Brynn Tannehill Profile picture
Oct 6 13 tweets 3 min read Read on X
I made the mistake of reading the comments. I suspect many of the blue-check comments dumping on the National Guard are either Russian disinformation, or getting their information from their outlets.

I have enough experience here to comment semi-intelligently. 1/n
First off, I've been a rotary wing aviator on and off since 1999. I'm currently a UH-60L pilot at MEDEVAC US ARNG unit. We just did a major disaster preparedness drill in April.

What's being said about the Guard denigrates some VERY good people. 2/n
First off, the Guard draws from the state's own population. This is North Carolinians trying to help North Carolinians.

They're also people who wand to be there: it's an all volunteer force. 3/n
Aircrew in the guard effectively works two jobs: their regular day job and a lot of extra hours getting in their aircrew proficiency hours and training. These guys bust their butts to be ready for this, for only a little extra pay. IOW: they do it because the want to. 4/n
Through it all, they have to deal with old equipment, dilapidated facilities, limited access to spare parts, while competing with the commercial industry for maintenance personnel.

The training budget is only a fraction of what it needs to be. 5/n
Having just come off fire season, they will fly their aircraft into the ground to get the mission done, and work stupid hours to keep them flying (which is hard when they're 35 year old Army cast-offs). At any given time, only a fraction are flyable on a good day. 6/n
So when I look at the UH-60 sorties rates, I see them flying as much as they can with the equipment and people they have.

Plus, the people playing armchair quarterback have never done this.

Example: HURREVAC. 7/n
What the military does when a hurricane is inbound is they fly out aircraft to safer locations if they can't fit them in hurricane-proof hangars, or they might flood.

It's unlikely that the hangars in NC were designed for this. 8/n
So, you generally don't have military helicopters flying rescue missions the instant the weather is vaguely VFR again. They're flying back in from areas away from the path of destruction. CPs are being set up, and arrangements being made for where they will operate out of. 9/n
The MEAL Team 6 types here don't quite get that there needs to be a modicum of Command and Control and logistic support from wherever they're operating out of. You can't just plop yourself down at a random airport and start flying missions. 10/n
There's also airspace management as a factor. The FAA establishes Temporary Flight Restrictions (TFRs) around disaster areas, and particularly where DOD / State / Federal aviation assets are being used as part of the efforts. 11/n
This isn't political: if you're slamming the professionals who volunteer to do this, and especially if you have no experience with these things, please kindly cease and desist.

Stirring up hate against the people doing their best to save their countrymen is unbecoming. 12/n
P.S. Worth noting that they're using hoists, meaning there's nowhere nearby safe to land. Hoisting is a slow, tricky, demanding, and somewhat dangerous operation. That's why MEDEVAC units practice it a lot. But it's still slow, and they only have ~2-2.5 hours of fuel. 13/n

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Brynn Tannehill

Brynn Tannehill Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @BrynnTannehill

Aug 20
So, I opened up my account briefly so people can follow if they like. I watched much of the RNC convention, speeches Trump, Vance, Harris, and Walz, the first night of the DNC. I've watched the polling and worked on my own modeling. A few thoughts. 1/n
First off, the polling has shown a swing towards Harris since Biden dropped out. My sources say the decision was made based on inputs from a lot of people close to him (including Jill). Ultimately, he made it because he didn't want Trump to win more than he wanted to stay. 2/n
The swing comes from a lot of factors. All the way back in August 2023 I outlined why Biden would face an uphill fight: and I was right. Part of the problem was Biden saw no path to victory when he made the decision. 3/n newrepublic.com/article/174929…
Read 26 tweets
Apr 30
With dogs in the news, and handling of behavioral issues, I thought I'd talk about our experience with difficult dog breeds. Namely: the Siberian husky.

And not just any huskies: every one of ours are behavioral surrenders. 1/n Image
Loki somebody's Christmas present for their significant other. He, ummm... didn't work out. We got him from the Fairfax County pound in January 2019.

Major behavioral issue: food aggression.

Medical issues: worms, coccidia, giardia, hernia, torn ACL

He's 10k in vet bills. 2/n Image
Meet Thor. Surrendered at 1 YO b/c owner kept him in a crate all day.

Initial behavioral issues: small dog aggression, fear of loud / chaotic situations / fireworks / firearms. Children made him nervous. Abandonment

Upside: best running buddy ever. And yes, he's judging you 3/n Image
Read 17 tweets
Apr 29
There's a new anti-trans book out that's been endorsed by JKR. I took a glance at the excerpts, and at the summaries, and realized it's a rehash of a bunch of anti-trans talking points we see coming from Gays Against Groomers and LGB Alliance. 1/n Image
The basic premise is that transgender people are stealing all the baby gays by forcing them to be transgender. He believes that LGB people are intimidated into supporting trans people. (He blocked me, so....)

The basic premises are not backed up by the facts, however. 2/n
First, there's the notion that transgender activists are forcing all the young gays to transition. If a boy touches a Barbie, or a girl climbs a tree, BAM!, puberty blockers and transition.

The DSM/ICD won't give a GD diagnosis w/o a cross gender ID 3/n Image
Read 17 tweets
Apr 27
By now, almost everyone has heard that Kristi Noem is a puppy killer (and goat murderer who wasn't particularly good at the job). She killed a 14 month old dog because it wasn't working out as a hunting animal (prey drive too high).

I have thoughts. 1/n
rollingstone.com/politics/polit…
So, I'll qualify this by saying I've got a fair bit of understanding with dogs. I wrote about them for DAME. I've had all sort of breeds of dogs in my life: border collies, shit tzu, poodle, labs, Australian Kelpie, huskies, doberman, mutts. 2/n damemagazine.com/2022/06/16/dog…
I'd also add that I've had a lot of experience with huskies, which are considered notoriously difficult dogs with a high prey drive. On top of that, all three of ours are surrenders who were neglected. Two of them had big behavioral issues. 3/n brynntannehill.medium.com/17-things-you-…
Read 20 tweets
Apr 22
Here's a fun thread for the day. Have you ever wondered what sort of things you have to know in order to fly a military aircraft? Well buckle up, here's an abbreviated list of just some of the unclassified stuff. 1/n
First, there's the Operator's Manual. (NATOPS in Navy parlance, the -10 in Army). This has systems, normal and emergency procedures, limitations, and charts for calculating performance. 1392 pages. 2/n books.google.com/books?id=dsxFD…
You have federal flight regulations, contained in the FAR/AIM. This governs all the legal and regulatory aspects of flying (FAR), and then the standardization of everything. AIM is 899 pages. 3/n faa.gov/air_traffic/pu…
Read 13 tweets
Apr 21
I haven't posted in a while about anything Ukraine, but this is sort of bizarre enough in how it touches on pre-WWI naval history that I thought it was worth a post.

TL;DR - Ukraine hit a REALLY old Russian ship with a Neptune ASM. 1/n
The Kommuna is definitely a valid target. It is a submarine tender / rescue / salvage ship that was used to recover items from the sunken Moskva, and support Kilo Class diesel-electric subs in the Black Sea Fleet. 2/n Image
What's really interesting about the Kommuna is it is (or was) the oldest active military ship in service in the world. It was laid down in November 1912, and commissioned in July 1915. That's 119 years. 3/n
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(