1/ NEW: trans identification is in free fall among the young
(h/t @FIRE data in particular)
2/ Non-conforming sexual identity (queer, questioning, etc) is also in sharp decline.
Gay and lesbian are stable while heterosexuality has rebounded by around 10 points since 2023.
3/ Not only this, but freshmen in 2024-25 were less trans and queer than seniors whereas it was the reverse when BTQ+ identity was surging in 2022-23.
This suggests that gender/sexual non-conformity will continue to fall.
4/ What explains the sudden reversal of trans and queer? It’s not because the kids became less woke, more religious or more conservative.
Those beliefs remained stable throughout the 2020s.
5/ Is it improved mental health? Yes, in part. Less anxious and, especially, depressed, students is linked with a smaller share identifying as trans, queer or bisexual.
6/ But not entirely. Mental illness fell after the pandemic but the sexuality and gender shifts happened at least a year later.
All groups, including LGBT, got less mentally ill after the pandemic.
7/ The decline in anxiety and depression occurred within trans, bisexual and queer groups as much as among others. So it wasn’t the case that most of those who solved their emotional problems became heterosexual.
8/ The fall of trans and queer seems most similar to the fading of a fashion or trend. It happened largely independently of shifts in political beliefs and social media use, though improved mental health played a role.
1/ NEW: Announcing the Buckingham Manifesto for a Post-Progressive Social Science
Just released at @chronicle
Signatories span the range from anti-Trump liberals (i.e. @sapinker @clairlemon) to conservative reformers (i.e. @realchrisrufo @GadSaad)
A new intellectual movement
2/ This is an intellectual manifesto, not a policy statement. A high cultural and research agenda for a post-progressive age. One that gets beyond the cultural left worldview that has dominated western intellectual life for the past 60 years.
3/ The Manifesto springs from a conference held at @UniOfBuckingham in June, and signatories all spoke there (nearly all those in the picture signed)
1/ We are entering a post-progressive era. The cultural left-liberalism which emerged a century ago and took off in the late 1960s is exhausted. This ‘vibe shift’doesn’t just repudiate the last decade, but the last 60 years. My latest @WSJ
2/ Ideas are often downstream of events, rather than the reverse. The origins of postmodernism and critical theory lie in decolonization, Civil Rights and the ‘new social movements’ of minorities, feminists and gays.
3/ As with postmodernism, events spurred post-progressivism: the illiberalism and irrationality of cancel culture & transactivism, endemic populism and polarization, family and community breakdown (including birthrate collapse)
1/ Trump's power trip is weakening national populism worldwide. Why?
2/ Right populism is essentially CULTURAL nationalism: a desire to defend national traditions against left-liberal extremism (i.e. on immigration, history, the sex binary, or censorship)
3/ Trump, after promising cultural nationalist actions on DEI & immigration, has pivoted to POLITICAL nationalism: breast-beating aggression toward allies like Canada and Europe, imposing tariffs, disrespecting Ukrainian heroism
1/ Authors of a pro-DEI paper published in Nature and reported in Science made critical errors which nullify their findings. Not only did they bury inconvenient findings, they reported junk results.
2/ First, they found that Black and Hispanic scholars have far fewer cited published works than White and Asian scholars but did not report this.
3/ Women are also less productive than men. What we see is that the race gap is found mainly among men (decline slope of blue line), with little difference between races among female scholars (flat red line). This model controls for discipline and years in academia.
1/ Woke won’t fade away because it is rooted in left-liberalism, the basis of modern western culture.
A thread on my new book Taboo (The Third Awokening in North America), released today:
2/ Woke is a useful analytical concept that describes a distinct phenomenon in the world: the making sacred of historically marginalized race, gender and sexual minority groups. Woke people are emotionally attached to minorities and cold toward majorities.
3/ Despite firms cutting back on DEI and less talk of ‘white privilege’ in the media, woke cultural socialism is not going away. Why? Because young people are a lot more woke. In 20 years they will be the median voter. Generational turnover will mainstream woke.
2/ Canadian attitudes average within 0.3 of a percent of British attitudes (across 30 items) and 1 percent of American attitudes (13 items), despite surveys conducted 1-2 years apart, with different samples and firms!
3/ Like Americans and Brits, of those with an opinion, around 8 in 10 Canadians say ‘political correctness has gone too far’. 61% say they can’t express political views because others may be offended, 55% feel less free to express views on immigration than 5 years ago.