Just back from a short holiday. The country is awash with travellers, and as vast numbers are now retired or retiring, it’s getting worse.
As a culture, a dominant desire at retirement is to ‘see the world’. Even the world at home. It’s a window we need to peer through. /1
Of course people don’t wait for retirement to get out there and travel. It’s an obsession now for all ages. But retirement is treasured because it can then become a near perpetual activity.
It’s always our most common, habitual things that hide our deepest secrets. /2
I’ve Tweeted a lot about travel, how I think it’s a desperate search for something we fundamentally don’t understand.
A search for place. By a culture still framed by old imperial categories of space, a very different thing. /3
Empires accumulate places, as spaces. As literal areas on maps. They live inside maps, not inside the places they accumulate.
In the West we’re still driven by desperate desires to accumulate places. What we as travellers call ‘sights’ and ‘experiences’. /4
Feeling that by visiting somewhere, we’re somehow experiencing it in a more authentic way, and it’s shaping us in turn.
That it’s broadening our minds. If this was true, the growth in travel in the past decades should have introduced transcendental levels of mind-broadening. /5
I’m not seeing it. If anything the world seems more stupid today than when the travel obsession began. And that travel is trashing locations, destroying them.
That’s because our itineraries are mostly in our own heads. We travel through our fantasies. /6
Fantasies spawned by our imitative social lives. We travel mostly so that we can tell and show other people, that we’ve travelled.
It’s another status game. The number of off-piste travel experiences proliferates, to differentiate the status of the ‘seasoned’ traveller. /7
All a wank. There is no more authentic travel. None that brings you any closer to where you’re visiting. You’re always just a visitor.
Last week I saw suburban streets with signs saying ‘only locals allowed’. That’s where we’ve arrived, as a culture. /8
People simultaneously obsessively driven to travel with every spare moment, and furious that everybody else is doing the same thing.
It’s stupid layered upon stupid. Because we’re not diagnosing this desire. /9
We feel compelled to travel, to try to fill an existential void in our own culture. The absence of place, of any understanding of what that means.
The incapacity to just BE. The desperate need for distraction from that void, an insatiable hunger for titillation. /10
Empires are never satisfied with their lot. It’s why they’re empires. They always want to expand, to accumulate more.
We’re still culturally infected by that desire, even though our empires are now crumbling. /11
We see the pinnacle of our life’s work now as the freedom to finally travel full-time. To become full-time tourists, not just in other lands, but even in our own.
Tourists in our own land! It’s absolutely, perversely bizarre even as an idea. /12
We’re accumulating more and more sights and experiences, trying to fill that simple void. That satisfaction of just being, which needs for nothing.
There was a time when a special place was accepted to be just that. Special. To be left alone. Make your own special place. /13
Now we must possess it, have it. Like geographical stalkers. Believing that if it’s beautiful, we MUST be allowed to have our share of it.
As a kid we looked at pictures of beautiful places. That was enough. Just as one human is usually enough, in a relationship. /14
You make your own place beautiful. And look at pictures of others. Those places are only beautiful in the first place because those cultures made them that. They understood place.
We won’t fill the void by accumulating more sights, more experiences.
/end
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
A friend took delivery of one of these yesterday, a magnificent BYD Seal. What happened next is a real window into what’s happened to us, as a society. /1
He’s a bit of a revhead, has always loved his cars. So him buying an EV at all was remarkable. I’d been talking about it with him for a couple of years, and suddenly he just up and did it.
He’s completely blown away by the car. Astonishing performance and premium comfort. /2
He shared the news with friends on social media. And that’s where I got to see again what these platforms have done to our collective life.
The pile-on was swift and brutal. Even his closest friends trotted out all the anti-EV factoids that circulate on SM. It was nasty. /3
My contention is that societies are created by a single mechanism - status - and not by economics or politics or anything else.
The content of public debates is almost completely irrelevant. You’re missing the wood, for the trees, by arguing the content. 1/8
Individuals and groups will co-opt any issue, any content, to further the status quo of themselves and their teams. You can see that right now in climate debates.
The quite funny interest pro-pollution folk have discovered in the health and safety of birds, for example. 2/8
These are people with no historical interest in birds or wildlife of any kind. It reveals what’s really going on.
Similarly the passionate fake interest Covid minimisers have shown in children’s education. Something they had exactly zero interest in, before the pandemic. 3/8
When catastrophes disrupt societies, it often triggers a desire to rebuild the world through a mythical utopian shift. Often a bucolic ‘tree change’ or ‘sea change’.
Areas of Natural Beauty (AONB) in the UK. How I think they teach us about our current Covid times. /1
The Cotswolds, designated as an AONB in the UK. Those who follow me won’t be surprised to learn when the AONB idea was invented.
In 1945. At the end of that wave of 3 mega-catastrophes. WW1, the Spanish Flu, and WW2.
(Photo by DAVID ILIFF. License: CC BY-SA 3.0) /2
This was the time much of the world was stumbling through the wreckage of their societies, looking to re-build.
It created an enormous yearning for a different kind of life than the one that had led to the catastrophes we’d just endured. /3
If you see a friend come back from an international trip or large event, Covid-free, it reinforces the sense of ‘maybe Covid is a spent force’.
The importance of infection and disease patterns. Covid is not everywhere, all the time. That’s why it infects in waves. /1
Sometimes these waves are seen as the rise and fall of population immunity. But it’s much more likely to be (for Covid) the development of a disease hub, spread from that hub, and then petering out of that spread.
Until the next hub forms. /2
It’s at the lived experience of people level that this is most important. If people see many situations where people take high risks and aren’t infected, it will reinforce the sense that the crisis is over.