We're deeply concerned that "Brian May: The Badgers, the Farmers, and Me" risks oversimplifying the complex issue of bovine TB, potentially misleading viewers by placing undue blame on cattle. It's essential that coverage of such critical topics is accurate and evidence-based. /1
We've reached out to @BBC, urging them to present a balanced view of bovine TB. Here’s what you need to know: /2
It appears there was no consultation with key industry bodies like AHDB or veterinary groups during the production. Instead of presenting a comprehensive view, the show leans heavily on opinions, often sidelining established science and evidence./3
Our key concern is that the TB control measures highlighted in the programme are portrayed as a universal solution. However, some of these methods fall outside current legislation, making them unrealistic for most farms to implement./4
TB transmission varies significantly from farm to farm and there is no one-size-fits-all solution to this devastating disease. It has come to light that unfortunately, the suggested solution promoted has not been effective./5
It’s important to note that there’s no concrete evidence pinpointing the cause of TB on this farm. Any claims about the reasons for these breakdowns are speculative at best, based more on opinion than on science./6
Research shows that badgers do transmit TB to cattle. Multiple peer-reviewed studies, including one published in February 2024, have demonstrated that badger culling can be an effective measure in controlling TB. Study here: /7nature.com/articles/s4159…
Contrary to @DrBrianMay claims, England's TB eradication strategy has made significant progress. Over the past decade, we've seen a marked decline in bovine TB, with 2023 recording the lowest number of new herd breakdowns in 20 years. /8
It's crucial to recognise the value of peer-reviewed science. Dismissing expert input and rigorous research processes not only undermines scientific efforts but also spreads misinformation. /9
We need to work in collaboration with access to all the appropriate tools in the box with a clear goal to achieve a sustainable agricultural industry free of the devastation that bTB causes./10
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
