Democrats gave the US its best economy in decades, yet they are currently locked in a 50/50 race against deranged fascists.
So, we can say with confidence that "deliverism" didn't work, right? The theory has been decisively refuted. Can we agree on that? noahpinion.blog/p/let-us-pause…
"Deliverism," for those unfamiliar, was the idea, popular at the outset of Biden's 2020 term, that improving the material circumstances of voters would cut through -- outweigh, matter more than -- the fog of negative media. I was fond of the idea myself! But ... it didn't.
I just wish we could all agree on this, for the record, because it leads inevitably to the conclusion that *Dems must directly address the fog of negative media*. They can't get around it. They can't succeed in the face of it, even if they pull off economic miracles.
Establishment Dems, the pols & pundits & consultants, really really really don't want to have this discussion, for reasons I still don't fully understand. I mean I understand somewhat: it's frustrating! It's not at all clear what, if anything, can be done!
But the only way out is through, and as long a Dems skirt this issue, public life will get more & more like this hurricane response: reality (gov't acting quickly & competently) utterly divorced from public sentiment, because the info environment is choked with bullshit.
So far, Dems have tried approximately fuck-all. (Hey, we did Air America, it didn't work, oh well!) I feel confident that simply *trying things* will work out better than fuck-all, even if there's no obvious silver bullet.
A final note on this: everyone, please please please listen to this season of Slate's Slow Burn podcast, hosted by @josh_levin, about the birth & rise of Fox News. It's a stomach-churning step-by-step guide to how we got here -- a Rosetta stone.
Consider: there was an enormous, horrific natural disaster, and the lies about it began *immediately*. Leftists lied about it. Conservatives lied about it. Trump lied about it. All kinds of social media randos lied about it, created weird AI images about it. Meanwhile ...
... the actual, boring, mainstream truth -- that aggressive gov't efforts were underway & working -- was effectively *nowhere*. What would once have been the main signal, the story that all the liars & charlatans defined themselves against, was effectively too quiet to hear.
That means, to average members of the public, absorbing news ambiently as they do, *only* the lies were audible. The lies swarmed immediately, everywhere. They are what most people heard, first & loudest.
So @ezraklein & @PeteButtigieg are two of the smartest dudes around, and I love listening to them talk, but this pod illustrates, yet again, a baffling blind spot among Dem elites. (You can probably guess what I'm gonna say, cause I'm always saying it.) nytimes.com/2024/09/24/opi…
There are several points in the interview where the absence is glaring, but maybe the most glaring is when Klein asks Buttegieg about the precipitous loss of trust, especially among rural Americans, over the last several decades. There are many causes, fine, but SURELY ...
... you have to cite, among them, the fact that a giant right-wing propaganda apparatus has grown to the point where it has completely captured these areas of the country, to the point that huge swathes of Americans are sealed in a bubble of RW agitprop.
I don't think anyone -- *especially* not anyone on the right -- has truly reckoned with how hollow, cowardly, & pathetic the Republican Party turned out to be, as violently exposed by Trump. theatlantic.com/magazine/archi…
The thing that was called the Republican Party for most of my political adulthood -- the very serious, suit-wearing, chin-stroking types that appeared on Sunday shows -- was ephemera. An illusion. GOP was always a collection of lickspittle proto-fascists waiting for a strongman.
It's not just Republicans like David Frum who participated in this illusion & owe us an accounting. The mainstream media worked as hard, if not harder(!), to prop up the illusion. Even as dirty hippies on the outside shouted & shouted about the reality.
It is effectively impossible to communicate how bad this is to ordinary Americans because no one has done the steady work, across the years, of communicating the importance of the large, stable US bureaucracy. You can't just parachute in at the last minute waving red flags.
I've run into this thought again & again over the last 10 years, as MAGA reactionaries try to dismantle the US system: we really should have spent more time conveying the value of that system, not just every four years, but as part of an ongoing communications effort.
We (educated liberals engaged w/ politics) take it for granted that people understand the value of rule of law, competent expertise in nonpartisan gov't bureaucracies, separation of powers, etc. etc. They don't. That stuff needs to be celebrated as loudly as RWers demonize it.
This is such a key insight into reactionary psychology. Their atavistic fears & instincts are primary, the unmoved mover, the foundation. Evidence -- what this world actually tells us through observation -- can & sometimes is used to support the instincts, but it's not necessary.
You can see echos of this all over the place. They want to pass repressive voter restrictions. Why? There's no evidence of any substantial voter fraud!
Yeah, but they *feel like there is*, and that's enough, so they must be satisfied.
The election was not stolen, but the J6 rioters *felt like it was*, so that justifies what they did.
Remember "facts don't care about your feelings"? That was all defensive projection too.
Hey, want to hear a funny story? (It's not that funny.)
Yesterday was my birthday. Guess what I got?
An emergency appendectomy! 🎂🎉🥳
I'm sitting, bored, in a hospital bed, so I'll tell the tale.
About 20 minutes before Mrs. Volts & I landed in Paris on Wed., I started getting stomach pains ... cold sweats ... kind of felt like I needed to diarrhea & puke at the same time ... not great. I thought it was food poisoning.
Folks, lemme tell you, the ensuing few hours were some of the most harrowing I've ever had traveling. Sit through the excruciatingly long de-boarding, then customs, border, security, race to other side of airport for connecting flight ... all while basically doubled over.