1/ Today was a great day for justice and a BAD one for Donald. Read on:
In two different New York City courtrooms, Donald was forced to start grappling with the consequences of his years—and in some cases decades—long flouting of the law.
I followed both proceedings today and found TEN key updates that you should know about. Let’s dive in.
Today is the beginning of Donald’s reckoning
In one room, prosecutors exposed Donald’s alleged criminal conspiracy to interfere with the election: the hush money payments; the deal with former America Media CEO David Pecker to have The National Enquirer run positive coverage of Donald while simultaneously attacking his opponents; the sketchy accounting used to hide the truth from American voters before the 2016 election were all outlined in the prosecution’s opening statement for a jury to see.
In another room, Letitia James was fighting to reinforce Donald’s bond, a symbolic gesture that signals the end of an era of Donald’s impunity.
We’ve waited years for this moment because the wheels of justice grind slowly. But justice is catching up and today. And for that, I am grateful. It’s a day that has been a long time coming.
2/ Donald’s biggest fear is coming true: The world is seeing him as the loser he is:
As someone who has known Donald for almost six decades (oy), I can tell you that beneath the bluster, there lies a fear so profound, it consumes him. It’s not the fear of losing his wealth or power or his status — although, to be clear, he lives in terror of these things as well — it’s something more personal: It’s the fear of being seen as a loser.
Donald has spent a lifetime, with a seemingly endless stream of help from various sources, building an image of success and invincibility. He’s crafted a persona that, to people who knew him from The Apprentice, made him appear larger than life. The truth is, though, it’s all smoke and mirrors. The reality of Donald is that he is nothing of what he has claimed to be. And his greatest fear is that the rest of the world will finally find that out.
This is exactly what is unfolding in Judge Merchan’s courtroom — a place in which Donald has no power, no control, and no authority.
As David Axelrod notes:
“...As Trump sits and watches the criminal trial he hoped to avoid unfold, he must know that a potential reckoning he has spent a lifetime eluding could be coming. He has been reduced to a criminal defendant in a courtroom where someone else has absolute power and the rules very definitely apply. The weariness and vulnerability captured in those courtroom images betray a growing recognition that he could wind up as the thing his old man most reviled.”
“A convicted criminal? No, worse. A loser.”
3/ The one major flaw of Donald’s defense that many missed
Meanwhile, as the criminal election interference trial unfolds, Donald’s defense already appears to be on shaky ground.
More significantly, a legal expert suggested that Donald’s attorneys have made a mistake so big, it has undermined their entire case and could lead to a slam dunk guilty verdict.
Why did Donald’s defense completely fall apart? Here is the answer:
4/ For the rest and the FULL list of TEN, please consider being a paid supporting subscriber to my newsletter!
The link is in my bio.
If you can upgrade, your support helps keep critical information free for those who can't afford it.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ UPDATE: A New York courtroom sets its stage for Donald’s dramatic downfall. As the gavel echoes, his once formidable power crumbles, and his psyche begins to fray at the edges. Uncover the unraveling of a man under the harsh spotlight of justice. My thoughts below.👇
Donald, Unprecedented:
There are a lot of crucially important events unfolding across the country (Supreme Court decisions, chaos in the Republican-controlled House of Representatives) and the world (Ukraine, Sudan, Israel, and Palestine), so in some ways it seems perverse, once again, to focus so much attention on one man. The fact remains, however, that the trial taking place in Room 1530 in the Manhattan Criminal Court will have a massive and complicated impact on the future of this country.
For the first time in American history, a former occupant of the White House is facing criminal charges. As David Corn of Mother Jones put it, “[Donald] keeps setting new Guinness Records in terms of unprecedented history.”
The reality is, the future of the country is, to a significant degree, tied to the future of Donald Trump.
2/ Standard Operating Procedure:
Before jury selection began, Judge Merchan took Donald through the Parker warning — standard operating procedure in a criminal trial:
“You have the right to be present during the trial and to assist your attorneys. Do you understand?”
“Yes.”
“If you disrupt the proceedings, you can be excluded from the courtroom and committed to jail based on your conduct, and the trial will continue on in your absence. Do you understand?”
“I do.”
“If you do not show up, there will be an arrest. Do you understand?”
“I do.”
Per the judge’s instructions, Donald will be stuck in that New York City courtroom for at least four days a week and eight hours a day. He is not free to come and go as he pleases. He needs to ask for permission if he wants, for example, to attend oral arguments at the Supreme Court for the presidential immunity case (denied) or his son’s high school graduation (despite the fact that he didn’t attend the high school graduations of his four older children). The decision is pending, despite Donald’s claim that the judge has already ruled against him.
No doubt Donald feels as though he’s being singled out for extraordinary punishment, but that’s because he has so rarely been in a situation in which he has no control over either the narrative or the proceedings. Because this is a criminal trial, he will have virtually no say about anything that happens inside that courtroom and, indeed, over anything that happens to him if he steps outside the lines that Judge Merchan draws.
Donald doesn’t handle it well when he feels like the walls are closing in on him. He freaks out — and acts out — when he feels thwarted because he so rarely ever has been. We’re looking at a very old and fairly complex psychology that goes back to his childhood. The crows finally coming home to roost when he’s in his late 70s is something that he’s not going to be able to manage.
We’re going to be seeing Donald Trump in a unique context for which he is totally unprepared. At a rally or at a press conference, he controls the room. He is determining the narrative, and any gaps or ramblings can be put down to the fact that he’s riffing or being extemporaneous or doing improv.
In the courtroom, however, Donald can’t speak out of turn — he will be subject to the judge’s rules. And a lot of people are going to see certain traits, like his thuggishness, his temper, his sense of grievance, that may play well to some in certain settings, but that in this setting will come across very differently. He will be seen to be rude, weak, and incapable of controlling himself when bound by the same rules to which the rest of us must conform.
There’s a reason he tried to get this case delayed until the 11th hour. Even after one day, it was clear Donald wasn’t faring well. He’s experiencing serious psychological trauma. The narcissistic wound that he’s suffering right now is basically short-circuiting him.
3/ We Deserve Cameras in the Courtroom:
It’s a travesty that there are no cameras or live audio feed in the courtroom. Thankfully there are several reporters in the courthouse able to live tweet, so we do get some sort of a play-by-play, but that doesn’t make up for not being able to see and hear what’s actually going on — from Donald’s demeanor, facial expressions, and body language to the jurors’ reactions, the tone of the counsel’s questions, and the judge’s rulings.
As was the case in his recent civil trial, Donald will make use of the media to give his spin in the courthouse hallway at every opportunity. The very first time he stepped up to the microphones yesterday morning, he lied constantly. In the two- to three-minute rant, he said one true thing. “Nothing like this has ever happened before.” Everything else was a lie. That is a pretty simple declarative statement, and it also underscores the fact that the media should not cover any of these statements.
Whether having cameras in the courtroom would help or hurt Donald is irrelevant, just as the political fallout from or people’s reactions to the verdict, one way or the other, are irrelevant. This is one of the most significant trials in American history. It is simply a matter of fairness to the American people. It benefits all of us to be able to see the wheels of justice turning — which by the way, we’ve been denied for a very, very long time.
For the sake of fairness and transparency, the rules around this issue need to change.
1/ UPDATE: Donald’s first day in court, and the hits keep coming! Judge Merchan threatens Donald with JAIL; Trump Media stock plummets; Donald can’t stay awake.
Read to the end for TEN trial updates, including the moment Donald GETS IN HIS LAWYER’S FACE! 👀👇
Today Donald became the first person in history to sit for his own criminal trial after leaving the Oval Office.
Overall, today marks a significant milestone — the rule of law, at least in this one instance, is holding and the wheels of justice are starting to turn a little faster.
2/ An ex-prosecutor says Donald will blow his defense by being in the courtroom
While Donald’s presence was not mandatory during his civil fraud trial, he is required to attend his criminal trial in person. Today, he whispered exasperated comments to his attorney, he glared at New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman who reported on his nap, and, according to Haberman, even falsely claimed he stormed out of court in a fundraising email.
Knowing Donald, his characteristic bluster, sense of grievance, and lack of impulse control will be on full display during the trial. Whether he’s making faces or making audible comments when he shouldn’t be speaking at all, his lack of respect and anger could have a tremendous influence on the jury.
During his fraud trial, Donald was heard making disparaging comments, glaring at opposing counsel, and storming out. That trial did not end well for him.
In an appearance on MSNBC, legal expert David Henderson said these same “antics” could prove to be Donald’s undoing: “You start whining and making faces and pouting in front of the judge, what tends to happen in a trial is … that can affect the outcome of the case,” he said.
Of course, there is the risk of jail too...
3/ Judge Merchan promises “there will be an arrest” and warns Donald to behave in court:
Judge Merchan made it clear to Donald that he must attend his Manhattan trial and refrain from disrupting proceedings, or he will be sent to jail.
This warning, known as a Parker warning, takes on a certain resonance when read to a former leader of the free world and who is currently a candidate for president.
This is a great sign that Merchan will treat Donald like any other criminal defendant, and not give him any special treatment.
Then this happened...
Donald “gets in his lawyers face” and pushes him to fight harder...
1/ Donald and his sycophants just got caught in a whirlwind: blunders, court failures, disbarments, humiliations… It’s turned out to be the strangest 48 hours yet for Donald’s campaign, criminal trial, and his enablers. Read on 👇
In a turn of events that could only be described as a comedy of errors, Donald and his enablers have been making headlines for all the wrong reasons, careening from one humiliating misstep to another.
First, Donald’s legal team seems to have decided to take a stroll in a minefield. Every step triggers another legal setback, making them look like a bunch of incompetent amateurs taking orders from the worst client ever. Then, there’s the rest.
All in all, I count SEVEN instances of questionable legal moves, outright incompetence, and behavior bordering on malpractice, both political and legal.
1. Donald’s legal team accidentally subpoenas the wrong person...
2/ Donald’s attempts to delay his New York criminal election interference hush money case led to a humiliating snafu.
His attorneys intended to subpoena former D.A. investigator Jeremy Rosenberg — but sent it to the wrong person instead.
What the actual recipient did next is hilarious.
When a random Brooklyn resident with the same name received the subpoena, he informed Donald’s attorneys that he had no files to share and added that he would be keeping the $15 sent to him for document handling.
Meanwhile, Donald’s attorney Todd Blanche, complained about the dismissive attitude of the subpoena recipient, completely unaware of the mistake until the mix-up was revealed in a court filing by the Manhattan district attorney’s office.
When Donald’s legal team finally identified the correct Rosenberg, they sent the subpoena to the wrong Brooklyn address.
2. Donald accidentally tells MTG and Boebert to kill the wrong bill, and they do… blocking something he authorized...
3/ Twenty Republicans responded to Donald’s call to tank a bill coming to the floor, including two of his most loyal sycophants, Marjorie Taylor Greene and Lauren Boebert.
It turns out that Donald confused two different statutes.
What happened next was a complete disaster – one of the biggest humiliations and indictments of the modern day GOP cult you can imagine, with huge security implications:👇
1/ The fact that the corporate media gave these stories such little attention today is journalistic malpractice:
Donald loses in criminal court… Letitia James gets closer to taking away his properties … and Donald just pissed off one of his key voting bases.
Each of these stories deserves to be covered widely—instead, crickets 👇
2/ Donald’s $175 million bond is even shadier than we thought… and Letitia James is closer to liquidating Donald’s assets.
Not only is the bond company unlicensed in New York; it hasn’t even been vetted by a voluntary state entity who could verify it meets eligibility requirements.
There’s even more 👇
3/ Donald’s abortion video was one of the biggest mistakes he ever made.
Not only did he take credit for overturning Roe V. Wade, when he said abortion should be left to the states, he infuriated Evangelicals who want a total abortion ban without exceptions, and independents who don’t want states to ban abortion.
Like many New Yorkers, that day and in the days that followed, I pored over every report, every video, and every photograph in order to try to make sense of what had happened. But there was no sense to be made. 1/ 🧵
Not long after, I turned inward. I didn’t want to hear other people’s stories. I didn’t want to tell my own—it was too personal, too difficult. And I didn’t want to see the pictures anymore. 2/ marytrump.substack.com/p/farther-away…
But that’s different from forgetting. That’s different from failing to exact justice. It seems like we’ve lost sight of the promise that arose in the wake of that day, missing opportunities and, instead, creating new horrors.
3/
In 2018, John Roberts appointed a federal panel of judges to investigate 83 ethics complaints against Brett Kavanaugh. Although considered “serious,” the complaints were dismissed because the panel determined it had no authority to discipline a SCOTUS justice. 1/
🧵
Three years later, we learned that the FBI had received over 4,500 tips about Kavanaugh during the hearings. In 2019, Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) and Chris Coons (D-DE) wrote a letter to FBI Director Chris Wray asking why none of these tips was pursued.
Wray's response came 2 years later and provided no useful information. Whitehouse and Coons wrote Wray again in 2021 “If the FBI did not follow up on any of the tips that it received from the tip line, it is difficult to understand the point of having a tip line at all.”
3/