

But...there's a problem. But it's the 1660s, & you've banned the import of foreign eels & you can't get enough English eels to satisfy you. So what do you do?

If you're Charles II of England...you cheat! 1/5 Meme. Painting of Charles I...
Charles & Parliament had banned foreign (mostly Dutch) eels in 1666. But there weren't any English eel merchants in London. If Charles wanted eels, they'd have to come from Holland!

The king was hungry.

So he ordered his fish purchaser, Walter Underhill, to make it happen. 2/5 Meme. Painting of Charles I...
At first Underhill bought cargo from captured Dutch ships. But this wasn't good enough. The crown needed more!

So in 1669 Charles ordered Underhill to go to Holland & "import eels for the supply of his Majesty’s Household."

All while average Londoners had to go without. 3/5 Meme. Still from a B&W movi...
Read 5 tweets
Apr 12, 2023
In 1200 CE, people in England paid 540,000+ eels in rent each year. That's a lot, right? RIGHT?

Yes. But.

Those were *just* the eels for rent. People were catching & eating LOTS more. In 1290, fishermen in the village of Ramsey caught 365,000 eels, above & beyond rent eels. 1/4 Meme. Medieval painting of ...
"Wait...what?!" you say. "No way."

Yes, way.

The 1290 lay subsidy roll recorded that 9 fishermen in Ramsey caught 115k eels, while the surrounding region was recorded as hauling in an additional 250k.

So...365,000 eels being caught each year in one small town. *At least.* 2/4 Meme. Medieval painting of ...
Lay subsidy rolls frequently *undervalued* property, & mostly captured surplus materials bound for regional and interregional trade.

So 365k eels is probably an undercount, & only captured those eels destined for markets in London, Lincoln, etc.

So. Many. Eels. 3/4 Meme. A picture of a pile o...
Read 4 tweets
Apr 4, 2023
I had questions yesterday about eel smuggling. Questions like: "WFT?" & "Why? & "How?" So let's take a look.

Eel smuggling is maybe the biggest wildlife crime going. It's a c. 4 billion a year black market industry. Interpol has called it "Europe's ivory trade." 1/7 Slide showing headlines related to eel smuggling. These are
Eel is a popular food in Asia. But eels are endangered, & the demand can't be met locally anymore.

There's a legal trade from the US & other places. But that's not enough. The most ready source of eels is Europe, but since 2010 it's been illegal to export eels from the EU. 2/7 Meme. Photograph of an eel underwater, looking warily at the
About one billion baby eels, called glass eels, come ashore in Europe each year. And between 1/4 & 1/3 of them are fished illegally, and smuggled to China.

How?

Well...often in bags, in suitcases. You can get 10s of thousands in a suitcase, & they sell for €1 per eel. 3/7 Picture of a bag full of glass eels, being held in the handsPicture of a suitcase with bags full of glass eels, sitting
Read 7 tweets
Mar 14, 2023
It's #piDay2023...so let's talk about eel pie!

Eel pie has been an important English food for a long time. Medieval cookbooks often included eel pie recipes, & everyone from peasants to kings at them.

In 1256, Henry III demanded eel pies from his bailiff at Fetcham! 1/8 Meme. Medieval painting of Henry III being crowned. Meme tex
Eel pie was so common that not knowing how to cook one was recognized sign of stupidity. In King Lear, there's a cook who was so far gone that she tried to eels in the pie w/o killing them first.

It doesn't mean much to us, but Shakespeare's audience knew better.

Hilarious! 2/8 Meme. Painting of Shakespeare looking thoughtful while writi
Over time, eel pie became associated w/ London. Pie & mash shops were common, esp. in the East End, & there were several hundred in 19th century.

There aren't many left now, & E. End eel pies are kinda a tourist food. But you can still find an eel pie if you really need one. 3/8 Photograph of F. Cooke Pie & mash shop in London
Read 8 tweets
Mar 2, 2023
Did you know that the US government once tried to transplant east coast eels to California? Weird but true!

It's a fun story. Train loads of eels! Crashes! Loss! Pyrrhic victory!

So. Settle in, friends, for a thread about some well-trained eels. 1/8 Meme. Photograph of an eel ...
Freshwater eels aren't native to the US Pacific Coast. All the eels in N. America come from the Sargasso Sea, & swim in waters that empty into the Atlantic or Gulf of Mexico.

There are lots of lampreys on the W. coast. But no native eels.

But they wanted some. Like you do. 2/8 Meme. Image of the Californ...
So in 1873 the famous fisheries expert Livingston Stone, working for the US Fisheries Commission & the CA Fisheries Commission, got to work.

He got 1,500 eels from Martha Vineyard, & 40,000 eels from the Hudson River, put them in an "aquarium car" on a train, & headed west. 3/8 Meme. Photograph of Livings...
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(