CALIFORNIA educators: state officials are considering a slate of bills this month that, if passed, will dramatically circumscribe our ability to teach histories of Palestine, ethnic studies, and genocide at all levels.
A 🧵on why I oppose SB 1277, SB 1287, AB 2918, and AB 2925.
SB 1287 seeks to bully university students into silence by threatening them if they violate new codes of conduct. Our campuses already have anti-discrimination laws and codes of conduct in place.
This bill targets pro-Palestine speech specifically.
SB 1277 invests state funds into the California Teachers Collaborative for Holocaust and Genocide Education to create curricula on genocide education. This group run by pro-Israel organizations and seeks to exclude critical discussion of Palestine.
AB 2918 proposes a new oversight measure to shift decisions about Ethnic Studies curricula from teachers to an ill-defined group of “stakeholders” with no disciplinary expertise.
It violates a core principle of academic inquiry: scholarly peer review.
AB 2925 would fund new campus anti-discrimination training. However, though this bill names Islamophobia, its project excludes Islamophobia, anti-Arab, and anti-Palestinian racism from its focus areas, and its drafters did not consult these communities.
This QT is exactly right. If you care about these issues and want your elected reps to know that, NOW is the time to let them know that. Write and email, make a call, this week is absolutely crucial.
A few days ago I tweeted about cognitive dissonance and Palestine. The tweet got quite a bit of hate, but for the rest of us, here are some thoughts about how teaching Palestine at a *public* university when a *popular* university appears in the quad.
Teaching history necessarily pushes students into confrontation of beliefs, assumptions, stereotypes, sometimes with identities. Being a teacher is 25% about pushing content, and 70% about helping students assimilate new ideas that conflict with old ones (the last 5% is grading).
Teaching Palestine is like any other history of oppression, colonialism, & struggle, in that students engage material some find offensive.
However, teaching Palestine also often means your university opposes your work in both subtle and obvious ways.