Importantly, the actual document that Rubio sent up to the Hill yesterday contradicts Elon's assertion that the agency is gone.
And contra Elon, it also acknowledges that any major re-org of US aid policy must involve Congress.
This is notable because outside of the twitter echo chamber, the USG still runs based on laws - a reality that the document acknowledges multiple times.
It's clear they still aim to absorb USAID into State - but they're also acknowledging they can't do so unilaterally.
Meanwhile Congress has affirmed that same reality.
Outside of Elon's twitter feed, here's where things actually stand:
- DOGE staff acting on unclear legal authority have attempted to unlawfully shut down a federal agency
- In doing so they have compromised sensitive government personnel, procurement, and classified info systems
- These actions have badly disrupted critical US-funded activities around the world and placed taxpayer-funded resources and assets at grave risk of waste or abuse
- US personnel operating overseas have been put at grave risk by being expelled from Embassy security & oversight
- USAID continues to exist as a legal entity, per State Dept notice to Congress; Rubio & Marocco in charge
- But most staff at the agency are being obstructed from carrying out their lawful duties
- Congressional funding mandates are being violated by the State funding freeze
- Russia is cheering all of this on from the sidelines (wonder why??)
- And vital USAID programs that save lives and advance US values and interests around the world remain disrupted and frozen.
To be clear: this situation is still a disaster. But there are some hopeful signs here that this attack on USAID will not pass unchallenged.
Aid leaders have been warning for 2 months that the gutting of @USAID would leave US unable to respond to major global disasters.
We are now seeing that play out in real time with the Myanmar quake - reality is calling bullshit on the Trump admin's narrative.
🧵
In today's press briefing @statedeptspox bizarrely "rejected the premise" that a meaningful US response requires USAID staff "to be physically there."
As the guy who used to deploy those teams - this is total nonsense.
You can't conduct search-and-rescue virtually. Come on.
The reality is that other countries began deploying their teams immediately - and the US would have too, under any prior administration (including Trump 1).
But Elon, Pete Marocco, and Rubio have wrecked the USG's ability to do this.
I posted this over a month ago on some specific line items on DOGE's wall of receipts, explaining how these violated the Rubio guidance on protecting lifesaving activities.
On claim after claim about @USAID / foreign aid, Elon is just making shit up as he goes along. No truth to any of it.
This claim is demonstrably false. Deaths have already been documented from the aid freeze. And the so called "sanity check" is a clown show of incompetence.
This is not a "brief pause." Aid orgs doing critical lifesaving work are being denied reimbursement for work already completed, and can't access USG payments to continue operations.
Many had their programs waived from the freeze, then terminated, then un-terminated.
A farce.
This is all hugely disruptive and the practical effect is global drawdown of lifesaving humanitarian and health activities.
Our @RefugeesIntl teams in the field over the past two weeks have documented widespread breakdowns of lifesaving relief operations in Syria & Bangladesh.
So - I've actually led Ebola outbreak response at @USAID.
This is bunk from Elon. They have laid off most of the experts, they're bankrupting most of the partner orgs, have withdrawn from WHO, and muzzled CDC.
What's left is a fig-leaf effort to cover their asses politically.
Normally there would be:
- resources rapidly pushed to partners & host govt
- robust interagency (USAID/CDC/DOD) teams deployed to field, backstopped by Ops Centers in DC and Atlanta
- real-time operational cooperation and info-sharing with WHO