Dr Tony Goldstone Profile picture
Dec 26 21 tweets 9 min read Read on X
1/ V. Important 🧵 if you are CONSULANT in England. This week I used my FREE modeller to identify & correct an error in #AnnualAllowance for 24/25 which I suspect may be a common error. It will save me over £2,600 from my AA liability, buckle up & see if you are affected
Ps RT Image
2/ As many of you will know Twitter/X is now really difficult to see the information you want to see from the people you follow so please help by RT, but also sending your colleagues on whatsap / FB groups if you think this will help them Image
3/ In preparation go onto ESR, download Mar '24, May '24 + Nov '24 payslips & 23/24 TRS (+/- 22/23 TRS) - and then I will talk you through IF you are also affected by this "misallocated arrears" error, tell you how to model the impact of this, and how to correct thisImage
4/ You are going to need to my new free tool which models 23/24 and 24/25 AA since NHS pensions havent sent out "brown envelopes" for pension savings, and you need this for self assessment.

Instructional video: youtube.com/live/CNYcurbDw…

Free Tool: bit.ly/Goldstone2325P…
5/ I wont be covering how to use this free tool in this thread or the new video, so if you havent already download the tool and watch the instructional video first: youtube.com/live/CNYcurbDw…

Free Tool: bit.ly/Goldstone2325P…
6/ Lets start by reviewing pay deal you voted on in England. Instead of getting 6% in 23/24 which would have been a HUGE PAYCUT vs very high inflation... you got the values in the final column which were different for different seniority. Crucially this was backpaid to Mar 24Image
7/ If you check your May '24 payslip (when most backpay arrears were paid) you should see an entry for basic pay arrears +/- on call arrears which are both PENSIONABLE

As your new pay was from MAY they needed to backpay TWO MONTHS (Mar 24 & Apr 24) Image
8/ Crucially you should note this 2 months back pay are March 24 and April 24 COMBINED.

*BUT* the March '24 should CORRECTLY be in the 23/24 tax year for pensions NOT the 24/25 tax year Image
9/ Now what *SHOULD* have happened, per the scheme administrators instruction is that 1 months back pay (from March 24)
"Can all employers please ensure that any retrospective or backdated pay ...are allocated to the correct pension year where pensionable, so that the correct figures are held by NHS Pensions"cms.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/retrospective-…Image
10/ Furthermore NHS pensions acknowedge that if they dont correctly allocate it "Placing the pay in the incorrect years and having the incorrect sessions or hours recorded can have an effect on annual allowance"
11/ So next CRUCIAL step to see if youre affected by this, like I was (& suspect many others are).
If you are CONSULTANT in ENGLAND does your MAR '24 pen pay (or FTE if LTFT) *MATCH* TRS pay 23/24 1995 (red arrows) from TRS released last week = if so *YOU HAVE ARREARS PROBLEM*Image
12/ In that slide I show you how to work out what correct pay SHOULD be based on YOUR arrears payment. For full details of that & entire process suggest you watch new 20 min YouTube 👇covering whole process (suggest you bookmark this)
13/ Much more detail in the video but example year 13 saving below reducing tax charge by £3,246

[also see in the video in tweet 12 how tax charge can also be reduced +++ by not tapering]

Reduction in AA will depend on your exact circumstances - watch the video Image
14/ Again more detail in video but example year 18 saving below reducing tax charge by £5,459

[also see in the video in tweet 12 how tax charge can also be reduced +++ by not tapering]

Reduction in AA will depend on your exact circumstances - watch the video Image
15/ You can get a ROUGH idea of potential max savings in the coloured cells on the right (based on "typical" 1995 service, or a slightly more refined "guestimate" by multiplying the TROF [Tax RIP OFF Factor] in the grey cells below by your 1995 years of service Image
16/ But you are strongly advised to actually model the affect of fixing this re-allocation using the new feature added to the free modeller 24/25 tab (see yellow cells and drop down) - watch video in tweet 12 for full details (note 23/24 and carry forward also affected) Image
17/ If after looking into this you wish to correct this "missalocated arrear error", you can ask your trust to fix this for you.

I sent the email below which you can copy from the link below (fill in your value using the video as a guide)

docs.google.com/document/d/1Hv…Image
18/ My trust fixed this very quikcly for me and I emailed NHS pensions the following day asking them to send my "on demand" Pension Saving Statement for 23/24 ensuring the new amount and they also responded back really quickly Image
19/ So again the whole process is covered in this short 20 min video which talks you through how to model this, and correct this error. It "saved" me over £2,600 versus paying for non-existent growth I would never get in my pension retiring in >3 years
20/ All of this, once again, demonstrates how RIDICULOUS annual allowance is in "DB" schemes. That comparatively small amounts of pensionable pay (£500-1000) can distort pension growth in a wholly artificial spike, causing incorrect bills ££££ is a joke
21/22 Once again - twitter/X is a mess now so please ensure colleagues get to see this by quote RT first tweet, and if they are not on X, please share via FB / Whatsapp groups etc and subscribe to my YouTube to stay in touch

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dr Tony Goldstone

Dr Tony Goldstone Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @goldstone_tony

Dec 12
1/ THOUGHT FOR THE DAY: Whilst I'm grateful for the changes to LTA/AA, the AA and the dreaded #taper still remain. And here's your regular reminder why its PARTICULARLY unfair, and stupid, in the NHS (from @BMA_Pensions @TheBMA evidence to DDRB).

Short 🧵pls read & share Image
2/ We are all in CARE now, so should all be paying generally the same employEE contributions.

But we aren't - and its worst - by a garden mile - in the NHS per this chart showing the ratio of conts from the highest earners : lowest earners in the public sector 👇Image
3/ So unlike in the private sector where there is no difference in cost for higher vs lower owners other than tax relief, we go through this ridiculously unfair step in the NHS - far worse than anywhere in the public sector - that strips away our higher rate reliefImage
Read 5 tweets
Dec 10
1/ very important and NEW: @nhs_pensions have overnight issues guidance on 23/24 tax year where they have failed to send you a pensions savings statement on time (which was their legal duty)

nhsbsa.nhs.uk/public-service…Image
Image
2/ the bottom line is they expect you ESTIMATE your carry forward and PIA and any charge in the normal timescale ie by Jan 31st 2025 …. Which is going to be extremely difficult ….. Image
Image
3/ after you estimate you will have until Jan 26 to correct your estimation based on the real figures Image
Image
Read 13 tweets
Oct 30
1/ Well after intense media speculation re: budget (speculation incl. reduction of tax free lump sum to £100k; flat rate relief at 30 or 20%; lifetime allowance re-introduction & pension "flexibility" [i.e. balance between pay & pension] .. speculation can now END....
Pls RT 🧵 Image
2/ Its now time for @RachelReevesMP to deliver her first budget ... I'll be live tweeting anything significant with a focus on #pensions and #pensiontax (if there is indeed anything!)

So keep following! Appologies for any typos/errors read to end for any corrections & docs Image
3/ So following #PMQs there is a statement that the contents of some of the budget has been made public before the budget and expresses dissapointment that this has happened Image
Read 27 tweets
Oct 17
1/ Longtime followers may remember this update from 4.5 years ago. Id met the then head of @nhs_pensions and the senior leadership team. They made lots of promises to improve things around Annual Allowance that BADLY needed improvement....

Pls read, share and RT
2/ Chief among those promises was to have an end to waiting till October for a PSS. Indeed no more brown envelopes. 85% of people would get their "digital brown envelope" by June (starting in 2020) 👇

3/ And furthermore for those that dont get automatic PSS (then around 85%), 15% would be able to see in this portal, from June 2020 why they DONT have a PSS i.e. you need manual calculations, or they cant issue one as they are awaiting info from employer

Read 14 tweets
Sep 7
1/ ICYMI Ive done a couple of videos 📹 on the tapered annual allowance - and why it could be hugely problematic for higher earners in the NHS *THIS* tax year (24/25)

Its crucial you have an understanding of chart 👇 if you are in affected groups.

Please share 👇/ RT & 👀📹 Image
2/ This was the first of two videos introducing the problem via a real case study

I discuss why its crucial that @wesstreeting @jamesmurray_ldn get an urgent grip of the dreadful tax policies they inherited affecting lower and higher earning consultants

3/ In second video I discuss a case in more detail & look at some strategies to try & mitigate this nightmare tax cliff.

None are desirable & tax needs changing to remove the huge discincentives to not to extra work, or worse still, reduce current

Read 4 tweets
Aug 20
THOUGHT FOR THE DAY: many senior doctors desperate to help waiting lists & would be willing to give up evenings/weekends to help out.

But current tax rules will mean some could end up #PayingToWork 👇

RT if you want @wesstreeting @jamesmurray_ldn to fix this ludicrous tax trap Image
2/ Per the chart with taxable income 242,400 after income tax, NI and AA post tax pay is around 95,056.40

However the same member earning 199,999 also gets 95,083.88 post income tax, NI, and AA

Why would this member do over £40k extra work, and PAY TO WORK?? Image
3/ Looking at it the other way the member earning 200,001 takes home 72,584.96

But the member earning 157,500 takes home essentially the same 72,559.40

*HOW IS THIS FAIR*

[CLUE: it isnt] Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(