Adam Klasfeld Profile picture
Apr 19 38 tweets 5 min read Read on X
Good morning from New York.

Now that a full 12-person jury has been selected for Trump's criminal trial, it's time to round off the alternates. One down, five more to go. 🧵
Trump has set down at the defense table, between his lawyers Todd Blanche and Emil Bove.
Justice Merchan says all 22 jurors are here.

"We're also working on the temperature," he adds.
Justice Merchan on the courtroom's temperature, yesterday.

"I would rather be real cold than sweating, and really, those are your choices."

Fact check: True
First potential juror is gone after expressing fear of the discovery of her identity.

“I have really bad anxiety.”

Both sides agree to excuse her.
The next potential juror, originally from Spain, says she doesn't watch the news — and she says, rather emphatically, that she doesn't listen to podcasts.

"No. Never!"
She's also emphatic about her excellent health.

Asked in a standard question, whether she takes any medication, she says: "No, not even Tylenol."
She affirms that she can decide the case on the evidence.

She says she has no strong opinions on Trump.

She hasn't read any of Trump's books — or his critics' books listed in the questionnaire.

"I will not hold anything against anybody."
Not a for-cause opening anywhere in these responses.
Next up: Another lawyer.

Originally from the Bronx, she's a Yankees fan and the daughter of a court officer. She knows a lot of NYPD officers, she says.
In response to the standard question about whether she's a crime victim, she discloses that she's been sexually assaulted and had her cell phone stolen.
She says she may have read Trump's "Art of the Deal" when she was younger.
The next potential juror is quickly excused after jumping straight to this question and saying she can't be impartial. Image
The next potential juror is an audio professional who was born and raised in New York, and a reader of the New York Times and Washington Post.

In response to the crime-victim question, he discloses that he's been mugged.
The next potential juror, an Upper East Side chef, enjoys running, watching TV and anime. His wife is a lawyer.
"Yes, I will be fair and impartial," he says.
He says of Trump: "I believe he is being treated fairly."
A potential alternate sounds emotional in response to a what he calls a "tough question" about his experiences with the justice system.

It was a "good experience" but a "tough one, but the system was helpful," getting choked up, then composing himself.
Citing his Scandinavian background, he says everyone is equal under the law.
A Jewish potential alternate inquires about the court's plans for Passover.

Judge: If we broke at 2 p.m., would that be good for you?

Yes, she responds.
Just a note:

Manhattan is a borough of 1.6 million residents, according to the most recent Census data.

Since yesterday, the juror info released by the court has been made broad enough to preserve anonymity. Specific info, like employer name, was once public but now isn't.
One of the potential alternates participated in a GOTV for Hillary Clinton and attended the Women's March.

On the question of whether he has opinions about prosecuting a former president in state court, he said: "All U.S. citizens should be subject to the law."
A potential alternate starts things off by saying:

"My father's lifelong friend is former Gov. Chris Christie."

But she adds that won't affect her ability to be impartial.
A potential alternate:

"I try to find a wife in my spare time."
We're moving on to the voir dire phase, with each side once again having 30 minutes to question the panel.

Up first for the DA: Susan Hoffinger
"You know this case has been in the news. There's been a fair amount of publicity about it," she says, with some understatement.
A prospective alternate asks whether "the burden of proof is subjective to each individual juror."

Hoffinger informs him that the burden of proof is beyond a reasonable doubt, for all jurors, and asks if he can follow that standard.

He replies that he can.
A potential alternate is excused after apparently tearing up.

"I thought I could do this," she says, emotionally.

She adds later: "This is so much more stressful than I thought this was going to be."

After a private talk with the judge, she's allowed to leave.
(I deleted and edited a prior tweet for clarity.)
The prosecutor polls every potential alternate on whether they could find Trump guilty if they prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt.

She also has them affirm that if they do not meet that burden, they should find him not guilty.

One by one, they so affirm.
Trump's attorney Susan Necheles begins the next round of voir dire.

The theme of the defense voir dire throughout this process:

Tell us how you really feel about Trump.
This time, Necheles — taking a not-so-veiled dig at Michael Cohen — asks the jurors how they can evaluate a witness's testimony if they have committed perjury or changed their story.
Necheles asks whether allegations of infidelity would affect the potential alternates' ability to be impartial.

None of them say it would.
A potential alternate from Scandinavia says he's "neutral, lean positive" on Trump.

"I think he’s brought a lot of value to the economy," he says, adding Trump's "successful."

"I really like lower taxes in this country," he says. "I like lower regulation for businesses."
When it comes to religion and a woman's right to her body, he says, "That’s where me and the party don’t necessarily share" views."
Trump's lawyers find a potential alternates old social media posts, including one assailing Trump's "sociopathic incompetence."

Judge: Does that describe your feelings at that time?

"I wouldn’t say that’s far off-base," he says.
Another one of his old posts said of Trump:

"I do actually believe that he’s the devil."

He says, "At that time, yeah, I may have thought that."

He's excused for cause.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Adam Klasfeld

Adam Klasfeld Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @KlasfeldReports

Apr 19
The afternoon session begins:

Trump has entered the courtroom and is seated at the defense table with his attorneys.
Trump's attorney Emil Bove begins his arguments in the so-called Sandoval hearing, seeking to prevent prosecutors from invoking other prior bad acts on cross-ex if his client takes the stand.

Background in thread
Right now, the parties are arguing about the admissibility of information about Trump's civil fraud case.

I'll unpack the issues here later.
Read 10 tweets
Apr 18
Good morning from New York.

We're seven sworn jurors into the process in Trump's criminal trial. Could we get the full 12-person panel today, save for the alternates?

Follow again for more voir dire, and see my chat with @Lawrence on Tuesday's session msnbc.com/the-last-word/…
First off:

On the first day, Justice Merchan read out a list of 41 names related to the case—not all witnesses.

For @Just_Security, @NormEisen spearheaded a breakdown of these names, with research from @JNKGoodman and me.

Bookmark this resource justsecurity.org/94696/trump-cr…
Trump has sat down at the defense table, more alert than we have seen him so far.

He appeared to be talking on his phone, until his attorney Todd Blanche made a cellphone gesture toward him, and he got off the phone.
Read 44 tweets
Apr 17
News

In Trump's NY criminal case, prosecutors file their so-called "Sandoval" notice—disclosing uncharged prior bad acts they intend to use at trial to impeach his credibility.

The list in the document rattles off the NYAG civil fraud case, the E. Jean Carroll case, and more. Image
"If the defendant chooses to testify, the People intend to inquire regarding the following"

Read the full list of litigation prosecutors intend to confront Trump with, if given the green light by the judge.

Doc 🔗 documentcloud.org/documents/2455…
Context

A Sandoval hearing establishes the permissible scope of cross-examination in order for the defendant to make an informed decision about whether to testify.

The notice shows that, for Trump, the list of prior bad acts, is quite long.
Read 6 tweets
Apr 16
The juror in seat No. 2 will be excused after Trump's lawyers discovered this post on social media:

“Good news!! Trump lost his battle on his unlawful travel ban!!! Get him out, and lock him up.”

(Punctuation marks recited into the record by Justice Merchan.)
Trump's legal team has been going down the list of jurors, one by one, and three jurors in, they have challenged every one for cause.

One challenged failed; one succeeded, and one is pending.
ADA Steinglass says that Team Trump's tactic of trolling potential jurors' social media accounts is a "conceptual problem."

Justice Merchan seems to agree, as Trump's third challenge is about an eight-year-old post by the juror's husband. (!)
Read 9 tweets
Apr 16
Good morning from New York.

We're gearing up for the second day of jury selection in Trump's criminal case in New York. Some nine jurors passed through the initial screening round, though none are empaneled, yet.

I'm reporting live from the courthouse every day. Follow here.
Per pool at 8:34 a.m. ET:

"Motorcade is on the move."
For my written reporting:

I will periodically fire off quick dispatches, and longer analytical pieces, on the trial for @Just_Security.

You can find the former category here. (Bookmark it!)

A more analytical dive here. justsecurity.org/daily-courtroo…
justsecurity.org/94560/trump-tr…
Read 35 tweets
Apr 15
Good morning from New York.

Jury selection is gearing up for Trump’s first criminal trial.

Lower Manhattan is a phalanx of metal barricades, and the largest press lines I have seen are outside the courthouse.

Follow here for the blow-by-blow throughout the proceedings.
There are all of two protesters in the park outside the courthouse, both carrying signs against Trump.

One sign says, “Convict Trump already,” on one side, and the other sign is a mock-TRUMP sign with the name replaced with “LOSER.”

No pro-Trump signs visible here, yet.
The press queues outside the courthouse for arraignment were quite long:

These seem larger, including among the two lines to get inside and the wall of cameras pointed at the facade of the building.
Read 68 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(