Culture Critic Profile picture
Nov 1 14 tweets 5 min read Read on X
Ancient Greek thinkers like Socrates and Plato hated democratic elections.

They saw democracy as part of an endless cycle of regimes — destined to slip into mob rule.

But Polybius knew how to break the cycle... (thread) 🧵 Image
Socrates likened the state to a ship. The uneducated voting in elections is like a ship taken over by a crew with no knowledge of sailing.

When selecting a captain, the crew is easily swayed by whoever is best at persuasion — not navigation. Image
Voting, thought Socrates, is a skill to be learned.

In Plato's 5 forms of government, democracy ranks only above tyranny, which it will inevitably become.

Why? Image
Systems that maximize freedom and equality lead us to pursue selfish pleasures, not the common good.

When votes are cast based not on what is good, but what is desired by the masses, demagogues emerge. Image
Like the ship, he with the best rhetoric wins by playing on selfish interests and emotions, not reason.

Once in charge, he creates a system of dependancy: "He is always stirring up some war so that the people may be in need of a leader..." Image
So, Plato thought the ideal system was aristocracy.

Voting should be a profession like any other, and only those with expertise should participate. Those with knowledge of "good" (the philosophers) should rule. Image
But Plato admitted this too is doomed to fail. When aristocratic rulers are no longer motivated purely by reason, but prioritize public approval, things fall apart again.

200 years later, a man named Polybius proposed a brilliant solution... Image
Polybius argued that regimes were in an endless cycle, and the three basic forms of government are destined to degenerate into their lower forms — and lead back to anarchy.

But there's a way to fix it... Image
To break the cycle, you need to combine elements of each system. Polybius admired this in the Roman Republic:

Consuls (monarch-like leaders), Senate (aristocratic body), and Assemblies (democratic element). Image
This idea of separation of powers was developed by Montesquieu, and led ultimately to the American system devised by the Founding Fathers:

The Presidency (monarch-like), the Senate (aristocratic) and the House (democratic) — plus the Judiciary to add balance. Image
There isn't a true aristocratic element (by birth or wealth), but Senators are in some sense.

They have longer terms than representatives, represent states not populations, and were originally chosen by state legislatures, not the public (until 1913). Image
Going back to Socrates, his concern was that democracies are unsafe in the hands of ordinary people.

But instead of a privileged voting class, he wanted everyone to think rationally enough to become worthy of participating. Image
Democracy, he thought, is only as good as the education system surrounding it — and Jefferson had much the same concern:

"If a nation expects to be ignorant & free, in a state of civilisation, it expects what never was & never will be". Image
If these threads interest you, I go deeper in my free newsletter every week — do NOT miss tomorrow.

93,000+ people read it: history, art and culture 👇
culture-critic.com/welcome

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Culture Critic

Culture Critic Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Culture_Crit

Oct 31
The most disturbing art ever made is 500 years old, by a mysterious Dutch painter.

But these aren't just imaginative nightmares. They're warnings about human nature — and what a world without religion is like.

Click this thread if you dare... 🧵 Image
Very little is known about Hieronymus Bosch, but his art is world-famous.

His paintings take us to Hell and back, revealing what sort of actions land us there, and the consequences... Image
Image
Bosch is known best for his surreal visions of Hell as a chaotic parade of punishments.

In Bosch's Hell, you won't burn in flames — you'll be crucified in a giant harp and prodded at, or devoured by a half-man, half-fish. Image
Read 19 tweets
Oct 30
Most people don't realize how mysterious the Pyramids truly are.

They're so old that Cleopatra lived closer to us than to their construction — yet Khufu's Pyramid is so precise it aligns north within 1/20th of a degree.

Some more mind-blowing facts about them… 🧵 Image
They're not just incredibly old, but impossibly precise.

The Great Pyramid (attributed to Khufu, c.2550 BC) is 3.4 arcminutes off perfect alignment with true north. That's precision of ~1 millimeter per meter of the length of its base. Image
Executing such accuracy on something with a 13 acre footprint is astounding — how did they do it?

Possibly with the help of the sun on the equinox, which on that day rises exactly in the east (and sets perfectly in the west)... Image
Read 19 tweets
Oct 29
Which of these paintings of Mary is better?

Pre-Renaissance art might look primitive to our eyes, but it in fact contains a hidden beauty.

Because this isn't a painting of Mary and Jesus — but of the entire universe... (thread) 🧵 Image
Gothic art or icons before the Renaissance might look crude, expressionless, two-dimensional to our eyes.

But it's not because they couldn't paint with perspective, say — they chose not to for a reason...Image
Image
In iconography, a painting of Jesus is much more than a painting of Jesus.

The process of making it is a symbolic exercise mirroring creation. First, flat colors are the chaos or "formless void" of the universe in Genesis... Image
Read 13 tweets
Oct 27
This 2,700-year-old tablet is the oldest map of the world.

It reveals just how differently the ancients understood the world — but one detail is particularly strange.

It sheds light on a VERY ancient story… (thread) 🧵 Image
The "Imago Mundi" is the oldest map of the world — as it was known to the Babylonians around 700 BC.

It's carved into a small piece of clay, with annotations explaining it, and the creation myth of the world. Image
The central parts of the map are easy to read:

The Euphrates river runs north to south, straddled by the city of Babylon (modern-day Iraq), and surrounded by cities and regions marked by small circles. Image
Image
Read 18 tweets
Oct 24
We often hear about the 7 Wonders of the World, both ancient and modern.

But what about wonders of the Medieval Age?

Here are seven — and what happened to them... 🧵 Image
There's no "official" list of wonders built in the Middle Ages like for antiquity. The 7 ancient wonders list was proposed by Ancient Greeks, and endured to today.

So here are suggestions — sadly, most are long lost to time... Image
1. Old London Bridge

By all measures considered a world wonder by medieval Europeans. "Living bridges" were common in the Middle Ages and London's was the greatest — people even flocked to it for religious pilgrimage. Image
Read 18 tweets
Oct 23
Everyone knows Botticelli's Birth of Venus — one of the most iconic paintings of all time.

But what exactly is going on here? Scholars have wrestled with its meaning (and mystery) for 500 years.

And it isn't what you think... (thread) 🧵Image
The first thing to notice is the title is wrong.

Venus, goddess of love, beauty, and fertility, is not actually being born here — she's coming ashore... Image
In Greek myth, Aphrodite (Venus to the Romans) came to be after Cronus castrated his father Uranus, and threw his genitals into the sea.

Then, out of the sea foam emerged Venus, riding upon a seashell to land on the island of Cyprus. Image
Read 18 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(