BREAKING: The BBC.
Fresh from the self flagellating report into Greg Wallace, the BBC said it had breached its own editorial guidelines by using the son of a Hamas official as the narrator for a documentary on Gaza.
👇🏼🧵
While it said it had found no undue influence from the boy - the son of a Hamas official - from his parents - it had paid his sister nearly £800 of our money.
Three people at the production company knew his dad was. The question is why didn’t the BBC know? Did they ask enough times? There are several executives in the firing line
The BBC also said that it should not have used a child as a narrator, especially one who used words from a script as if they were his own words.
And please let’s not forget the many different BBC staff members who demanded the video was reinstated even though it was clear guidelines had been breached.
The BBC has apparently had this report for some weeks and it has been going backwards and forwards over language used. This is why the BBC should not have been allowed to mark its own homework.
Many are already describing this report - that has taken months to come out - to me as a ‘whitewash’ and say that the BBC should not have been allowed to mark its own homework.
Meanwhile the corporation is saying it may even rerelease a version of the documentary on the iPlayer.
This to me hints at the huge internal divisions going on at the BBC.
When the scandal was first uncovered by @mishtal, BBC chairman Samir Shah described it as a ‘dagger to the heart’ of BBC impartiality.
@mishtal Tim Davie will be in front of a Parliamentary Committee tomorrow who will demand answers about the barrage of failings we have recently seen from the corporation.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Two politicians from opposite sides of the political spectrum - @LordJohnMann and @PennyMordaunt admit to behind ‘stunned’ by the normalisation of antisemitism they encountered for their report which took them six months to compile.
This is what they say:
👇🏼🧵
They found it in the arts and the universities:
‘What are we meant to say as hardened politicians to a young Jewish female performer who told us that following October 7 venues and promoters, who the artist had worked with for years, no longer wanted to engage with her? Or to students who saw their research staff members coming from an encampment with a megaphone, and disabilities liaison staff members who Jewish student’s trust with their health records shouting for an Intifada?’
They founded it embedded in professional bodies:
‘We were told about the experience of a Jewish member of a professional body describe that body as taking years to investigate incidents of anti-Semitism, and heavily editing articles about anti-Semitism and the Jewish experience so as not to cause “offence” to its to broader membership.’
A few weeks ago I wrote about antisemitism in the music industry.
It feels pertinent to revisit it after yesterday.
This is a snapshot of what I found:
1) One Israeli musician was kidnapped because of his ethnicity. Really. Earlier this year two men were jailed for luring Ishtay Kashti to a farmhouse in Wales to keep him hostage.
He told me:
“Even the police weren’t able to tell me where this thing started but it seems that someone who worked with me or knew of me had given them my name,” he says. “I believe it was probably a product of a heated debate. I had a lot of friends in the music industry who were posting about the war and against Israel and I was responding to them.’
2) The British band Oi Va Voi had two UK gigs cancelled because they had an Israeli singer whose record cover featured her naked in a watermelon field.
3) Radiohead star Jonny Greenwood had UK gigs cancelled because he was appearing with Dudu Tassa, one of Israel’s leading rock stars, after threats from pro-Palestinian activists. In a letter, they said: “Forcing musicians not to perform and denying people who want to hear them an opportunity l to do so is self-evidently a method of censorship. Intimidating venues into pulling our shows won’t help achieve the peace and justice everyone in the Middle East deserves.”
Small thread on what happened at Glastonbury today:
A few weeks ago a music source told me that Glastonbury was in a bind: dozens of acts had threatened to pull out if Kneecap was taken off the line-up due to the terrorism charge for allegedly wearing a Hezbollah scarf.
Thread 👇🏼
I spoke to a young journalist at the Mail, @SabriSun_Miller and we agreed to work on it together as it was basically going to mean some leg work in terms of asking every act.
Within a few hours Sabrina had her first response. A band attacking her for daring to write the letter asking them. A day or two later, I had a similar attack. And then the two of us were ‘featured’ in a blog calling us out as Zionists. Yup, we both believe that a country filled with 8 million Jews deserves to survive.
If you want to have an idea about how antisemitism in the form of antizionism has infiltrated our institutions, I give you a talk at the Royal College of Psychiatrists @rcpsych from Wales today.
Really.
In this first slide we see that suicide bombings fall under ‘resistance’ while Zionism is simply ‘colonisation and occupation’.
In some ways the second slide is worse.
Especially when it says ‘call out the dangers of weaponising trauma and other efforts to silence suffering and discrimination.’
This is PSYCHIATRISTS being told to ignore the trauma of Jewish people.
What I would like to know is how any Jewish person can be safe visiting a psychiatrist (a science created by a Jewish man) if they are feeling traumatised by what’s going on - as almost every Jew I know is.
@rcpsych is this really acceptable? Is this inclusive? Because it looks deeply one sided and discriminatory to me.
Every day we see stories about death and pandemonium around food in Gaza so this is a little bit about what I know through interviewing a Gazan via Zoom/ speaking to Israelis and reading.
👇🏼🧵
The Americans have set up an agency called the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation
with the backing of the IDF who work at a distance from them.
The GHF on the ground is mainly made up of American ex servicemen etc and people from Gaza.
Hamas is very keen that this aid system does not work. This is because Hamas creams off the humanitarian aid provided by UN and other humanitarian bodies such as UNRWA and the World Food Programme.
It stores some of it in the warehouses for their fighters (now often teenagers) and their families and also sells it for a huge profit in the markets.
Excellent investigation by the Times’ Matt Dathan about an antisemitic and antiZionist leader of the civil service’s Muslim Network.
These claims were initially investigated and dismissed by Whitehall mandarins after some members of the Network blew the whistle - which is chilling in itself.
But now the Times has the videos:
👇🏼
The videos show one individual in particular, civil servant Sami Rahman using the antisemitic trope that the ‘Zionist lobby’ had an ‘insidious influence’ on British politics.
He also spread a conspiracy that British and American forces had ground troops in Gaza.