Many can escape the pandemic already. They can just refuse to socialise. Yes if they have kids, if they need hospitals or aged care (for example), they will have enforced high-risk situations.
But quite a lot of people are not in that situation. A short thought experiment. /1
I’ve lived a fairly normal life, without catching Covid, for the entire pandemic. That’s because social life (including travel) has never been a great desire.
I’m not a hermit. I have lots of friends. But I don’t crave social events. /2
I have kids, who have had to go through school and now university, during this pandemic. They’ve also even able to avoid Covid, except for one who caught it at university.
They masked to do this. So we did find a way to manage that high-risk situation. /3
We’ve also socialised with friends. But in controlled situations. Always outside. It can be done. No doubt we’re socialising less, because we’ve excluded indoor things.
But life is still good. I’ve always been a person who likes their own company. /4
I’m inviting a partial reframing of this pandemic here. That sees the worst challenges of it as being partly also of our own making.
The number who seem to desperately need continuous social connection. To involve themselves in mass gatherings. To travel, above all. /5
It’s a criminal disgrace that we’re allowing Covid to spread. But in a way Covid is attacking that part of our lives that was already *hypersocial*, unhealthily so.
You can see it in all the stories about ‘loneliness’. How ill-equipped many are to be alone. /6
As if continuous social connection is the default state for human health and happiness. To me that’s a mistaken idea.
Social connection is violence. Driven far more by the desire for conformity, than by individual happiness and health. /7
Our ‘mental health’ has never been more fragile than since the introduction of social media, vastly accelerating our supposed connection. In reality imposing a relentless, unending, anxiety-producing game of social comparison and conformity upon us. /8
What I sometimes call high school life, scaled up to all life. The continuous battle for identity in groups/teams, in battle with other teams. Who wants that shit?
Not me. I similarly have minimal stress on this platform, because I simply refuse to play the team sports. /9
Reality acts in mysterious ways. As much as anybody I want Covid gone, so the full range of life is available to me and my family.
But even then, I would still be very sparing in the social side of that life. Human development uses sociality as a stage. /10
A pathway to individual self-knowledge. You’re supposed to need friends and sociality less, as you age. Not more. As you come to mature self-understanding.
You need people less. You’re placing less burden on them. You still have family and friends. But you *need* them less. /11
That’s what the saying you’re born alone, you live alone, and you die alone means. Not that you’re a hermit, but that you’re always existentially alone, really. No other person can ever really understand what being you is. Nor should they, they have themselves to understand. /12
Friendship and our loves are encounters, between strong independent souls. Or they should be. Not the team sports of trying to find an identity in a status hierarchy, through eternal social events.
It’s a false binary to say being less social is being more ‘anti-social’. /13
There’s always a silver lining. Covid is attacking our hypersociality, our culture infected by conformity and comparison. Those pretending to love ’living with’ Covid are destroying themselves, doing it.
You have some power here, to choose less social life. /14
And thus much less Covid. Perhaps even none, depending on your circumstances.
Pandemics reboot societies. This one is doing it right now, we’re just very short-term in how we frame it. /15
Alongside the horrendous toll it’s taking on those who can’t avoid it, it is also at the same time attacking the worst aspects of our cultures, too.
The smug status quo is being eaten away from the inside. It just doesn’t realise it.
Yet.
/end
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
What do you do, in a world where public services like public health have been destroyed?
This is the question for every day. Most of the world never had those public services. So we’re now returning to the pack. I think we sometimes forget how privileged we’ve been, and why. /1
We should absolutely expect public-focused governance to be the norm. Though we’ve never done very much at all to extend that model to the rest of the world, who must look on right now and chuckle.
Welcome back to humanity, they might say. And rightly so. /2
I won’t labour the chronology here, people know that I think ‘the public’ was invented after WW2, to re-build societies after 4 major catastrophes in quick succession. WW1, the Spanish Flu, the Great Depression and WW2. /3
Somebody asked me if it’s depressingly pessimistic to say meaningful social change only comes from catastrophe.
It’s neither pessimism or optimism. I don’t project feelings onto reality. It’s an empirical observation of history. /1
A field of study now, not just my idea. Sometimes abbreviated as PET - Punctuated Equilibrium Theory. I add various other layers to it though, for example I think this theory is true because of some basic social facts. /2
Most importantly, that social life is governed by status. All the things we use to explain it, like politics and economics, are really just status re-badged.
That’s also why the main mechanism for social life is imitation. Imitative rivalry. /3
Just back from a short holiday. The country is awash with travellers, and as vast numbers are now retired or retiring, it’s getting worse.
As a culture, a dominant desire at retirement is to ‘see the world’. Even the world at home. It’s a window we need to peer through. /1
Of course people don’t wait for retirement to get out there and travel. It’s an obsession now for all ages. But retirement is treasured because it can then become a near perpetual activity.
It’s always our most common, habitual things that hide our deepest secrets. /2
I’ve Tweeted a lot about travel, how I think it’s a desperate search for something we fundamentally don’t understand.
A search for place. By a culture still framed by old imperial categories of space, a very different thing. /3
A friend took delivery of one of these yesterday, a magnificent BYD Seal. What happened next is a real window into what’s happened to us, as a society. /1
He’s a bit of a revhead, has always loved his cars. So him buying an EV at all was remarkable. I’d been talking about it with him for a couple of years, and suddenly he just up and did it.
He’s completely blown away by the car. Astonishing performance and premium comfort. /2
He shared the news with friends on social media. And that’s where I got to see again what these platforms have done to our collective life.
The pile-on was swift and brutal. Even his closest friends trotted out all the anti-EV factoids that circulate on SM. It was nasty. /3
My contention is that societies are created by a single mechanism - status - and not by economics or politics or anything else.
The content of public debates is almost completely irrelevant. You’re missing the wood, for the trees, by arguing the content. 1/8
Individuals and groups will co-opt any issue, any content, to further the status quo of themselves and their teams. You can see that right now in climate debates.
The quite funny interest pro-pollution folk have discovered in the health and safety of birds, for example. 2/8
These are people with no historical interest in birds or wildlife of any kind. It reveals what’s really going on.
Similarly the passionate fake interest Covid minimisers have shown in children’s education. Something they had exactly zero interest in, before the pandemic. 3/8
When catastrophes disrupt societies, it often triggers a desire to rebuild the world through a mythical utopian shift. Often a bucolic ‘tree change’ or ‘sea change’.
Areas of Natural Beauty (AONB) in the UK. How I think they teach us about our current Covid times. /1
The Cotswolds, designated as an AONB in the UK. Those who follow me won’t be surprised to learn when the AONB idea was invented.
In 1945. At the end of that wave of 3 mega-catastrophes. WW1, the Spanish Flu, and WW2.
(Photo by DAVID ILIFF. License: CC BY-SA 3.0) /2
This was the time much of the world was stumbling through the wreckage of their societies, looking to re-build.
It created an enormous yearning for a different kind of life than the one that had led to the catastrophes we’d just endured. /3