I’m so sick of people trying to sell me “good russian” like Solzhenitsyn. Oh he was dissident against Soviet oppression🙄
Only because it oppressed him.
He hated Jews and would have fully supported gulags for all Jews. In his last years he advocated for peace between Jews and Russians to both share guilt. Can you imagine? What guilt Jews have to share with their oppressors? Hating Soviet system does not make him hero. All normal people should hate totalitarian regimes.
Being russian Soviet dissident is not alone worthy of respect. Navalny was dissident under Putin and hated Muslims, cheered Chechen genocide. But he’s such hero🙄
Even opposing Putin is not heroism. It’s basic human responsibility. That only few manage such responsibility is not heroism. It’s just being human being. Are we to make heroes out of human beings just for being human beings? Then what that say about Russia? It says that out of over hundred million, only few people can be called human beings. And out of those, very few can be called heroes.
Stop selling me these people who say Putin is Hitler. Yes he is. Instead ask them how many russians are guilty of helping Putin. See what they then say.
Stop telling me all Russians should be like this one good one. Same argument was made against Tsarist Russia. Rise up all good Russians. And what they did? Became exactly same. Then all russians should rise up against Soviets. Look at these dissidents, such heroes. What happen next? Soviets collapse and they became same. Now it’s call for all good russians to rise up against Putin. Look how brave such people are. And what you think will happen when Putin falls? They suddenly stop being who they are?
It’s not just Putin. It’s not just Stalin. It’s not just Tsar. There is no russian opposition to support. There can be no redemption. It’s not possible. Our only hope is to isolate ourselves from them and build up our military defenses.
Stop selling me fantasy that this time they will stop being who they are.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Let’s discuss nationalism. Is nationalism and defensive nationalism same? No. Is defensive nationalism cancel culture? No. Unless you have IQ of shoe and live in safe place where you are so free, you get bored and create bullshit for drama. 🧵
1. Nationalism in countries not ethnically cleansed is right wing ideology of state worship that one group try to impose on rest. Such people are dangerous, authoritarian assholes.
2. Defensive nationalism is when you are erased and you try to hold on to yourself through asserting your identity.
How do you get erased? Here is thread I do to explain Russification to Americans.
If you don’t read that, don’t bother with the responding.
It’s simple reality that my father explain better than I. Putin wants out of this war in way that keep him alive. If he stops it, he’s dead. But if he show russians they greatest ever because of choices he made, they will happily starve for this myth. 🧵
1. West don’t understand russia because West imagine everyone on earth share their values. How could people not want freedom or not want better life? russians never wanted such thing. They don’t share West values.
You have hundred million people most of them
2. Are forced to be russian against their will across generations. Now they don’t have identity. They only have myth of their greatness. That’s all they have. And they are willing to die and kill for this myth because without it, they don’t exist.
Friends if you want to commemorate #Holodomor, consider watching and showing these to others🧵
1. You can watch and share this historical drama about resistance during Holodomor.
2. You can watch and share this excellent film on role of American New York Times in covering up Holodomor and bravery of Welsh journalist to tell world
Here is promised present. I recorded & transcribe & translate entire conversation I have with my father about 🇷🇺 nuclear threats. Some words I don’t know exact translation for so I leave. I try to retain his humor but it’s not as funny translated🧵
1. Another point you will notice he talk in questions. He’s not expecting answer. It’s how he talk. And he switch from russian to Yiddish constantly so I make it flow as one translation.
1. Ok papa, I record. Tell my friends if you think Russians will use nukes.
Papa: “It’s stupid fear. It’s combination of issues that make this impossible scenario.
“You imagine he just walk over and press button? No no, this is not reality. Do you know how many people exist”
📝Good morning. My father and I just have quite profound conversation over coffee about America. I don’t have heart to write it all because there are so many good Americans. I don’t won’t to hurt you friends.
My father has religion called freedom.🧵
1. He is devout to this religion. He will die for this religion if he must. Thats how deeply he value it above all things. In his mind he believe that America is guardian or high priest of this religion. American founding documents are Bible of this religion.
2. American values are commandments of this religion. It’s such pitiful thing that this old man come to realize that that what he spend his life believing in he realize is fraud. It’s like god died. I don’t know why he idealize it so much. He’s not only one like this.