🧵Thread on a project undertaken by the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in collaboration with Chinese military researchers and other institutes. You've probably never read it before, in detail.
This thread requires patience and time, from those who are really interested.
So, the ‘major project’ as it was called, was launched in 2012, and funded by China’s state-run NSFC.
It was named: ‘’Discovery of animal-derived pathogens and their pathogenicity to humans” (Grant no. 81290340). archive.is/9c4Z8
The project had 5 subject leaders: Shi Zhengli, Guodong Liang, Zhang Yongzhen, Cao Wuchun, and Xu Jianguo, with Xu Jianguo leading the charge.
This plan involved collecting samples from bats, rats, ticks, and mosquitoes over five years (2013-2017) .... archive.is/Q8Bb4
...isolating them, and evaluating their potential to infect humans.
Interestingly, 2012, the year the project was launched, also saw a mysterious SARS-like illness emerge in Mojiang. Some samples from the Mojiang miners were sent to the Chengdu Military Center for analysis ...
... indicating that the Chinese military was involved in the Mojiang cases from the get-go (in addition to WIV and China CDC). documentcloud.org/documents/2069…
Coming back to the project:
Cao Wuchun is with PLA's Academy of Military Medical Sciences (AMMS) and holds numerous influential positions, including on National Biosafety Expert Committee and National Public Health Emergencies Expert Advisory Committee. archive.is/vjqRt
Cao Wuchun also serves on the Scientific Advisory Committee for the Center for Emerging Infectious Diseases at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. institute.wuhanvirology.org/About_Us2016/C…
He also co-authored the controversial Nature paper "Identifying SARS-CoV-2-related Coronaviruses in Malayan Pangolins" (Lam et al., 2020), which has since become mired in issues.
Xu Jianguo was the perfect candidate to lead this project. He heads the State Key Laboratory of Infectious Disease Prevention and Control (SKLID), which has Wuchun Cao and Gao Fu as members. Importantly, this lab operates under the direct authority of CCP. archive.is/s3vt8
“Xu and his team have been on the front line for a long time, engaged in the pathogenetic research of new, sudden and unexplained infectious disease outbreaks,” according to his profile. en.chinacdc.cn/about/academic…
In mid-2019, Xu Jianguo would also go on to pioneer China’s early outbreak warning system. Ironically, this is the same system that failed during the early days of the outbreak in Wuhan, for reasons still unclear.
81290345: Xu Jianguo on pathogens in Yunnan and Tibet 🏔 archive.is/lTgpb
Among other things, Shi Zhengli's project aimed to "establish a database of pathogens carried by bats" — the same database taken down before COVID. archive.is/ZGD6g
In this extensive project, WIV collected “more than 16,000 bat feces, swabs, tissues, and other samples from 22 provinces”. web.archive.org/web/2021091220…
Of note: During their first year of sampling, they discovered Ra4991 in Mojiang, a new strain of the SARS-virus lineage, which prompted WIV and China CDC to investigate further.
Shi Zhengli’s funded papers under the project include the only paper on the Mojiang mineshaft – Ge et al. (2016); and WIV’s two reverse genetics papers – Menachery et al. (2015) and Ben Hu et al. (2017), among others.
EcoHealth Alliance not only assisted WIV in collecting samples for this project, a project conducted in collaboration with the PLA researchers, but also helped fund the experiments, with several papers being jointly funded by both NIH and NSFC grants.
Isn't that something?
In January 2018, the project was “finalized and accepted,” having discovered numerous new pathogens and technologies. archive.is/vMd5D
So just to recap: From Jan 2013 to Jan 2018, WIV conducted a project aimed at identifying the next SARS-like pandemic pathogen. This project operated under an overarching umbrella that had direct involvement from the Chinese military researchers.
@ianbirrell But what happened after Jan 2018 is where things get really interesting.
In February 2018, EHA-WIV-UNC began collaborating on the DEFUSE proposal. Notably, this was around the same time that Trump initiated his trade war with China.
@ianbirrell The planned experiments and the involvement of DARPA in DEFUSE project almost certainly would have raised eyebrows in China. It would have spurred the WIV-AMMS-CCDC-SKLID team to increase to come up with a comparable project, aligned with their national interests and objectives.
@ianbirrell Previously, I had outlined the post-2017 plans pursued by Shi Zhengli, who secured CAS funding for a 'Special Project' titled 'Research on Virus Traceability, Cross-Species Transmission & Pathogenic Mechanism’.
@ianbirrell Cao Wuchun and Xu Jianguo also proceeded with their own projects.
In 2018, a report from the National Health Commission (NHC) noted that Cao Wuchun was leading an NSFC project titled "Natural Epidemic Disease Discovery and Traceability." archive.is/9mAb2
@ianbirrell In July 2019, Cao Wuchun's project received the 2nd prize of the 2019 National Natural Science Award.
The project involved five researchers from AMMS: Cao Wuchun, Jiang Jiafu, Jia Na, Fang Liqun, and Hao Li. archive.is/AT5vk
@ianbirrell Around the same time, in July 2019, Xu Jianguo proposed the "Reverse Etiology" theory.
@ianbirrell The project aimed to not only isolate and conduct lab experiments on pathogens capable of jumping species and spread h2h, but also examine their genomes for “putative virulence gene sequences”. That may imply a focus on screening for cleavage sites. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/P…
@ianbirrell In July 2019, under the same project, 50 strains were to be isolated, with over 5 slated for testing in cell lines and lab animals. archive.is/HA9ql#selectio…
On January 02, 2020, Xu Jianguo delivered an academic report on "Reverse Etiology".
The press release notes that it is a new academic perspective...on the basis of leading the NSFC project "Animal-derived Pathogens and Their Pathogenicity to Humans." archive.is/gdqmd
As luck would have it, just days after Xu Jianguo delivered his report, reports of the pandemic started to emerge in Wuhan, and he was appointed as the "leader of the expert group for the preliminary evaluation of pathogen detection results". web.archive.org/web/2020010908…
So we have what appears like:
- WIV (and EHA) was deeply entrenched in a project with ties to the PLA.
- China likely went ahead with their own version of DEFUSE.
- Xu Jianguo's "Reverse Etiology" project mirrors what DEFUSE collaboration would have looked like in China.
Why would they not do this? There was no scientific reason not to.
Published US intelligence assessments also lends credence to the theory.
“The Wuhan Institute of Virology has been conducting classified research, including laboratory animal testing, on behalf of the Chinese military since at least 2017.” 2017-2021.state.gov/fact-sheet-act…
The evidence, collectively, paints a coherent and compelling picture.
That the emergence of a novel SARS-like coronavirus - with a furin cleavage site (FCS), and a spike exhibiting 10–25% differences from SARS1 - in Wuhan of all places, appears less and less like a coincidence.
The following @thetimes report is a worthwhile read on this topic:
"According to the US investigators, the classified programme was to make the mineshaft viruses more infectious to humans.” archive.ph/CzLoM
Missed a key detail: Jin Qi is also affiliated to the same lab, SKLID. For the uninitiated, he was among the first to survey the mine following the Mojiang outbreak. He sampled the rats and authored the MojV paper. He also published one of the few existing photos of that mine.
Gao Fu, the vice president of SKLID, supervised a 2016 thesis by H. Canping, which detailed the Mojiang mineshaft cases and revealed that 4 miners had SARS like antibodies. The author of that paper recommended long-term sampling of the mine.
Kristian Andersen and Robert Garry, co-authors of the Proximal Origins paper had testified that they had met with CIA agents. science.org/content/articl…
Just came across something striking: Wuchun Cao, a serving Colonel in the Chinese PLA, was a key presenter in the China Virome Project (part of the Global Virome Project).
This is really interesting. 🧵
If you've been following this story, the 'China Virome Project (CVP)' might ring a bell. For those who haven’t, here’s some background from @mattwridley and me: unherd.com/2022/04/did-vi…
So, what’s a PLA scientist like Wuchun Cao doing here?
For context, he was involved in a 'major project' with Shi Zhengli and now serves on the Scientific Advisory Committee at WIV.
The project was focused on identifying the next pandemic pathogen.
Interestingly, all the three unpublished ACE2 sequences (likely from Mojiang) are from R. pusillus.
According to EHA's R01 renewal, R. pusillus (Rpu) was among the most sampled species of bats. Yet, WIV has published next to nothing on Rpu's so far. ecohealthalliance.org/wp-content/upl…
Of note: R. pusillus has been proposed as a likely host of SARS2’s progenitor.
1/ Just musing here, but when the Mojiang miners died clearing bat droppings, it stands to reason that WIV would have left no stone unturned to investigate the cause, especially after they made advancements in NGS, genetically engineered cell lines and reverse genetics in 2017-18
2/ Li Xu, 2013: “the analysis of these 6 cases of unknown pneumonia..may be considered as follows: caused by "SARS-like CoV"
Wang, 2014: “it is likely that the 6 miners were infected with the pathogen carried by bats”
Canping, 2016: “4 people carried SARS virus IgG antibodies”
3/ WIV, 2017: “establish genetically engineered cell lines dedicated for virus isolation which will provide significant improvement over current cell lines..without having to relying on cytopathic effect (CPE) as all current methods do.” web.archive.org/web/2021081821…
Theory: In 2017, US lifted the #GoF moratorium. Subsequently, EcoHealth, through their DEFUSE proposal provided the WIV and parts of Chinese military with the necessary action plans and work protocols to create enhanced viruses. One of these enhanced viruses escaped the Wuhan lab
I'm not implying anything insidious here. My proposition is: WIV conducted the DEFUSE work using their own funding, with the involvement of Chinese military.
Did NIH fund this research? No.
Did NIH funding support the research? Likely, yes.
Did NIH know about it at the time? Idk
EHA/NIH funded research at WIV, which successfully modified bat coronaviruses previously unable to infect humans, and successfully modifed them to make them even more infectious in human-like cells.