Matthew D. Taylor Profile picture
Jul 26 11 tweets 4 min read Read on X
OK, I must comment, b/c I saw the same analytical error in 2 diff New Apostolic Reformation-related stories in the same day:

If you don't understand the concept of charismatic strategic spiritual warfare, you will misinterpret what NAR leaders are saying.

Let me explain... 1/
Illus. 1: In this otherwise good piece in @newrepublic, the journalist makes the interpretive leap from Lance Wallnau saying Kamala Harris "represents... an amalgam of the spirit of Jezebel" to say he's equating her w/ Jezebel.

Close, but not quite. 2/

newrepublic.com/article/184213…
Illus. 2: This @Newsweek story that describes NAR Apostle Robert Henderson as a "conservative Texas pastor" (sorta) interprets Henderson's comments about Harris being driven by "the Antichrist spirit" without any context or elaboration on that phrase.

3/

newsweek.com/conservative-p…
I, of all people, understand that NAR theology & terminology can be difficult to parse, much less explain succinctly.

So I am keenly sympathetic to anyone writing publicly about NAR leaders/ideas who's tempted to offer some broad generalizations or skip over NAR minutiae. 4/
But here's why it matters:

What Wallnau & Henderson (both members of the NAR innermost circle) are saying in these comments is not merely racist or misogynistic or hyperpartisan -- it's all those things too!

They are declaring spiritual war on Kamala Harris.

5/
By directly linking pres. candidate Harris to two of the major "territorial spirits" in the NAR theological worldview (), Wallnau et al., are labeling her one of Satan's top assets on Planet Earth, a person who must be opposed & defeated at all costs. 6/ arsenalbooks.com/Territorial-Sp…
Image
This is the apocalyptic & strategic-spiritual-warfare rhetoric that was at the heart of the Christian mobilization for January 6th.

See:

my documentary (),

my podcast ()

& my forthcoming book (). 7/
icjs.org/charismatic-re…
icjs.org/the-violent-ta…
Image
NAR leaders (apostles & prophets) understand themselves to be commanders/generals of spiritual warfare, directing the collective spiritual aggression & mustering of their charismatic spiritual warrior troops against particular territorial spirits or the demons' human allies. 8/
As much as NAR leaders hate Joe Biden (they really do!), this aggressive posture against Kamala Harris surpasses even the hyperbolic spiritual warfare rhetoric they've used against Biden.

This means that they view Harris as a more potent threat to their political program. 9/
So, yes, it's racist. Yes, it's misogynistic. Yes, it's hyperpartisan to the Nth degree.

But it also represents the NAR oligarchs declaring spiritual jihad against Kamala Harris, casting her as archvillain in they psycho-spiritual, apocalyptic, prophecy-infused melodrama. 10/
I've argued (see links above) that, 4 years ago, this style of spiritual blitzkrieg NAR rhetoric was a major contributing factor to the mobilization for & violence of January 6th.

What will the downstream effects of this new wave of NAR demonizations of political enemies be? 11/

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Matthew D. Taylor

Matthew D. Taylor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TaylorMatthewD

Jul 14
I am glad the attempted assassination on Donald Trump failed, because his martyrdom would have torn the country apart.

But the current outcome is also very bad, not only for how it terrifies/polarizes the U.S., but also for how it ignites the prophecy/conspiracy theory world. 1/
I've argued that a major--& underestimated--rationale driving the violent mobilization for January 6 were a massive group of charismatic Christian prophecies about Donald Trump winning the election.

Millions of Xns believed it was God's will. 2/

icjs.org/charismatic-re…
Image
In the aftermath of J6 & Biden's inaug., there was some reckoning in the charismatic world about reining in the prophets & political prophecies.

Some leaders even produced a signatory Prophetic Standards Statement, admonishing prophets to get in line:

3/ propheticstandards.com
Image
Read 22 tweets
Jul 10
ICYMI, Indiana Congressman Jim Banks pin-tweeted an Appeal to Heaven flag on the night Trump was convicted in New York (~1 week after the Sam Alito ATH flag story broke).

@NOTUSreports asked him about it, & his answer is menacing. 1/

notus.org/newsletter/000…
Image
As a refresher, Banks supported Trump's 2020 election lies () & was slated to be a right-wing plant (along w/ Jim Jordan) to derail the January 6th Cmte, until Nancy Pelosi put the kibosh on that little plan -- to the feigned outrage of Banks/Jordan. 2/facebook.com/RepJimBanks/po…
Banks is a far-right, Christian-nationalist Republican congressman & an election denier, so it's not shocking that he'd embrace the ATH flag's rebellious (&, frankly, violent) symbolism.

What I'm interested in is Banks' reply when asked by @NOTUSreports about his reasons. 3/
Read 12 tweets
Jun 13
I'm not certain with what intent this is posted, but I'll engage it in good faith.

I have never said the Appeal to Heaven flag only & exclusively means "Christian nationalism." Of course, there are history nuts & Americana collectors who love this flag for many reasons. 1/
In my view, traditions of flying the Appeal to Heaven flag along with other historical American flags -- as seemingly has been a practice in San Francisco & Los Angeles for some time -- is perfectly fine.

Especially if those traditions pre-date 2015 & Sheets' ATH campaign. 2/
As I write here, the flag does have those historical denotations, but in the past decade it has acquired new connotations centered on conceptions of America's prophetic destiny, Christian nationalism, & Christian supremacy. 3/

thebulwark.com/p/appeal-to-he…
Read 9 tweets
May 25
A common objection I've seen since the @jodikantor story broke in the @NYTimes on Alito's Appeal to Heaven flag:

"The ATH flag was used at a BLM protest, so it can't be coded right wing, right?"

I'll address this claim seriously (recognizing many who use it are trolls). 1/
1st off, I'm suspicious of "trump card" photos online these days b/c of AI, but this does appear to have happened.

Photos of it were posted on this Substack in Sept 2020: and in other places online.

So, yes, the flag did show up at a BLM protest. 2/ravenewworld.substack.com/p/midnight-joy…
How could a flag that codes as right-wing & Christian nationalist be seen at a BLM protest?

This actually isn't that complicated or indecipherable *if you understand the New Apostolic Reformation movement that has popularized & invested this flag with theological meaning. 3/
Read 27 tweets
May 22
I'm very pleased to see my research featured in today's breaking news from @nytimes by @jodikantor.

The Appeal to Heaven flag is deeply entwined with the New Apostolic Reformation.

For the those new to the NAR & Dutch Sheets, I have 3 resources. 1/

nytimes.com/2024/05/22/us/…
First, the appetizer option is to watch this award-winning, 25-minute documentary created by @ICJSBaltimore (my employer) about the NAR, Dutch Sheets, the Appeal to Heaven flag, & January 6th.

After that, you'll be thinking: where do I find more? 2/

That's when you should go listen to my award-winning, 7-hour audio-documentary series, Charismatic Revival Fury, produced by @BradleyOnishi for @StraightWhiteJC.

There you'll hear how the NAR leaders became the spiritual propagandists for Trump.

3/ icjs.org/charismatic-re…
Image
Read 4 tweets
May 12
Fantastic reporting by @FredClarkson on close coordination between Trump world & Lance Wallnau (+ other New Apostolic Reformation leaders) in this 2024 campaign:



For context, there's an escalating pattern of NAR leaders intervening in elections. 1/religiondispatches.org/wheres-wallnau…
1st, we need to dispel some conspiracy theories & myths about the NAR:

*the NAR is not a hierarchy w/ marching orders
*the NAR is not a shadowy cabal of highly coordinated activists
*also, the NAR is not even a single org that people belong to or affirmatively identify with. 2/
The NAR is a cluster of ldrship networks est'd by C. Peter Wagner in the late 1990s & early 2000s.

What distinguished these networks (apart from Wagner's leadership) was a shared set of theological paradigms + nearly all these leaders IDing as modern-day apostles & prophets. 3/
Read 23 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(