Thread by @yosef69847

Debunking the False Claim: "Jesus Was Not Jewish"

A meme circulating among some Christian Nationalists falsely claims Jesus wasn’t Jewish, citing mistranslations, selective quotes, and fringe theories.

1. Houston Stewart Chamberlain Quote
Claim: Chamberlain asserts that calling Jesus a Jew confuses race and religion or distorts the history of Galilee to favor Jewish narratives.
Debunking:

Chamberlain’s Bias: Houston Stewart Chamberlain was a 19th-century British-German author whose work, Foundations of the Nineteenth Century (1899), is widely regarded as a foundational text for antisemitic and racialist ideologies.

His views are not grounded in historical scholarship but in anti-Jewish propaganda that influenced later extremist movements, including Nazism.

Historical Context:

Jesus was born in Bethlehem, raised in Nazareth (Galilee), and lived in a Jewish cultural and religious context.

The Gospels (e.g., Matthew 1:1-17, Luke 3:23-38) trace his genealogy to King David, a central figure in Jewish history, explicitly identifying him as a Jew by descent and religious practice.

Race vs. Religion Misrepresentation: In Jesus’ time, "Jewish" referred to both ethnic descent (from the tribes of Israel, particularly Judah) and adherence to the religious practices of Judaism.

Jesus was both ethnically Jewish (from the tribe of Judah) and religiously Jewish, as evidenced by his participation in Jewish rituals like Passover (Luke 2:41-42, John 2:13) and teaching in synagogues (Luke 4:16-21).

Galilee’s Jewish Identity: Galilee was a predominantly Jewish region in the Second Temple period, as confirmed by archaeological evidence (e.g., synagogues, mikvahs) and historical sources like Josephus, a 1st-century Jewish historian.

Chamberlain’s claim about Galilee’s history is a distortion, falsely implying it was non-Jewish to distance Jesus from Jewish identity.
Conclusion:

Chamberlain’s quote is not a credible historical argument but a reflection of his antisemitic agenda, contradicted by both biblical and secular evidence.

2. John 7:1 Quote
Claim: The verse states Jesus avoided "Jewry" (Judea) because "the Jews sought to kill him," implying he was not Jewish or was opposed to Jews.

Debunking:
Context of John 7:1: The Gospel of John uses "the Jews" (Greek: Ioudaioi) to refer specifically to the religious authorities in Judea (e.g., Pharisees, Sadducees) who opposed Jesus, not to Jews as a whole.

This is a narrative device, not an ethnic or religious rejection of Jewish identity. Jesus himself is identified as a Jew in John 4:9 by the Samaritan woman.

Translation Note: The King James Version’s use of "Jewry" for Judea is an archaic rendering of the Greek Ioudaia, meaning the region of Judea, not a separate ethnic or religious category. Modern translations (e.g., NIV, ESV) clarify this by using "Judea."

Jesus’ Jewish Identity in John: The Gospel of John affirms Jesus’ Jewishness. For example, in John 4:22, Jesus says, “Salvation is from the Jews,” affirming the Jewish roots of his mission.

His avoidance of Judea was a tactical decision due to threats from specific authorities, not a rejection of his Jewish identity.

Historical Setting: Tensions between Galilean Jews (like Jesus) and Judean authorities were common due to regional and political differences, but this does not negate Jesus’ Jewish ethnicity or religious practice.

Conclusion: The verse is misrepresented to suggest Jesus was not Jewish, ignoring its context and the broader narrative of the Gospel, which consistently portrays Jesus as a Jew.

3. "Jew" as a Mistranslation of Ioudaios
Claim: The term "Jew" is a 17th-century mistranslation of Ioudaios, which means "Judean," not "Jew."

Jesus was a Judahite (descendant of Judah) and Judean (resident of Judea), but not a Jew, as modern Jews allegedly descend from Esau, not Jacob/Israel.

Debunking:

Meaning of Ioudaios: In the New Testament, Ioudaios (plural: Ioudaioi) refers to people of Jewish ethnicity and/or adherents of Judaism, often translated as "Jew" or "Judean" depending on context.

In Jesus’ time, it encompassed both those from Judea and Jews broadly (e.g., Galilean Jews like Jesus.

@threadreaderapp unroll