Shaun Lawson Profile picture
May 25 24 tweets 4 min read Read on X
Emily, of course, knows exactly why Newsnight is being deliberately run down. She's just too decent a human to spell it out.

So I'll spell it out instead. The reason why Newsnight, probably the best current affairs programme on the planet for decades, is being destroyed is:
- The same reason as Emily was raked over the coals by her CBC (no typo) bosses for the crime of asking Rod Liddle whether he considered himself a racist and highlighting his never-ending racism.

For having depicted a racist as a racist, she had "failed to be even-handed".
- And the same reason as when she declared that Dominic Cummings had broken the rules during lockdown when he'd... broken the rules during lockdown.

A journalist stating facts sent the CBC into fits of apoplexy.
- And the same reason as when she was AGAIN reprimanded for retweeting the following, by Piers Morgan:

"If failing to quarantine properly is punishable by 10yrs in prison, what is the punishment for failing to properly protect the country from a pandemic?"
- And the same reason as why she, Jon Sopel, Lewis Goodall, Andrew Marr, Mark Urban and others have all left the BBC.

It's because it's not allowed to cover UK politics remotely properly any more. It's not allowed to do journalism - because facts hurt Tory feelings.
The feelings of 'Lord' Robbie Gibb, in particular.

This isn't cost-cutting. Nor is it some inexplicable accident.

It's deliberate, wanton vandalism - because Newsnight continued to at least try and do its job, and WE JUST CANNOT HAVE THAT.
I first discovered Newsnight in the very early 1990s: sometime around Thatcher's resignation or just afterwards.

There was John Cole on the main bulletins enthralling the audience quite majestically. And there was Newsnight providing the most SUPERB analysis.
It was also around the time Jeremy Paxman started presenting it. He went on to give it an even more special place in the nation's heart.

If a journalist worked for or presented Newsnight, they were a true, proper journalist. They were the cream. The best in class.
Once I finally had a TV put in my bedroom, I'm not sure I ever went to sleep on a weeknight without first having had my Newsnight fix.

Its coverage of the latest misfortune to befall Major's shambolic government was especially unmissable.
Then, during the Iraq war, the quality of Mark Urban's analysis was absolutely astonishing.

Quite often, he even stunned US military generals with it. They were beyond impressed at how much he knew and understood.

Don't forget Peter Snow's sandpit during the 1991 war too!
My idea of Newsnight being run down was when it started only using a shortened version of the closing titles, which I adored. Only on Fridays was the full version played now.

But I wouldn't even have dreamt of what's been done to the BBC in the years since.
The Tories vandalise everything they touch. Everything. Above all if, like the NHS, it's a cherished national institution.

The Conservative Party is, in practice, about as 'conservative' as the Democratic Republic of Korea is democratic. It conserves NOTHING.
And Emily? I had my criticisms of her when, as I repeatedly suggested on here, she was being muzzled by her despicable bosses.

But she, just like Newsnight was for so long, is absolutely top drawer. A world class broadcaster.
Like most people probably, I found local news boring whether on the BBC or ITV.

But when Emily and Nina Hossain started presenting the revamped London News in 2001... wow. They both seemed so modern, so new, and both had such a presence about them.
No surprise to me they've gone on to enjoy the great careers they've both had.

But now, again unthinkably, ITV's domestic news and political coverage is far, far in excess of almost anything the systematically devastated BBC puts out.
ITV, Sky News and good old Channel 4 News all do a fine job - with Krishnan Guru-Murthy and Sophy Ridge the two best anchors on UK screens.

At its best, Newsnight was even BETTER than C4 News. The latter always had a discernible editorial slant: under Jon Snow and Krishnan.
Under the splendid Cathy Newman too.

The thing about Newsnight was: it NEVER HAD any kind of editorial slant. It was never biased. Never ever.
It was quite astonishingly objective and scrupulously fair.

It did 'balance' for many decades before the Tories bastardised the entire concept. So much so that if it's raining outside, someone saying "it's raining" and a Tory saying "it's sunny!" are now treated as THE SAME.
Of course Emily wanted out of that. Any journalist worth their salt would.

Ditto her colleagues at the News Agents - a fine show, however much *cough cough ahem ahem* what Global did to Sangita Myska remains an indefensible national disgrace.
But anyway. Emily Maitlis remains what she's always been. A superb broadcast journalist with oodles of integrity.

I once almost met her, by the way! She was in the Duke of Clarence pub in South Kensington. But I thought it'd be too invasive for a stranger to say 'hello'.
As for the BBC... there is no way, no way on Earth, that Labour somehow haven't noticed what's been going on there.

They'll have tons and tons of media contacts who'll have told them as much - and a blind chimp could see what Kuenssberg and Fiona Bruce both do, every damn week.
For obvious reasons, cleaning up the BBC root to tip isn't one of Labour's main initial priorities... but it has to. It bloody HAS to.

The wanton degradation of a once glorious, world leading broadcaster has been an absolute disgrace.
It needs massive renewal, like everything else the Tories have trashed.
cc @maitlis @lewis_goodall @jonsopel @AndrewMarr9 @MarkUrban01 @MarinaPurkiss @jemmaforte @peterjukes @campbellclaret @RoryStewartUK @AvaSantina @UKLabour @BBCNewsnight @krishgm @cathynewman @SophyRidgeSky

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Shaun Lawson

Shaun Lawson Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @shaunjlawson

May 22
I don't think Sunak's chucked it exactly. He's not a complete idiot; he does, contrary to many appearances, know what reality is. It looks like this:

1. This election is unwinnable with any strategy or for any Tory leader. It's been that way since the mini-budget in 2022.
2. The Tory party is also completely unmanageable - especially under anyone who even vaguely tries to look for the centre ground. Just as it was between 1993 and 2005.

3. Waiting till the end of the year would've meant EVEN MORE public fury and disgust.
There's no rabbits out of hats that can be pulled here. Any Tory MP who thinks there are is plain delusional. Which brings me to:

4. The currents of the Conservative Party are drifting ever further rightwards: towards Badenoch or even Braverman. Ever further away from reality.
Read 10 tweets
May 5
OK, let's deal with this. It's too easy and trite to dismiss it as antisemitism - it certainly comes up a lot.

Labour Friends of Israel was founded in 1957. Less than a decade after Israel's creation: which a Labour government had a HUGE amount to do with.
I think the number 1 reason Israel-Palestine is such a constantly huge issue on the British left and in British politics generally is just that: our large historic role.

Yet back in 1957, Israel barely enjoyed any real US support. That didn't follow for another decade.
It, along with Britain and France, had just shamed itself in front of the world during the Suez crisis: when an apoplectic Eisenhower said sanctions would be imposed unless there was an immediate withdrawal.

Which promptly followed, with Britain especially humiliated.
Read 21 tweets
May 3
Yes, that claim was completely false. But:

1. No, it wasn't the primary claim or any kind of claim given it was completely debunked before the war

2. You don't seem aware of the history of Iraq annexing Kuwait, them being driven back out, or of the whole of the 1990s!
The reason we know Iraq had WMD (including chemical weapons) is:

1. Saddam used those chemical weapons against the Kurds at Halabja and against the Iranians in the 1980-88 war

2. Ourselves, the US, France, West Germany and the Netherlands had sold them to him!
The WMD were destroyed in the mid-90s. However, Saddam pretended he hadn't - and executed his son-in-law when he told the world they had been.

Why did he do that? Because with Iraq completely crumbling, Saddam's only hope of survival lay in playing the regional 'strongman'.
Read 23 tweets
Apr 28
The thing that shocks me about @simon_schama, a fellow alumni of the same school incidentally, is he's not just a brilliant historian with a majestic ability to explain complex events in rivetingly engaging ways people can identify with.

He's always - until now - been so HUMANE.
That was what echoed throughout so much of his work. His warmth, his humour, his empathy, his sheer humanity.

Now, it's completely gone missing. I would say I find it incomprehensible - but not quite. Here's why.
I fully understand the emotional connection so many Jews all around the world feel to Israel.

After what she went through in the Holocaust, my gran stopped believing in God - how in the world could she after what she'd experienced? - but became a fierce supporter of Israel.
Read 35 tweets
Apr 12
Another man without the first damn clue what he's talking about.

When an icon as great and heroic as @Martina speaks, I listen.

She knows that women's spaces and women's sports are under grave threat. She also knows how unbelievably homophobic the entire discourse has become.
Martina = mensch. And all time legend.

Rothenberg = who?
And if I see one more inadequate, entitled, clueless male on this website come out with pathetic, condescending beyond belief, passive aggressive bullshit like:

"It's such a bummer"

"I'm so disappointed"

"It's so heartbreaking"

I am going to scream.
Read 19 tweets
Jan 6
You pathetic, odious, vile little plankton.

Gary Neville won 8 Premier League titles, 2 Champions Leagues and 85 England caps.

You got relegated with Newcastle, relegated twice with QPR, handed Man City the title by assaulting three of their players, and won 1 England cap.
That one lousy England cap was as part of our worst team since 1993. The ONLY one not to qualify - and you weren't even good enough to be picked for it more than once.

In fact, you have MORE CONVICTIONS FOR VIOLENT CRIME than England caps, you absolute waste of skin.
Gary Neville can tell his grandkids about the absolutely magnificent career he had in the game.

You can tell yours about the time you stubbed a lit cigar out in a youth player's eye.

Or when you violently assaulted a teammate, leaving him unconscious with a detached retina.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(