Dr Sally Witcher Profile picture
Jun 20 19 tweets 3 min read Read on X
On Wednesday they take away #AssistancetoLive. On Friday -today - they may give #AssistanceToDie. On Wednesday they take away our Personal Independence. They make us dependent. They take support away from unpaid carers on whom we depend. 🧵
On Friday they look set to give people who feel dependent – a burden – a way out. In just a few days they go from #TakingThePIP to #TakingOurLives.
For yeas disabled people fought for #RightsNotCharity, for an equal fundamental human right to life. To live. Without fear. With the dignity of rights. For recognition that we are #EquallyHuman. We are not 'other'. We may be your child, your mum, your bestie. Maybe you. Any day.
On Wednesday they take away those rights, and with it #DignityInLiving. On Friday they give #DignityInDying? But it is not just benefit rights, but other essential support that are under threat due to soaring need, with the arrival of Covid marking a step change upwards.
Not just benefits, but social care support, mental health services, healthcare, ‘special educational needs’ support for children, Access to Work support for those in work, for years all have long been systematically underfunded to the point of collapse. And that was before Covid.
Then Covid came. And another new wave has just arrived. Maybe at some point they’ll put two and two together and get four. Maybe they’ll add the intolerable pressure on mental health of cost-of-living crises, freedom of speech that means freedom to lie, attack...
whip up anger & hatred, the catastrophe of looming climate destruction, the gearing up for war, & loss of faith in govts of supposedly different political colours that only seem to make ordinary people’s lives harder, while a few individuals amass more wealth than some countries.
Maybe someday they’ll work out that sick and disabled people’s rising need for support is because the collapse of social and economic systems is making more people sick and disabled.
It’s crunch time. Will govts get tough on the causes of sickness & disability their policy failures have created or on sick/disabled people, the victims? Will they drive a final nail in the coffin of sick/disabled people & those who will become so if we continue down this path?
Is this what happens when AI means the rich don’t need the poor anymore, or even the middle-classes? If, when Musk said to Sunak a while ago ‘soon no one will need to work’, what he meant was ‘soon we won’t need workers’?
A petition calling for an end to the benefit cuts also called for a National Disability Strategy. But it very much looks like the Government has one. Unusually for a government strategy not only is it coherent, they are actually implementing it. petition.parliament.uk/petitions/7239…
So, let’s be clear why this safeguard-free Assisted Dying Bill is so dangerous. We live in an era where so many lives are being made completely intolerable. Unbearable.
There is no evidence of political will to address the root causes. People are being driven into sickness, disability & dependency & the door is to be opened to end it.
No one should experience #IndignityInLife or #IndignityInDeath. The resources & tools exist to achieve both. They're not being used. Some may disagree, but I simply don’t accept that it’s beyond our collective capacity to find a way to square the circle. To have dignity in both.
I know MPs who are sincerely wrestling with which to choose – a rock or a hard place. My message to you is, please vote against this dangerous Bill. Let's work together to find a better way forward, on the shared view that profound avoidable suffering is never acceptable
And to those MPs who know exactly what they’re doing, who only value human life by how much profit can be made from it, who know that they don’t need to herd people seen as ‘useless eaters’ into camps & kill them if they can make death their choice, I say shame on you. I see you.
Gandi said “"The true measure of any society can be found in how it treats its most vulnerable” I would like to propose a codicil: “The true measure of any society is whether it forces people into vulnerability when it has the resources, tools and capacity not to do so”
Solidarity to all living in avoidable suffering and to those going through or witnessing avoidable suffering in death. Please vote against the Bill & please let's work to find a better way ahead, to end avoidable suffering for all, from cradle to grave.
@threadreaderapp please unroll

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dr Sally Witcher

Dr Sally Witcher Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SalWitcher

Jun 19
Good news @Keir_Starmer @RachelReevesMP! You can raise more than £5bn without implementing #PathwaysToPoverty [autocorrect] or raising taxes. All you need to do is implement Labour’s Manifesto commitment to clamp down on tax legally owed but unpaid. You’re welcome! 🧵 We will modernise HMRC and change the law to tackle tax avoidance. We will increase registration and reporting requirements, strengthen HMRC’s powers, invest in new technology and build capacity within HMRC. This, combined with a renewed focus on tax avoidance by large businesses and the wealthy, will begin to close the tax gap and ensure everyone pays their fair share.
It also says "Labour will address unfairness in the tax system..abolish non-dom status... replacing it with a modern scheme for people genuinely in the country for a short period..end the use of offshore trusts to avoid inheritance tax..."
The total tax gap—the difference between tax legally owed and actually paid—is estimated at £39.8 billion (HMRC 2022–23 data, published mid‑2024). It’s due to a combination of ‘failure to take care’ (errors), error and evasion, and tax avoidance.
Read 15 tweets
Jun 18
I honeslty don't think the public & many politicians in Scotland/ Scottish MPs realise just how devastating this could be for people in Scotland & (any) @scotgov 's ability to exercise devolved power to diverge from Westminster. 🧵
This isn't just about a massive cut to Scotland's budget (the fact it isn't happening right away is irrelevant), but because of how closely intertwined the 2 systems are, with eligibility for devolved benefits contingent on getting reserved ones and vice versa.
So if the PIP assessment is to be how you get Universal Credit additional health/ incapacity payments, how does that work if Adult Disability Payment, Scotland's currently very similar version of PIP is no longer the same?
Read 22 tweets
Jun 14
How can @leicesterliz have the bare-faced cheek to trumpet support for carers while ensuring that hundreds of thousands lose their carers allowance because those they care for lose PIP😡. Increasing the earnings limit for carers allowance is a fat lot of use if you've lost it! 🧵
A 2024 report by Carers UK and the Centre for Care found unpaid carers in the UK provide £184.3 billion worth of care annually—equivalent to funding a second NHS! Personally I think that's more than enough. But not, it seems, for Liz and @RachelReevesMP carersuk.org/reports/valuin…
Social care is in crisis & the UK Govt has kicked reform into the long grass again where it's been repeatedly kicked for many years. Review after review has lead nowhere. And who are the victims of this epic policy failure? Yes, disabled people & their unpaid carers.
Read 4 tweets
Mar 26
1/7 This morning I wrote to the individual who has the honour (he may consider it misfortune!) to be my MP, begging him not to support the proposed cuts to disability benefits. Here's what I said [with a few typos removed! No room to put in Alt text - DM me if needed]. 🧵
2/7 I began by recalling when I chaired the last Labour Govt's Disability Employment Advisory Committee when another 'Pathways to Work' was around, explaining why it & many other such progs don't work as expected, & why it's vital to see it from the employer's perspective. Image
3/7 I agree the situation is unsustainable, that being the soaring rise in sickness & disability due to an NHS on its knees, failure to manage & learn from the pandemic & ongoing devastating health impacts. If you want to reduce the benefits bill, maybe invest in clean air! Image
Read 8 tweets
Mar 25
Let me be even blunter than @danny__kruger. The private sector is driven by profit. To involve them in delivering assisted dying means making it profitable. Will they be set 'kill targets'? Will they be paid bonuses for exceeding them?
When you introduce a profit motive & if there's more profit to be made from killing people than keeping them alive, if you turn the process into a safeguard-free zone with no meaningful oversight, guess what happens.
Maybe investing our tax-payers money on a new privatised death service is what Starmer & co mean by prioritising 'growth' over everything else. Let the bodies of the otherwise unprofitable pile high, if that's what it takes? Didn't Boris Johnson say something similar?
Read 16 tweets
Mar 18
Here's my 1st take on @leicesterliz's statement today on proposals for disability benefits, following weeks of govt scaremongering & demonising sick & disabled people, placing their mental health under intolerable strain at the prospect of losing support they need to survive 🧵
You don't fix a broken system by making it worse. You won't stop soaring disability benefit cost unless you act to stop soaring disability & ill health due to an NHS on its knees, the ongoing consequences of a pandemic let rip, & the scale of health-destroying poverty.
You don’t get very sick & disabled people into work by gaslighting the reality they'll never work & employers will never employ them, & making their lives even harder. Many devastating forms of disability are hidden. It doesn't mean they aren't very very real.
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(