A lot of what is happening on college campuses, to me, is a direct culmination of a generation worth's effort to conflate antisemitism and criticism of Israel, an extension of the Zionist effort a generation before that to equate Judaism and Israeli nationalism. /1
Much like Zionism and the creation of Israel had a tectonic impact on world Jewry, the moment we are in is going to huge consequences for Jewish people everywhere. /2
One of those consequences is not being able to identify when Jews are genuinely unsafe, not being able to combat antisemitism, and continuously pitting Jews against the world. /3
When there are elements of hate or antisemitism, they are all the more difficult to combat, because of how identified the fight against antisemtism has become with the fight for a Greater Israel, and how discredited American Jewish and Israeli leaders have become. /4
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Israel is arguably in the most unstable and precarious situation it has ever been in, certainly in a generation. Not just security wise but internally. The public does not trust the government. Yet it is waging the most decisive war maybe since it’s founding. /1
Israel’s vulnerability is the product of the deepening rightward shift over the last 20 years that combines military and economic might with the ability to act with total impunity. The failure to provide stability is stark, and yet no one is able to challenge the zeitgeist. /2
The very notion of a political solution, of anything but military force, is considered defeat. It’s gotten to the point that now Israeli govt can’t get people to go back to their homes b/c it has promised total defeat of Hamas and now, it has similar problem with Hezbollah /3
2023 broke a bunch of records as far as Israel's treatment of the Palestinians, even well before the October 7 attack. 🧵
2023 saw the highest number of housing units in settlements approved, in both the West Bank and East Jerusalem, according to @PeaceNowIL peacenow.org.il/en/a-record-nu…
@PeaceNowIL 2023 was the worst year in settler violence against Palestinians in the West Bank since Israeli and other human rights orgs started documenting them in the early 2000s.
Exactly one year ago today, Netanyahu came back to power by forming the most far-right government in Israeli history, openly committed to a Jewish supremacist state between the river and the sea /1
Since the govt took power and announced its plan for authoritarian legislation that would remove checks on power, Israelis engaged in mass protests every week, ultimately managing to largely stem the judicial overhaul. But then October 7 happened /2
Before October 7 Netanyahu was weak, with the entire former and some of the current security establishment coming out against him and specifically warning of threats to Israel’s national security and economy /3
Israel has been saying for days, even weeks, that its control of northern Gaza is near complete. Yet every morning, we learn of soldiers killed there. This doesn’t sound like control. If this is what it looks like now, it does not bode well.
As Israeli journalist Nahum Barnea writes today: "The objectives that the political leadership dictated to the military were unattainable. That was obvious to everyone from day one." Israelis, especially reservists and their families, will wonder what they fought for /2
The Israeli right will also be disappointed, as they had hoped for a multiple-theater war that results in the expulsion of millions of Palestinians and renewed Israeli settlement in the Gaza Strip. /3
Israel has been saying its control of northern Gaza is almost complete. Israel's defense minister yesterday said Hamas's military force, al-Qassam Brigades, was on verge of collapse. Then this morning, we find out 10 soldiers were killed in a two-explosion ambush in Shuja’iyya /1
This is the highest daily toll on IDF soldiers since the ground invasion began, two months into the war, as Israel tries to build a victory narrative around Hamas militants' surrender, while also insisting it will take much more time. /2
Israel doesn't seem to be anywhere near achieving its military objective, and with every day that passes, the hostage number goes down as more dead bodies are discovered. How much longer does it think it can go like this? /3
A few thoughts on where things are after second day of pause and successful hostage release between Israel and Hamas. 🧵
1. Hamas is still in tact, able to coordinate the hostage release while enacting delays.
2. The Israeli narrative has done a complete 180. It’s now all about the hostages. The destruction of Hamas no longer at the forefront, despite Israel’s insistence on continuing after pause.