White unemployment rate: 3.2 percent
Black unemployment rate: 6.3 percent
Highest white unemployment rate in the nation: California at 4.8 percent (The highest white unemployment is lower than the average unemployment rate for Black Americans)
Highest Black unemployment rate in the nation: Kentucky at 11.3
White homeownership rate: 74.2
Black homeownership rate: 45.7
The 28-point gap is wider than it was during legal segregation
Black poverty rate: 20.6
White poverty rate: 9.5
Average student loan debt
White borrowers: $46,000
Black borrowers: $53,000
Wealth gap between white and Black Americans is $172,000, the widest it's been since 2007.
Black families are the most impacted by inflation.
Percent of Black households that experience food insecurity: 21 percent
Percent of white households that experience food insecurity: 8 percent
There was no single factor that led the majority of white Americans and by some measures half or more than half of Latinos to vote for Trump, but to put the emphasis on economic anxiety as the primary factor is just too easy and speaks to a need to justify this vote.
Black Americans are the base of the Democratic Party, they are heavily working-class despite the narrative about a working-class revolt leading to Trump. Despite Black Americans being amongst the most economically vulnerable people in the nation, and despite them facing conditions that by some measures have worsened, 90 percent did not vote for Trump. They did not succumb to Trump's messaging about immigrants taking Black jobs and so vote for a man threatening to round up millions and put them in camps. They did not, though many are socially conservative, succumb to his scapegoating of transpeople. They were not willing to trade rights and democracy for a better chance at buying a house. When we get to the why of this, it helps us understand how we got here. The experience of class in America is racialized, and not just for Black people. Demographic anxiety leads those who are used to ascending to feel as if they are losing something, even when they aren't.
As I always say, Black Americans are so inconvenient to the American narrative. But we have to grapple with the realities if we are to come out of this. There are reasons a majority of white Americans were the most susceptible to Trump's xenophobic, misogynistic campaign, and we can't get to the truth of it by deluding ourselves.
The economic anxiety argument is the exact same rationalization for Trump winning that we saw in 2016. The exact same. I wrote about this then. It took too many too long to listen. Now here we are again when we absolutely should know better. It is part of the process of justifying the country to itself and the majority of white American voters who chose a man who said he would be a dictator on day 1, who has threatened to round millions in camps, who has targeted transgender people, who ran a racist and misogynistic campaign, who has threatened to jail his political opponents and shutter news orgs and has promoted violence against media and adversaries. This comes from a deep need to absolve and normalize and this, too is dangerous. America has the strongest economy in the world and that doesn’t mean people aren’t struggling, they are, but polling is already showing it’s perception of economy not actual economy that led people to vote for Trump.
And yet, Black Americans, who are disproportionately working class, hold collectively close to zero wealth, who have the highest unemployment rates even in a good economy did NOT vote for the man that his own former generals called a fascist. What that tells you is that vote was about perceived loss of status. What elected Trump was demographic anxiety — his campaign ran explicitly on it, explicitly! — and so many people whose job it is to dispassionately deal with facts still do not want to deal with that.
Let’s say however, economic issues were the reason. It still doesn’t change the fact that the majority of white voters were willing to vote for someone who has threatened to terminate the Constitution, whose own generals called a fascist, because they think groceries are too high or they wish they could by a home. This is exactly how autocrats come to power. We in the press must rise to the occasion and see what’s happening with clarity so we can best do our jobs. Our delusions have not served us well. The stakes are too high for us to indulge them.
We must not delude ourselves in this moment. Multiracial democracy in the United States is less than 60 years old. It has always been contested, often violently so. It has always been fragile. Since this nation's inception large swaths of white Americans -- including white women -- have claimed a belief in democracy while actually enforcing a white ethnocracy. In the face of shifting demographics where white Americans will lose their numeric majority, we see a growing embrace of autocracy to keep the "legitimate" rulers of this country in power. History teaches us that we are in a perilous moment.
The first time America attempted multiracial democracy was during Reconstruction at the end of the Civil War. A white majority in order to unify after a contested election succumbed to those who wanted to violently reinstate a white ethnocracy in what became known as the period of Redemption. Black Americans were stripped of their newly obtained citizenship rights for nearly a century in the name of national unity.
It was naive to believe that if Kamala Harris avoided discussing her race and gender, that if she evaded so-called identity politics, that she would nullify the liability of being a Black woman seeking the presidency in a country where racism and misogyny are embedded in the culture. This is a country that responded to a multiracial electorate sending the first Black president to the White House with a *minority* of the white vote by electing an openly white racist man over the person who could have become the nation's first woman president.
Political scientist Jeffrey Winters opens Democracy Summit 2024 with a primer on oligarchy. He tells journalists that megadonor is an inaccurate term and not neutral because donors give without expecting something in return.
Professor Winters says that oligarchy impacts democracy by limiting democracy, controlling the agenda and narrowing our political choices.
I really wish rich, out-of-touch folks who nothing about education would just stop. 1) Read the fine print. THIS IS A GOVT VOUCHER PROGRAM. Voucher programs have not been shown to improve results for poor Black children because most cannot get into high-quality private schools. 2) Read the fine print. All of the money is coming from taxpayers, ie. the government. Roc Nation is not funding this, it is just launching an educational campaign that maybe it is being paid to do. I'm researching. But certainly, it's involvement is to convince poor Black parents to leave the public schools. 3) What do you think that $300 million could do for improving those low-performing public schools? 4) It is a lie that these programs do not take from public-school funding. Fewer kids in the classroom means fewer dollars to the school. 5) This is a windfall to the city's private schools at the expense of the public ones that most kids attend.
Stop playing with us. Not only do students who go to private schools on vouchers not perform better, 1 out of 5 leaves the private school and actually see improved academic results by returning to the public school. brookings.edu/articles/resea…
This is no different than the right-wing efforts in Arizona, Florida and elsewhere just because they put a Black face on it.
What we are witnessing, once again, is the alignment of white power against racial justice and redress. We now have a legal landscape that takes the very laws created to eliminate the anti-Black caste system and uses them destroy racial justice efforts. The Supreme Court has determined actual school segregation is fine, but efforts to remedy it are unconstitutional.
The courts have determined the almost complete exclusion of Black women from venture capital is legal — Black women get just .34 percent of these funds — but efforts to address that disparity violate the 14th Amendment, written to ensure BLACK people equal protection.
Black people are about 5 percent of US doctors, but HBCU medical schools have been targeted and threatened with lawsuits if they specifically seek to help Black people become doctors.
Can you show me the data that shows that private school teachers are better qualified? See, here’s the thing, you all think your voucher will pay for the Daltons of the world. It won’t. And Dalton won’t take your kids anyway. Your kids will be at some low/budget private school that doesn’t have to adhere to any academic standards and the rich parents who were already sending their kids to the Daltons of the world will just get a big fat rebate they don’t need on the taxpayers dime. Y’all are delusional.
Further, many of these voucher movements are not bubbling up from parents. When polled, public schools parents consistently rate their own schools high.
The nationalization of liberation market-place rhetoric has convinced you all that private means better. Private just means not publicly funded. Private schools can discriminate. They don’t have to adhere to standards. They might be excellent. They might be terrible. We see everyday that private businesses fail or get rich while producing inferior products. Stop being brainwashed.