In ancient Rome, Janus was the god of transitions—a deity with two faces, looking both to the past and future.
No story better embodies this duality than Bill Cosby's.
One face showed America's Dad. The other...
Here's how a legacy crumbled: 🧵
No story better embodies this duality than Bill Cosby's.
One face showed America's Dad. The other...
Here's how a legacy crumbled: 🧵
1965: Like Janus himself, Cosby presented two faces to the world.
The public face: His comedy albums topped charts, he made history as the first Black lead on TV, and critics called him a genius.
The hidden face: Kristina Ruehli, 22, was allegedly assaulted at a party.
Two stories unfolded.
The public face: His comedy albums topped charts, he made history as the first Black lead on TV, and critics called him a genius.
The hidden face: Kristina Ruehli, 22, was allegedly assaulted at a party.
Two stories unfolded.
While collecting Emmy awards for I Spy, Cosby crafted an image of groundbreaking entertainer.
Behind that facade, the first allegations were surfacing.
But in an era where victims were rarely believed, these stories stayed buried.
Power wears many masks.
Behind that facade, the first allegations were surfacing.
But in an era where victims were rarely believed, these stories stayed buried.
Power wears many masks.
By 1972, the duality deepened:
Public face: Dr. Cosby, with a doctorate in education, creating Fat Albert to teach kids morality.
Private face: Multiple women, including Linda Joy Traitz, reported being drugged.
The contrast was devastating.
Public face: Dr. Cosby, with a doctorate in education, creating Fat Albert to teach kids morality.
Private face: Multiple women, including Linda Joy Traitz, reported being drugged.
The contrast was devastating.
1984: The Cosby Show premiered, transforming television forever.
25 million viewers saw the face he wanted them to see: America's Dad.
Meanwhile, Janice Dickinson and Beth Ferrier carried the weight of knowing the other face.
Fame can be the perfect disguise.
25 million viewers saw the face he wanted them to see: America's Dad.
Meanwhile, Janice Dickinson and Beth Ferrier carried the weight of knowing the other face.
Fame can be the perfect disguise.
The numbers tell a chilling story:
• 5 consecutive seasons as #1 show
• 8 straight years in Top 20
• $4 million per episode salary
• 60+ women would eventually come forward
Success became his shield, perfecting the illusion.
• 5 consecutive seasons as #1 show
• 8 straight years in Top 20
• $4 million per episode salary
• 60+ women would eventually come forward
Success became his shield, perfecting the illusion.
Things started to turn
1997: Tragedy struck Cosby's personal life.
His only son, Ennis, was murdered in a failed robbery attempt while changing a flat tire on a Los Angeles freeway.
The nation mourned with America's Dad.
Behind closed doors, the mask was cracking.
1997: Tragedy struck Cosby's personal life.
His only son, Ennis, was murdered in a failed robbery attempt while changing a flat tire on a Los Angeles freeway.
The nation mourned with America's Dad.
Behind closed doors, the mask was cracking.
2004: The masks began to slip when Andrea Constand reported being assaulted at Cosby's Pennsylvania home.
Prosecutors declined to press charges.
The case settled quietly out of court.
But this time, the story wouldn't stay buried...
Prosecutors declined to press charges.
The case settled quietly out of court.
But this time, the story wouldn't stay buried...
The mask cracked further when on October 25, 2006 the cartoon Drawn Together had Bill Cosby say "without the pudding, I'm just another unemployed sexual predator"
November 8, 2007 the character Foxxy has a false memory in her head about being sexually assaulted by Phat Allen and His Junkyard Pals.
November 8, 2007 the character Foxxy has a false memory in her head about being sexually assaulted by Phat Allen and His Junkyard Pals.
October 2014: Comedian Hannibal Buress shattered the illusion with 2 minutes of standup:
"You rape women, Bill Cosby... Google 'Bill Cosby rape.'"
The video went viral.
Sometimes truth needs just one voice to emerge.
"You rape women, Bill Cosby... Google 'Bill Cosby rape.'"
The video went viral.
Sometimes truth needs just one voice to emerge.
Like Janus's two faces merging into one truth, the allegations painted a devastating pattern:
• 60+ women came forward
• Spanning 5 decades
• Similar stories described
• Lives and careers destroyed
The masks were finally falling.
• 60+ women came forward
• Spanning 5 decades
• Similar stories described
• Lives and careers destroyed
The masks were finally falling.
2018: Justice arrived.
Cosby was found guilty of assaulting Andrea Constand.
Verdict: 3-10 years in prison.
For the first time, both faces were visible to the world.
Cosby was found guilty of assaulting Andrea Constand.
Verdict: 3-10 years in prison.
For the first time, both faces were visible to the world.
Then came the twist that shocked America:
In June 2021, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court overturned the conviction.
The reason? A decades-old agreement with a former prosecutor that should have prevented charges.
Justice has many faces too.
In June 2021, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court overturned the conviction.
The reason? A decades-old agreement with a former prosecutor that should have prevented charges.
Justice has many faces too.
The legal details were complex:
• A 2005 prosecutor had promised immunity
• That promise was binding
• The conviction was vacated
• Cosby walked free after 3 years
But here's the crucial detail:
• A 2005 prosecutor had promised immunity
• That promise was binding
• The conviction was vacated
• Cosby walked free after 3 years
But here's the crucial detail:
The court didn't rule on Cosby's innocence.
They ruled on a legal technicality—a promise made by one prosecutor that another ignored.
The truth and the law don't always align.
Sometimes justice wears its own mask.
They ruled on a legal technicality—a promise made by one prosecutor that another ignored.
The truth and the law don't always align.
Sometimes justice wears its own mask.
The aftermath was seismic:
• Survivors felt betrayed
• The public was outraged
• Legal experts were divided
• A movement gained momentum
The bitter truth? Sometimes protecting constitutional rights means setting monsters free.
• Survivors felt betrayed
• The public was outraged
• Legal experts were divided
• A movement gained momentum
The bitter truth? Sometimes protecting constitutional rights means setting monsters free.
When we look back, remember:
Behind every celebrated facade, there can be hidden faces.
Behind every legal victory, there can be technical defeats.
Behind every story of justice, there's the question:
Justice for whom?
Behind every celebrated facade, there can be hidden faces.
Behind every legal victory, there can be technical defeats.
Behind every story of justice, there's the question:
Justice for whom?
Like Janus, this story forces us to look both ways:
Not at guilt vs innocence, but at principle vs justice.
The same laws that protect the innocent can shield the guilty.
Legal precedent is often set by the worst among us.
Not at guilt vs innocence, but at principle vs justice.
The same laws that protect the innocent can shield the guilty.
Legal precedent is often set by the worst among us.
Liked this thread?
I dig deep into history's most fascinating stories—the ones that shaped our world but rarely make the textbooks.
Follow @hunleyeric for more hidden chapters of history that will change how you see the present.
I dig deep into history's most fascinating stories—the ones that shaped our world but rarely make the textbooks.
Follow @hunleyeric for more hidden chapters of history that will change how you see the present.
Every monster needs a mask.
For Bill Cosby, it was the role of America's favorite father figure.
For 50 years, he maintained two identities: one in the spotlight, one in the shadows.
Here's how the mask finally slipped:
For Bill Cosby, it was the role of America's favorite father figure.
For 50 years, he maintained two identities: one in the spotlight, one in the shadows.
Here's how the mask finally slipped:
https://x.com/hunleyeric/status/1869815909298446825
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
